Functorial, operadic and modular operadic combinatorics of circuit algebras
Sophie Raynor · 2024
Read Functorial, operadic and modular operadic combinatorics of circuit algebras by Sophie Raynor (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-20260.txt.
Description
Abstract . Circuit algebras are a symmetric analogue of Jones’s planar algebras introduced to study finite-type invariants of virtual knotted objects. Circuit algebra structures appear, in different forms, across mathematics. This paper provides a dictionary for translating between their diverse incarnations and describing their wider context.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sophie Raynor |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 166 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-20260
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Functorial, operadic and modular operadic combinatorics of circuit algebras Thanks: The author acknowledges the support of Australian Research Council grants DP160101519 and FT160100393. Sophie Raynor Abstract . Circuit algebras are a symmetric analogue of Jones’s planar algebras introduced to study finite-type invariants of virtual knotted objects. Circuit algebra structures appear, in different forms, across mathematics. This paper provides a dictionary for translating between their diverse incarnations and describing their wider context. A formal definition of a broad class of circuit algebras is established and three equivalent descriptions of circuit algebras are provided: in terms of operads of wiring diagrams, modular operads and categories of Brauer diagrams. As an application, circuit algebra characterisations of algebras over the orthogonal and symplectic groups are given. 1. Introduction Circuit algebras are a symmetric version of Jones’s planar algebras [ 22 ] . Their basic data consists of a graded monoid equipped with a contraction (or trace) operation and a levelwise symmetric action. They were introduced by Bar-Natan and Dansco [ 2 ] as a framework for relating local and global features of virtual tangles in the study of finite-type invariants (see also [ 8 , 21 , 47 ] ). Recently, Dancso, Halacheva and Robertson have shown [ 9 ] that oriented circuit algebras are equivalent to wheeled props [ 33 , 35 ] , and used this to describe the graded Kashiwara-Vergne and Grothendieck-Teichmüller groups \mathrm{KRV} and \mathrm{GRT} as automorphism groups of circuit algebras [ 10 ] . Though the term “circuit algebra” is not commonly used outside quantum topology, circuit algebra structures appear in different guises widely across mathematics. This paper defines a broad class of circuit algebras – including wheeled props – and explains how they may be equivalently characterised as algebras over an operad, as monoidal functors, and as modular operads with an extra operation. Theorem 1.1 ( 4.12 & 5.11 ) . A circuit algebra is, equivalently (1) an algebra over an operad of wiring diagrams, (2) a symmetric lax monoidal functor from a category of Brauer diagrams, (3) a modular operad equipped with an additional graded product. To my knowledge, this is the first time that these perspectives (though not new) have been explicitly stated and compared, together in one work and in such generality. Each description relates to structures that arise in different areas of mathematics, so 1.1 provides a dictionary for translating results between these contexts. Moreover, the categorical and operadic structures underlying each version may be generalised (and specialised) in distinct ways, thereby precisely locating circuit algebras within a diverse zoo of related concepts (see Table 1 for a partial overview). As an application of this combined approach, and building on [ 11 ] , the following theorem, providing a circuit algebra characterisation of algebras over the orthogonal and symplectic groups, is proved: Theorem 1.2 ( 6.3 ) . The category of algebras over the d -dimensional orthogonal (respectively symplectic) group is equivalent to a subcategory of circuit algebras that satisfy two simple relations. In their original low-dimensional topology and quantum algebra context (first in [ 2 ] , then e.g., [ 8 , 21 , 47 ] ), circuit algebras are defined as algebras over operads of wiring diagrams (see e.g., [ 9 , 10 ] ). Different flavours of circuit algebras – including nonoriented [ 36 ] , oriented (wheeled props), and mixed – are described by different “coloured” operads of wiring diagrams (see Section 3.2 and 4.8 ). This also gives an alternative proof that oriented circuit algebras are wheeled props (see 4.13 ). For any given colouring, several important generalisations of circuit algebras arise as algebras over suboperads of wiring diagrams. The columns of Table 1 are indexed by structures – including (coloured) planar algebras [ 22 ] and modular operads [ 15 , 19 , 37 , 38 ] – obtained this way. Rows (2)-(3) describe the operads and categories governing these in the sense of 1.1 . 1 Structure Circuit algebras (CAs) Nonunital (or downward) CAs Modular operads Planar algebras Special cases: Oriented Wheeled props, [ 9 ] (see e.g., [ 33 , 11 ] ) Nonunital wheeled props (see e.g., [ 45 ] ) Wheeled properads (see e.g., [ 18 ] ) 2 Governing operad Wiring diagrams (WDs) downward WDs (Koszul [ 27 , 45 ] ) connected WDs planar diagrams 3 Classifying category Brauer diagrams (BDs) downward BDs (cospans, Remark 3.12 ) Temperley-Lieb diagrams 4 Rep. theory (Sections 3.3 & 6.1 ) (Sections 3.3 & 6.2 ) (See CA column) nonoriented mono. O_{d},\ Sp_{d} O_{\infty},Sp_{\infty} [ 41 ] (quantum SU_{2} ) oriented mono. GL_{d} [ 11 ] GL_{\infty} [ 41 ] 5 Monad in [ 38 ] \mathbb{L}\mathbb{D}\mathbb{T} \mathbb{L}\mathbb{T} (has arities [ 38 ] ) \mathbb{D}\mathbb{T} Table 1. Comparison of circuit algebras and generalisations obtained from suboperads of wiring diagrams: The subcategories of Brauer diagrams in Row 3, like the operads in Row 2, are dependent on colouring. Modular operads cannot be described as functors from categories of Brauer diagrams. Row 4 indicates (dimension parameter dependent) groups that are related by Schur-Weyl duality to (sub)categories of monochrome (non)oriented Brauer diagrams. The planar case is not studied in this work. Row 5 refers to the (colouring-independent) monads described in [ 38 ] . Statements (1) & (2) of 1.1 are already implicit in the original definition of circuit algebras [ 2 ] . Their equivalence is a formal consequence of the definition, in Section 4.2 , of operads of wiring diagrams in terms of a “category of Brauer diagrams” (or “Brauer category”, c.f. 3.1 ). Such diagrams have been widely studied since Brauer’s 1937 paper [ 5 ] extending Schur-Weyl duality to representations of the finite dimensional orthogonal and symplectic groups (see e.g., [ 51 , 28 ] ). More recently, categories of Brauer diagrams have been used to simultaneously study systems of related representations [ 30 , 40 , 41 , 42 ] . So, Statement (2) of 1.1 implies a link between circuit algebras and classical themes in representation theory. However, the proof of 1.2 in Section 6 does not explicitly use these methods. Instead, since wheeled props are equivalent to oriented circuit algebras, 1.2 is proved by adapting Derksen and Makam’s invariant-theoretic approach to wheeled props [ 11 ] from the oriented, to the unoriented case (see Section 6 ). The final characterisation (3) in 1.1 describes circuit algebras as modular operads equipped with an extra product operation. Modular operads were first introduced in [ 15 ] to study moduli spaces of higher genus curves. General unital modular operads, as in [ 19 , 20 , 37 ] , may be obtained from 1.1 , (1) by restricting to a suboperad of connected wiring diagrams. Unlike the restriction to planar diagrams, which respects the categorical structure (in the sense of 4.6 ), this is a purely operadic construction and admits no categorical description in terms of Brauer diagrams. This paper is one a pair that, together, provide a detailed conceptual and technical account of circuit algebra combinatorics. In the companion paper [ 38 ] , I use the modular operadic perspective to build on the results of [ 37 ] and construct a monad and