Can solvents tie knots? Helical folds of biopolymers in liquid environments.
Rhoslyn Coles, Myfanwy E. Evans · 2024
Read Can solvents tie knots? Helical folds of biopolymers in liquid environments. by Rhoslyn Coles, Myfanwy E. Evans (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-20181.txt.
Description
Abstract Helices are the quintessential geometric motif of the microscale, from α \alpha –helices in proteins to double helices in DNA. Assembly of the helical biopolymers is a foundational step in a hierarchy of structure that leads to biological activity. By simulating folding in a simplified setting we probe the role of the solvent in the collaborative processes governing biomaterials.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rhoslyn Coles, Myfanwy E. Evans |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-20181
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Can solvents tie knots? Helical folds of biopolymers in liquid environments. Rhoslyn Coles, Myfanwy E. Evans Abstract Helices are the quintessential geometric motif of the microscale, from α \alpha –helices in proteins to double helices in DNA. Assembly of the helical biopolymers is a foundational step in a hierarchy of structure that leads to biological activity. By simulating folding in a simplified setting we probe the role of the solvent in the collaborative processes governing biomaterials. Using a simulation technique based on the morphometric approach to solvation, we performed computer experiments in which a short, flexible tube—modelling a biopolymer in an aqueous environment—folds solely based on the interaction of the tube with the solvent. Our findings reveal a variety of helical structures that assemble depending on solvent conditions, including overhand knots and symmetric double helices. By differentiating the role of solvation, our work illuminates the environment of all soluble biomolecules, demonstrating that the solvent can drive fundamental rearrangements, even up to tying a simple overhand knot. keywords folding, helix, solvation, helical folds, geometric simulation, knots, biopolymers 1 Introduction Solvation, the physics of molecules in fluids, is the collection of spontaneous processes resulting in the energetically favourable (re)arrangement of the molecule within the fluid. Solvation is one of the key mechanisms through which the aqueous environment of soluble biomolecules, such as proteins and nucleic acids, affects their structure, stability and functioning Y. & J.., 2006 ; Ball, 2008 ; Privalov & Crane-Robinson, 2017 . At a fundamental level, the solvent mediates between chemistry and structure, as a chaperon to other more concrete processes. The capacity of the solvent by itself receives little attention; the water surrounding is arguably the most challenging part of the modelling of a soluble biomolecule and therefore the development of accurate yet computationally efficient models is of central importance Onufriev & Izadi, 2018 . Details tend to be on the atomic level, specific to a particular protein, and do not address the behaviour of a general soluble polymer in a general solvent. Biopolymer chains wind themselves into a plethora of shapes in nature. The optimal \alpha -helix and \beta -sheet forms are the fundamental motifs found in protein structures. DNA, itself a double helix, can exhibit a variety of geometric forms, which helps to expose certain base pairs along the strand Irobalieva et al., 2015 . Knotted configurations are found in biopolymers in wide variety of settings, where their geometric form is related to their functionality Marenduzzo et al., 2009 ; Shakhnovich, 2011 . The broader zoo of optimal shapes of short flexible biopolymers (see Fig. 1 ), and their contribution to biological function, is a rich field of research. From this broader perspective, we investigate how a fluid environment may affect the shape of a short tube–like string. Understanding form through experimentation with simple geometric objects under physically motivated constraints provides interesting insights; our optimal forms contain helical motifs known for their optimal packing upon confinement Maritan et al., 2000 ; Chiara et al., 2008 , and our results establish the thermodynamic stability of the overhand knot and double helix in solution. Modelling the effect of the solvent on the structure of large (polyatomic) biomolecules like globular proteins is challenging: A protein’s configuration is governed by a fine balance between intramolecular bonding energy and the free energy of solvation of the fluid system Dobson, 2003 ; Salvi & De, 2003 . Whilst including the solvent explicitly in state models may enable a more complete picture of the solvent–solute interaction, the additional computational cost means there is little possibility to explore complex solute geometries let alone solvent induced shape change Y. & J.., 2006 . These difficulties motivate the development of implicit solvent models, which treat the solvent as a continuous medium, with application in molecular dynamics simulations to efficiently simulate biomolecules like proteins and nucleic acids in solution Onufriev & Case, 2019 ; Roux & Simonson, 1999 . Implicit solvent models make use of the geometric properties of the space occupied by the solute within the liquid in order to compute the free energy of the liquid Edelsbrunner & Koehl, 2005 . Of interest therefore is the space-filling representation of a molecule or solute expanded by the solvent’s radius, known as the solvent-accessible surface Lee & Richards, 1971 . Early solvation free energy models were often based on the volume excluded by this surface which has an entropic cost to the energy Simonson & Bruenger, 1994 ; Lum et al., 1990 , as well as the surface area Banavar et al., 2007 ; Ooi et al., 1987 ; Eisenberg & McLachlan, 1986 . Figure 1: Helical forms of a flexible tube, relevant to biopolymer foldings. Clockwise from top left, an overhand knot, the optimal helix, a compact structure with curve motifs arranged in parallel, and a double helix folded back on itself. This link between geometry and the thermodynamics of fluids was made more precise through the development of the morphometric approach to modelling solvation Mecke, 1996 ; Roth et al., 2006 ; König et al., 2004 . In this approach the solvation free energy, \mathbf{F}_{\mathrm{sol}} in ( 1 ), is given as a linear sum of the basic rigid motion invariant valuations, the volume \mathrm{V} , surface area \mathrm{A} and two further measures of curvature \mathrm{C} and \mathrm{X} , of the body bounded by the solvent accessible surface ( \mathcal{B} ). The thermodynamic coefficients coupling to the geometric measures are \mathrm{p}>0 the fluid pressure, \sigma<0 the planar surface tension and \kappa , \bar{\kappa}\in\mathbb{R} for which there is no physical interpretation König et al., 2004 ; Roth et al., 2006 ; Hadwiger, 1957 . \mathbf{F}_{\mathrm{sol}}=\mathrm{p}\mathrm{V}(\mathcal{B})+\sigma\mathrm{A}(\mathcal{B})+\kappa\mathrm{C}(\mathcal{B})+\bar{\kappa}\mathrm{X}(\mathcal{B})\,. (1) These four geometric functions, the measures of curvature , appear as a novel application of Hadwiger’s characterisation theorem of integral geometry Hadwiger, 1957 . The measures \mathrm{C} and \mathrm{X} are computed as the mean and Gaussian curvatures integrated over the boundary of \mathcal{B} provided sufficient regularity allows an interpretation of these curvature functions M., 1986 . By the Gauss–Bonnet theorem \mathrm{X}=4\pi\chi where \chi is the Euler characteristic. The real advantage of this approach is that it (de)couples physics and geometry in a computationally convenient manner. The thermodynamic coefficients \mathrm{p} , \sigma , \kappa and \bar{\kappa} depend only the physical properties of the fluid, like temperature and the chemical coupling between the solvent and solute, not on the shape of the solute. These can be determined by fitting free energy values as obtained from ( 1 ) to those computed from solvent models of the statistical–mechanical theory, as tested with simple solute geometries. Once the coefficients are given, the free energy is evaluated from the geometry of \mathcal{B} . If \mathcal{B} is modelled as a union of balls, results from computational topology lead to the development of fast algorithms which evaluate \mathrm{V}(\mathcal{B}) , \mathrm{A}(\mathcal{B}) , \mathrm{C}(\mathcal{B}) and \mathrm{X}(\mathcal{B}) exactly and efficiently, fairly independently of the shape Edelsbrunner, 1995 ; Edelsbrunner & Koehl, 2005 . For fluid systems like that of a protein within the aqueous environment of the cell, the morphometric approach can compute free energy values of complex solute geometries in excellent agreement with the classical theory at a fraction of the computational cost, making a geometric centered investigation of