Comparative Performance Analysis of Quantum Machine Learning Architectures for Credit Card Fraud Detection

Mansour El Alami 1 , Nouhaila Innan 2,3 , Muhammad Shafique 2,3 , and Mohamed Bennai 1 · 2024

Read Comparative Performance Analysis of Quantum Machine Learning Architectures for Credit Card Fraud Detection by Mansour El Alami 1 , Nouhaila Innan 2,3 , Muhammad Shafique 2,3 , and Mohamed Bennai 1 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-19441.txt.

Introduction

Mansour El Alami and three co-authors compare quantum machine learning designs for catching credit card fraud in this 2024 arXiv paper. Fraud grows more complex each year, and quantum methods promise sharper tools. The team tested three quantum classifiers on two raw fraud data sets that had not been cleaned into a standard scale.

The three designs differ in how they turn data into quantum states and read the answer out. One design, the variational quantum classifier, did best, with a strong balance of hits and few false alarms. A second design also did well, while the third struggled on the raw data. Tests under five kinds of quantum noise showed the best models held up well. The authors stress that setup choices matter as much as the quantum hardware itself.

Catalog record

CREATORMansour El Alami 1 , Nouhaila Innan 2,3 , Muhammad Shafique 2,3 , and Mohamed Bennai 1
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-19441

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comparative Performance Analysis of Quantum Machine Learning Architectures for Credit Card Fraud Detection Mansour El Alami 1 , Nouhaila Innan 2,3 , Muhammad Shafique 2,3 , and Mohamed Bennai 1 Abstract As financial fraud becomes increasingly complex, effective detection methods are essential. Quantum Machine Learning (QML) introduces certain capabilities that may enhance both accuracy and efficiency in this area. This study examines how different quantum feature map and ansatz configurations affect the performance of three QML-based classifiers—the Variational Quantum Classifier (VQC), the Sampler Quantum Neural Network (SQNN), and the Estimator Quantum Neural Network (EQNN)—when applied to two non-standardized financial fraud datasets. Different quantum feature map and ansatz configurations are evaluated, revealing distinct performance patterns. The VQC consistently demonstrates strong classification results, achieving an F1 score of 0.88, while the SQNN also delivers promising outcomes. In contrast, the EQNN struggles to produce robust results, emphasizing the challenges presented by non-standardized data. These findings highlight the importance of careful model configuration in QML-based financial fraud detection. By showing how specific feature maps and ansatz choices influence predictive success, this work guides researchers and practitioners in refining QML approaches for complex financial applications. I Introduction Credit card fraud represents a pervasive and escalating global threat, costing individuals and organizations billions of dollars each year. For instance, a 2022 UK Finance study reported fraud-related losses of £1.2 billion, with online solicitations accounting for approximately 80% of fraudulent activities [ 1 ] . Similarly, a CNBC report published in 2023 estimated that fraud imposed an $8.8 billion burden on American consumers in 2022 [ 2 ] , while a joint assessment by the European Banking Authority and the European Central Bank indicated that credit card fraud reached 633 million euros in the first half of 2023 [ 3 ] . These escalating figures threaten consumers and financial institutions, contributing to broader economic instability. Conventional fraud detection methods have advanced significantly, yet they face persistent challenges. The increasing volume and complexity of transactional data, the highly imbalanced nature of fraud detection datasets, and the growing need for real-time decision-making continue to strain classical Machine Learning (ML) approaches [ 4 , 5 ] . Quantum Machine Learning (QML) offers a promising avenue to overcome these limitations [ 6 ] , potentially enhancing computational speed, handling complex data distributions more effectively, and improving overall detection accuracy. Moreover, QML has demonstrated success across a wide range of applications—extending from healthcare and finance to climate modeling [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] , materials science [ 10 , 11 ] , and cybersecurity—illustrating its versatility in tackling complex [ 12 ] , data-intensive problems [ 13 , 14 ] . This success largely depends on selecting and optimizing various QML models and architectural configurations designed to employ the unique capabilities of quantum computing [ 15 , 16 , 17 ] . Consequently, developing effective QML-based solutions necessitates a thorough investigation of different model architectures and configurations to identify those that most effectively address the specific challenges of each application domain. In the context of financial fraud detection, this involves analyzing how different QML architectures impact performance metrics such as accuracy, recall, and F1-score, thereby ensuring the development of robust and efficient detection systems [ 18 ] . This study focuses on examining how various QML configurations—specifically, configurations of feature maps and ansatz architectures—influence accuracy, recall, and F1-score when applied to two real-world credit card fraud detection datasets. By evaluating a range of model setups and pinpointing those configurations that achieve the best performance, this work provides valuable insights for designing more effective QML-based fraud detection systems. Ultimately, this analysis contributes to the broader goal of protecting consumers and businesses from increasingly sophisticated financial threats. The contributions of this work can be summarized as follows (as illustrated by the overall methodology in Fig. 1 ): • A comprehensive analysis of three emerging QML models—Variational Quantum Classifier (VQC), Sampler Quantum Neural Network (SQNN), and Estimator Quantum Neural Network (EQNN)—applied to credit card fraud detection tasks. • A thorough empirical evaluation involving two credit card fraud detection datasets, assessing the responses and performance of the QML models. • An in-depth examination of the impact of different feature maps and ansatz configurations on model accuracy and detection capabilities. • Insights into identifying the optimal feature map–ansatz configurations that offer the most effective performance in quantum-enhanced financial fraud detection. Through these contributions, we explain the critical parameters that influence the performance of these QML models and the impact of non-standard financial fraud detection datasets. Fig. 1 : Overview of the proposed methodology. Two benchmark datasets undergo initial preprocessing, after which three QML models are evaluated. Each model is tested with three distinct feature map architectures, and each selected feature map is further assessed using four different ansatz configurations The rest of the paper is structured as follows. In Sec. II , we review the existing literature on classical and QML approaches to financial fraud detection. In Sec. III , we provide the background and the architecture of different feature map and ansatz architectures. In Sec. IV , we describe the QML models employed and the associated circuit constructs. In Sec. V , we present the datasets used, report our experimental results, and highlight the model configurations achieving the highest performance. Finally, in Sec. VI , we conclude by summarizing our findings and discussing potential directions for future work. II Literature Review Classical ML algorithms have been extensively explored for detecting fraudulent credit card transactions. A variety of models, including multivariate logistic regression [ 19 ] , support vector machines [ 20 ] , and random forest classifiers [ 21 , 22 ] , have demonstrated varying degrees of success. More sophisticated approaches integrate intelligent techniques, such as optimized light gradient boosting machine [ 23 ] , as well as deep learning architectures like auto-encoders and restricted Boltzmann machines [ 24 ] , and graphical neural networks [ 25 ] . Despite significant progress in classical approaches, these methods face persistent challenges due to the volume, complexity, and continuously evolving patterns of fraudulent activities. This has motivated interest in QML, which employs quantum properties—including entanglement and superposition—to operate efficiently in high-dimensional feature spaces. As a result, QML has the potential to process large datasets more rapidly, capture complex interactions among transactional features, and express intricate patterns, offering tangible benefits for fraud detection tasks [ 26 , 27 , 28 ] . The emergence of accessible QML tools, such as IBM’s Qiskit and Xanadu’s PennyLane [ 29 , 30 ] , has further accelerated research in this area. Several studies have begun to explore QML solutions for fraud detection. For instance, Liang et al. introduced two quantum anomaly detection algorithms grounded in density estimation and multivariate Gaussian distributions that can be applied to fraudulent transaction identification [ 31 ] . A quantum graph convolutional neural network proposed expanded quantum neural network to graph-structured data [ 32 ] , holding promise for fraud scenarios involving complex relational information. Another study compared quantum kernel-based anomaly detection with classical baselines such as one-class support vector machines, demonstrating the potential of QML in improving detection performance [ 33 ] . Additional research has directly compared quantum-enhanced methods to classical benchmarks.

Read the complete text