Solar Gamma-Ray Evidence for a Distinct Population of > > 1 MeV Flare-Accelerated Electrons

Gerald H. Share, Ronald J. Murphy, Brian R. Dennis, Justin D. Finke · 2024

Read Solar Gamma-Ray Evidence for a Distinct Population of > > 1 MeV Flare-Accelerated Electrons by Gerald H. Share, Ronald J. Murphy, Brian R. Dennis, Justin D. Finke (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-19586.txt.

Introduction

Gerald Share, Ronald Murphy, Brian Dennis, and Justin Finke present a 2024 paper on gamma rays from solar flares that point to a distinct group of very fast electrons. Big flares hurl electrons to high energies, and their glow spans X-rays and gamma rays. Telling the parts of that glow apart has been hard.

Better nuclear line models and instruments now let the team split the spectrum cleanly. They fit 25 large flares seen by three missions with two electron glow shapes plus the nuclear lines. One electron shape follows its own time course and comes from a different place in the flare. That hints it springs from a separate acceleration path.

Catalog record

CREATORGerald H. Share, Ronald J. Murphy, Brian R. Dennis, Justin D. Finke
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-19586

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Solar Gamma-Ray Evidence for a Distinct Population of > > 1 MeV Flare-Accelerated Electrons Gerald H. Share, Ronald J. Murphy, Brian R. Dennis, Justin D. Finke Abstract Significant improvements in our understanding of nuclear γ \gamma -ray line production and instrument performance allow us to better characterize the continuum emission from electrons at energies ≳ \gtrsim 300 keV during solar flares. We represent this emission by the sum of a power-law extension of hard X-rays (PL) and a power law times an exponential function (PLexp). We fit the γ \gamma -ray spectra in 25 large flares observed over 40 years with this continuum and the calculated spectra of all known nuclear components. The PLexp is separated spectroscopically from the other components and its presence is required with > > 99% confidence in 18 of the flares. Its distinct origin is suggested by significant differences between its time histories and those of the PL and nuclear components in 18 of the flares. RHESSI imaging/spectroscopy of the 2005 January 20 flare, reveals that the PL and nuclear components come from the footpoints while the PLexp component comes from the corona. While the index and flux of the anisotropic PL component are dependent on the flare’s heliocentric angle, the PLexp parameters do not show comparable dependences with 99.5% confidence. The PLexp spectrum is flat at low energies and rolls over at a few MeV. Such a shape can be produced by thin-target bremsstrahlung from electrons with a spectrum that peaks between 3 – 5 MeV and by inverse Compton scattering of soft X-rays by 10–20 MeV electrons, or by a combination of the two. These electrons can produce radiation detectable at other wavelengths. I Introduction The solar flare \gamma -ray spectrum is produced when high-energy electrons and ions interact in the solar atmosphere. Magnetic reconnection in the corona is widely believed to initiate flares and release the energy to accelerate these particles to relativistic energies in the corona (e.g. Chen et al. 2020 ; Fleishman et al. 2020 ) and onto magnetic loops anchored in the photosphere ( Holman et al. 2011 ; Benz 2017 ) . Bremsstrahlung from non-thermal electrons in the corona and chromosphere dominates the well-studied X-ray spectrum \gtrsim 20 keV ( Dennis 1988 ; Krucker et al. 2008b ; Holman et al. 2011 ; Fletcher et al. 2011 ; White et al. 2011 ; Kontar et al. 2011 ; Kontar et al. 2019 ) and extends into the \gamma -ray energy range where nuclear contributions to the spectrum become important ( Vestrand 1988 ; Vilmer et al. 2011 ) . It was known from the early \gamma -ray measurements in the 1980’s by the Solar Maximum Mission Gamma Ray Spectrometer ( SMM /GRS) that electrons can be accelerated to tens of MeV because their steep \gamma -ray spectrum could be distinguished from the hard \pi -decay spectrum produced by the interaction of > 300 MeV protons deep in the chromosphere ( Forrest et al. 1986 ) . It has been difficult to unambiguously determine the > 300 keV flare emission produced by electrons, primarily because of the nuclear lines and continuum that also contribute to the \gamma -ray spectrum in this energy range. Nuclear \gamma rays were first detected by the OSO-7 spectrometer from the 1972 August 4 flare ( Chupp et al. 1973 ) . Suri et al. 1975 found a residual MeV continuum after subtracting background and solar nuclear lines at 0.5, 1.6, 2.2, 4.4, and 6.1 MeV, and their instrumental continua. However, using the latest nuclear cross sections available at the time, Ramaty et al. 1977 concluded that almost all of the residual MeV radiation was due to the superposition of broad and narrow nuclear lines that were not taken into account by Suri et al. 1975 . The importance of knowing the nuclear contribution in studies of the MeV electron-produced continuum was highlighted by Vestrand 1988 and Shih et al. 2009 , who found a close correlation of > 300 keV electron bremsstrahlung with both nuclear de-excitation and 2.223 neutron-capture line emissions. Ion acceleration appears to accompany relativistic electron acceleration down to the limiting sensitivity of detectors, thus highlighting the requirement for an accurate knowledge of nuclear-line emission in flares. The road to this understanding commenced with the seminal work of Ramaty et al. 1979 and led to the detailed studies of particle acceleration onto magnetic loops ( Hua et al. 1989 ; Murphy et al. 2007 ) , production of the 511-keV positron annihilation line ( Murphy et al. 2005 ; Murphy et al. 2014 ) , broad and narrow nuclear de-excitation lines and unresolved continuum ( Kozlovsky et al. 2002 ; Murphy et al. 2009 ; Murphy et al. 2016 ; Tusnski et al. 2019 ) , neutrons and the 2.223 MeV capture line ( Hua & Lingenfelter 1987 ; Murphy et al. 2012 ) , \pi -decay \gamma -rays ( Murphy et al. 1987 ; MacKinnon et al. 2020 ) , Compton-scattered photons from de-excitation lines and continua ( Murphy & Share 2018 ) , and Compton-scattered photons of 2.223 MeV neutron-capture line \gamma rays (Murphy and Share, manuscript in preparation). The end product of all of this work is an array of nuclear \gamma -ray spectral templates for each of the processes for different ambient and accelerated particle abundances, flare locations, and ion spectral indices. Access to these templates is provided by OSPEX (Object Spectral Executive) 1 1 1 https://hesperia.gsfc.nasa.gov/ssw/packages/spex/doc/ospex_explanation.htm that is available in the SSW IDL software depository 2 2 2 http://www.lmsal.com/solarsoft/ssw_whatitis.html . Using this newly-derived information on nuclear \gamma -ray production, we began a program to fit the time-integrated spectra from 25 intense nuclear-line flares to determine the ambient and accelerated elemental abundances in the plasma where protons and heavier ions interact. It soon became clear that the broken power-law function commonly used in previous studies to represent the electron-generated \gamma -ray continuum was inadequate to fit all of the flare spectra. This was in part due to the fact the continuum rolled over at high energies. We therefore replaced the broken power-law with the sum of two continuum components: a Power Law extension of the hard X-rays to MeV energies (PL) and a hard MeV continuum represented by a flat Power Law times an exponential (PLexp). This more generalized form naturally accommodates spectra that harden in the MeV range, such as power laws that break up, and importantly allows for possibility that it is produced by two different sources, such as the spectrally distinct footpoint and coronal emissions observed in the 2005 January 20 flare ( Krucker et al. 2008a ) . The exponential factor accommodates spectra with rollovers at high energy ( Ellison & Ramaty 1985 ) . This summed continuum was first used in spectral fits to the 2010 June 12 flare observed by Fermi /GBM ( Ackermann et al. 2012 ) and in more recent studies ( Kurt et al. 2017 ; Murphy & Share 2018 ; Lysenko et al. 2019 ) . In this paper we discuss the characteristics of the PLexp continuum in solar flares over three decades of intensity. We present compelling evidence that it is a unique component, distinct from both

Read the complete text