Algorithmic Idealism I: Reconceptualizing Reality Through Information and Experience

Krzysztof Sienicki · 2024

Read Algorithmic Idealism I: Reconceptualizing Reality Through Information and Experience by Krzysztof Sienicki (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-20485.txt.

Description

Abstract Algorithmic idealism represents a transformative approach to understanding reality, emphasizing the informational structure of self-states and their algorithmic transitions over traditional notions of an external, objective universe. Rooted in algorithmic information theory, it redefines reality as a sequence of self-state transitions governed by principles such as Solomonoff induction.

Catalog record

CREATORKrzysztof Sienicki
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-20485

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Algorithmic Idealism I: Reconceptualizing Reality Through Information and Experience Krzysztof Sienicki Abstract Algorithmic idealism represents a transformative approach to understanding reality, emphasizing the informational structure of self-states and their algorithmic transitions over traditional notions of an external, objective universe. Rooted in algorithmic information theory, it redefines reality as a sequence of self-state transitions governed by principles such as Solomonoff induction. This framework offers a unified solution to longstanding challenges in quantum mechanics, cosmology, and metaphysics, addressing issues like the measurement problem, the Boltzmann brain paradox, and the simulation hypothesis. Algorithmic idealism shifts the focus from describing an independent external world to understanding first-person experiences, providing epistemic interpretations of physical theories and dissolving metaphysical divides between ”real” and simulated realities. Beyond resolving these conceptual challenges, it raises profound ethical questions regarding the continuity, duplication, and termination of informational entities, reshaping discussions on identity, consciousness, and existence in the digital and quantum age. By offering a mathematically rigorous yet philosophically innovative framework, algorithmic idealism invites a rethinking of reality as an emergent property of informational dynamics rather than a static external construct. 1 Introduction In the quest to understand the nature of reality, physics and philosophy have long wrestled with two fundamental questions: what defines the ”world,” and how do humans fit into it? Traditional physics, rooted in the principles of realism, assumes that physical theories describe the objective and external properties of the universe. However, this paradigm encounters significant challenges when addressing phenomena such as quantum mechanics, paradoxes like Wigner’s friend [ 1 ] , the Boltzmann Brain problem [ 2 ] , and thought experiments involving consciousness, duplication, and simulated realities. Markus P. Müller’s work [ 4 ] introduces a novel framework, Algorithmic Idealism, that seeks to address these issues by redefining the conceptual foundations of reality. By focusing on first-person experiences rather than external realities, algorithmic idealism proposes a conceptual and mathematical framework that blends elements of quantum physics [ 6 ] [ 7 ] , algorithmic information theory (AIT) [ 5 ] , and epistemology. This article critically examines the core tenets, philosophical implications, strengths, and limitations of algorithmic idealism. Physics traditionally aims to describe the objective world through universal laws and properties that exist independently of observers. This approach, rooted in scientific realism, has provided a coherent understanding of the universe through models such as classical mechanics, relativity, and quantum physics. However, cracks appear when realism confronts the counterintuitive nature of quantum mechanics. For instance, the wave function in quantum theory is not directly observable; instead, it represents probabilities for measurement outcomes. Interpretations like the Copenhagen or Many-Worlds interpretations [ 8 ] attempt to reconcile this with realism, but lingering questions persist, such as the problem of measurement and the nonlocality highlighted by Bell’s theorem. [ 9 ] Beyond quantum mechanics, paradoxes like the Boltzmann brain problem and simulation hypothesis expose the limits of realism. The Boltzmann brain problem [ 10 ] questions how we can trust our perception of reality if the universe is vast enough to produce random, self-aware structures with false memories. [ 11 ] Similarly, the simulation hypothesis challenges the distinction between simulated and ”real” existence. These paradoxes demand a framework that shifts focus from describing the world to understanding how observers experience it. Algorithmic idealism challenges the traditional assumption of an objective world by asking a fundamentally different question [ 4 ] : What should an agent believe they will experience next? This shift from a third-person ontology to a first-person epistemology underpins algorithmic idealism’s conceptual foundation. By introducing a mathematically rigorous framework grounded in algorithmic information theory, algorithmic idealism provides a formal method to address both mundane physical predictions and exotic metaphysical questions. 2 Core Postulates 2.1 The Concept of Self-States in Algorithmic Idealism In the philosophical framework of algorithmic idealism, the notion of a ”self- state” occupies a central position, redefining the way reality is conceptualized. Unlike traditional views of reality that rely on the existence of an objective, external world populated by independent entities, algorithmic idealism shifts the focus to the internal informational structures of agents and the transitions between these structures. A self-state represents the entirety of what defines an agent’s existence at any given moment, providing a radically abstract and generalizable foundation for understanding reality. This idea challenges conventional metaphysics, offering a novel way to reconcile quantum mechanics, philosophical paradoxes, and questions about consciousness and identity. A self-state is best understood as a pattern of information that encodes all the relevant data about an agent at a specific moment. This informational pattern is not tied to physical space or any material substrate; rather, it is abstract and autonomous, existing as a mathematical construct. For a human, for instance, a self-state might encode the neural configurations, sensory inputs, memories, and current thoughts at a given instant. For an artificial intelligence or computational process, it could represent the state of its memory, algorithms, and inputs. This abstraction means that self-states are not bound by traditional notions of physical location or embedding in an external environment. Instead, they are standalone entities, defined entirely by their informational content. The transitions between self-states form the backbone of how algorithmic idealism interprets reality. In this framework, reality is not a static entity or an objective external environment; it is the dynamic evolution of self-states. These transitions are governed by principles of algorithmic induction, such as Solomonoff induction [ 12 ] , which predict the likelihood of a future state based on the informational structure of the current state. For example, the probability of transitioning from one self-state to another depends on the algorithmic simplicity or complexity of the new state relative to the current one. Simpler transitions are favored, adhering to the principle of Occam’s razor, which prioritizes explanations with fewer assumptions. This view of self-states as autonomous and self-contained entities leads to profound philosophical implications. Traditional physics embeds agents within a spacetime framework, where they are part of a larger objective reality. Algorithmic idealism, however, eliminates this embedding. The self-state alone defines the agent’s reality, and the transitions between self-states account for the progression of experiences. The laws of physics, which appear as regularities in our observations, are reinterpreted as emergent properties of the algorithmic processes that govern self-state transitions. In this way, the external world is no longer fundamental but arises as a secondary phenomenon from the informational patterns of self-states. This conceptual shift resolves many long standing paradoxes in physics and philosophy. The quantum measurement problem, for instance, finds a natural explanation in this framework. [ 13 ] Rather than interpreting the collapse of the wave function as an external physical process, algorithmic idealism treats it as a transition in the observer’s self-state. [ 4 ] The probabilities encoded in the wave function correspond to the likelihoods of specific self-state transitions, avoiding the need to invoke an external observer-independent reality. Similarly, the Boltzmann brain paradox, which questions the reliability of perceptions in a vast universe filled with random fluctuations, becomes irrelevant. In algorithmic idealism, the concept of ”self-location” in an external universe is meaningless; the agent’s self-state alone determines its experiences. The simulation hypothesis also finds a straightforward resolution. The distinction between ”real” and simulated realities dissolves, as both are

Read the complete text