Revisiting the Bohr Model of the Atom through Brownian Motion of the Electron
Vasil Yordanov · 2024
Read Revisiting the Bohr Model of the Atom through Brownian Motion of the Electron by Vasil Yordanov (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-19918.txt.
Introduction
Could the electron in an atom be a jittering particle rather than a wave, and still give quantum answers? Vasil Yordanov revisits the old Bohr model in a solo 2024 paper, treating the electron's path as Brownian motion steered by an optimal control law.
The electron's position is random, its density obeying a diffusion equation, and the path carries one drift for each direction of time. A control principle chooses the forward drift step by step to minimize a time-symmetric energy cost. The coupled equations that result collapse into the Schrödinger equation itself. Simulations of hydrogen states reproduce the standard energy averages, and excited states swirl at the predicted rate. The old picture, reframed, survives.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Vasil Yordanov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 107 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-19918
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Revisiting the Bohr Model of the Atom through Brownian Motion of the Electron Vasil Yordanov Abstract We revisit the Bohr model of the atom through Brownian motion of the electron and the principles of stochastic optimal control. The electron is assumed to have a definite but random position, represented by a single real-valued stochastic process in physical space whose probability density obeys the Fokker–Planck equation. Because Brownian paths are not differentiable, the process carries two mean drifts, one for each direction of time. We treat the forward drift as the control field, while the backward drift is fixed by the density of the same process. The running cost of the control problem combines the two drifts into a time-symmetric kinetic term, and through the backward drift it inherits a dependence on the density, so the value becomes a functional on density space. Bellman’s dynamic-programming principle requires the control to minimize the expected action from every intermediate time and density onward. The drift therefore emerges as a feedback law on position and density, rather than from the global stationarity of a stochastic action. The resulting law-dependent HJB–Fokker–Planck system reduces to the Schrödinger equation once the standard single-valuedness condition is imposed on the reconstructed phase. For stationary hydrogen states the theory yields explicit drift fields in spherical coordinates and reproduces the standard radial and angular kinetic-energy averages of the quantum operator formalism. Direct trajectory-level simulations of the electron’s stochastic motion around the nucleus show the coordinate distributions converging to the Born marginals and the time-averaged energies reproducing the quantum expectation values. For the 2 p 2p eigenstates with magnetic quantum number m = ± 1 m=\pm 1 , a phase-driven azimuthal drift makes the simulated trajectories circulate at the analytically predicted rate, and the angular momentum accumulated from the raw trajectory increments converges to exactly L z = m ℏ L_{z}=m\hbar . The angular-momentum quantization postulated in the Bohr model thus reappears as a property of the simulated stochastic motion. 1 Introduction The hydrogen atom was historically the simplest system in which the conflict between classical orbital mechanics and atomic spectra became unavoidable. Thomson’s model [ 1 ] and Rutherford’s nuclear atom [ 2 ] established the basic picture of electrons bound to a central charge, while Bohr’s model [ 3 ] explained the hydrogen spectrum by imposing quantized orbits on an otherwise classical dynamics. Schrödinger’s wave mechanics [ 4 ] replaced these orbits by a wave equation and a probabilistic description. The present paper revisits this transition from a different direction: it asks whether the stationary quantum properties of hydrogen can be represented by a single real stochastic motion of the electron in physical space. We develop such a representation by combining Nelson’s forward–backward stochastic kinematics [ 5 ] with Bellman’s dynamic-programming principle [ 6 ] in a control problem posed on the space of probability densities. This construction determines the forward drift of the electron’s stochastic motion as an optimal feedback field. In Nelson’s framework, the electron’s motion is modeled as a diffusion with coefficient D=\hbar/(2m) . This diffusion admits forward \mathbf{b}_{+} and backward \mathbf{b}_{-} drift fields, associated with its two time directions [ 5 ] . The forward–backward kinematics is essential: the difference between the two drifts is fixed by the probability density of the particle’s position through the osmotic velocity \mathbf{u}=\frac{1}{2}(\mathbf{b}_{+}-\mathbf{b}_{-})=D\,\nabla\!\ln P , while their mean defines the current velocity \mathbf{v}=\frac{1}{2}(\mathbf{b}_{+}+\mathbf{b}_{-}) . Nelson’s theory was subsequently reformulated and extended through stochastic variational methods. Because the present construction is posed on density space, a point of particular relevance is how probability-density evolution enters these variational approaches. Yasue [ 7 ] proposed a time-symmetric stochastic variational formulation of quantum mechanics with the symmetric kinetic Lagrangian \tfrac{1}{2}m(\mathbf{v}^{2}+\mathbf{u}^{2})-V . The stochastic Euler–Lagrange equation is obtained without imposing the Fokker–Planck equation as a variational constraint. The Fokker–Planck equation nevertheless enters Yasue’s treatment of the density evolution and the equivalence with the Schrödinger initial-value problem. Guerra and Morato [ 8 ] introduced a stochastic action principle with the alternative time-symmetric Lagrangian \tfrac{1}{2}m(\mathbf{v}^{2}-\mathbf{u}^{2})-V , which recovers Nelson’s mechanics and yields the Madelung equations [ 9 ] . In their construction, the controlled stochastic differential equation gives an explicit evolution equation for the one-time density, while the transition probability density satisfies the forward Fokker–Planck equation. A variation of the control drift induces corresponding variations of both densities. Pavon developed related variational formulations — in both hydrodynamic [ 10 ] and particle [ 11 ] forms — in which the Madelung equations arise as Hamilton–Jacobi-like equations of a stochastic variational problem. More recently, Yang [ 12 ] proposed a stochastic variational formulation that supplements the least-action principle with constraints based on relative entropy and Fisher information, treating each forward and backward path configuration as a variational degree of freedom. The Fokker–Planck equations are not imposed as variational inputs. A relation obtained from the variation is combined with the forward–backward drift relation, first to obtain the continuity equation and then to rewrite it as the corresponding forward and backward Fokker–Planck equations. The present formulation retains Nelson’s forward–backward description of the electron as a single stochastic process with drifts \mathbf{b}_{+} and \mathbf{b}_{-} . It adds an optimal-control structure by treating \mathbf{b}_{+} as the control field, while \mathbf{b}_{-} is not an independent control: for the same process, it is fixed by \mathbf{b}_{+} and the probability density P through the forward–backward time-reversal relation. We choose the bilinear Lagrangian L=\tfrac{1}{2}m\,\mathbf{b}_{+}\!\cdot\!\mathbf{b}_{-}-V=\tfrac{1}{2}m(\mathbf{v}^{2}-\mathbf{u}^{2})-V as the running cost. Expressing \mathbf{b}_{-} through \mathbf{b}_{+} and P makes this cost depend on the probability law represented by P . The control problem is therefore law-dependent and is posed on density space, with P as the state variable. The Bellman value is consequently a functional \mathcal{V}(t,P) on density space. Bellman’s principle yields the functional HJB equation, and minimization over the forward-drift control field determines the optimal feedback drift. For each admissible forward drift, the controlled stochastic differential equation induces the evolution of P through the forward Fokker–Planck (FP) equation. This density evolution is kinematic and does not follow from Bellman’s principle; accordingly, the chosen time-symmetric cost L neither avoids nor replaces the FP equation. The FP and functional HJB equations together form the coupled HJB–FP system governing the density-space control problem. The present optimal-control formulation differs from the Guerra–Morato–Pavon variational formulations in how optimality is imposed. In those formulations, the dynamics follow from stationarity of a stochastic action under admissible variations over a prescribed time interval. Here, Bellman optimality is recursive: the continuation cost is minimized from every intermediate time and probability density. This law-dependent density-space structure is therefore close to McKean–Vlasov control and dynamic programming on spaces of probability measures [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] . Unlike standard mean-field applications, however, P is here the one-particle density of a single real diffusion, not an empirical density of interacting particles; the law-dependence comes instead from the forward–backward consistency of the same diffusion. The density-space Bellman formulation presented here leads to a local HJB–Fokker–Planck system for J and P . After rewriting this system in terms of the phase S , one obtains the Madelung equations and, after imposing the standard single-valuedness condition on the reconstructed phase [ 20