Fluid-particle interactions and fluctuation-dissipation relations III - Correlated fluctuations, regularity and added mass

Massimiliano Giona, Giuseppe Procopio, Chiara Pezzotti · 2024

Read Fluid-particle interactions and fluctuation-dissipation relations III - Correlated fluctuations, regularity and added mass by Massimiliano Giona, Giuseppe Procopio, Chiara Pezzotti (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-19170.txt.

Introduction

Massimiliano Giona, Giuseppe Procopio, and Chiara Pezzotti extend fluctuation theory for particles in fluid in a 2024 paper. Classic theory assumes the thermal force on a particle does not depend on its past motion. In liquids, fluid ripples can in fact correlate with that motion. Sound effects and finite stress speeds support relaxing the old assumption.

The authors add correlated noise to their earlier models. The global link between diffusion and friction still holds, they show. Velocity ripples become smooth in time almost everywhere. An added mass also appears from the correlations, at both micro and macro scales. They name that link a fluctuation-inertia relation.

Catalog record

CREATORMassimiliano Giona, Giuseppe Procopio, Chiara Pezzotti
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE76 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-19170

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Fluid-particle interactions and fluctuation-dissipation relations III - Correlated fluctuations, regularity and added mass Massimiliano Giona, Giuseppe Procopio, Chiara Pezzotti Abstract The fluctuation-dissipation theory is grounded on the Langevin condition expressing the local independence between the thermal force and the particle velocity history. Upon hydrodynamic grounds, it is reasonable to relax this condition in order to account for the correlated fluid fluctuations, especially in the case of liquids, consistently with the inclusion of acoustic effects and with the finite speed of propagation of internal shear stresses. We show that the introduction of correlated stochastic processes in the basic fluctuational patterns defined in Giona et al. (2024), preserves the global fluctuation-dissipation relation, connecting diffusivity to the global friction factor, and the resulting velocity fluctuations become almost everywhere smooth functions of time. Moreover, a fluctuational added mass arises as a consequence of correlations. This leads to a fluctuation-inertia relation, connecting the fluctuational added mass at microscale to its occurrence for macroscopic objects. I Introduction In [ 1 ] and [ 2 ] , henceforth referred to as part I and part II, respectively, we have followed the classical Kubo approach to fluctuation-dissipation relations, assuming that the thermal force {\bf R}(t) at time t is uncorrelated to particle velocity at previous time instants, \langle{\bf R}(t)\otimes{\bf v}(0)\rangle=0\,,\qquad t\geq 0 (1) where \otimes indicates the tensor product. This is indeed the Langevin condition [ 3 , 4 ] , that undoubtedly displays analytical advantages, as it provides straightforwardly the evolution equation for the velocity autocorrelation function, and suggests the white-noise nature of the stochastic forcings entering the various fluctuation-dissipation patterns introduced in part I, typically regarded as distributional derivatives of independent Wiener processes. The Langevin condition eq. ( 1 ) and the equipartition relation for the squared variance of the velocity entries at equilibrium \langle v_{i}^{2}\rangle=\frac{k_{B}\,T}{m}\,,\qquad i=1,2,3 (2) where m is the particle mass and T the constant temperature of the fluid medium (coinciding with that of the particle), are the two foundative properties deriving from statistical physics, defining particle velocity fluctuations and characterizing the Kubo fluctuation-dissipation theory. In recent years, stort-time and high-resolution experiments on Brownian particles both in liquids and gases [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] have qualitatively demostrated the correctness of the scaling of the velocity autocorrelation function with time predicted by the Kubo theory, supplementing it with the hydromechanic analysis of the force exterted by the fluid onto the particle including also the fluid-inertial effects, i.e. the Basset force [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] . On the other hand, these experiments have shown that Brownian motion trajectories and velocities at short time scales in Newtonian fluids (water, acetone) are smooth functions of time and more regular than what expected at the Einstein’s times [ 8 , 13 ] . Moreover, deviations from eq. ( 2 ), i.e. from the equipartition result, have been reported [ 14 ] . The latter phenomenon can be attributed hydrodynamically to the added mass effect, that occurs as an instantaneous fluid-inertial contribution in incompressible fluids, proportional to the actual value of the particle acceleration [ 15 , 16 ] . However, as correctly observed by Zwanzig [ 17 ] , this instantaneous effect could be the consequence of the simplified and unphysical assumption of the infinite sound velocity subsumed in the assumption of incompressibility. The analysis performed by Chow and Hermans [ 18 ] , considering a compressible time-dependent Stokes equation for the fluid (i.e., a linear proportionality between pressure and density) supports this thesis. Therefore, the possible occurrence of a non-vanishing added-mass influencing the squared velocity variance, i.e., \langle v_{i}^{2}\rangle=\frac{k_{B}\,T}{m+m_{a}}\,,\qquad i=1,2,3 (3) with m_{a}>0 , instead of eq. ( 2 ), has become a crucial issue both theoretically and experimentally [ 19 ] , with relavant implications in the modeling of hydrodynamics at microscale [ 20 ] , and in the foundations of statistical physics. The inclusion of the “tiny acoustic effects” (i.e. compressibility) to explain the statistical properties of micrometric particles in still fluids (Brownian motion) clearly indicates that the removal of the unphysical assumption of infinite sound velocity determines significant changes in the qualitative statistical properties of the particle velocity fluctuations. In turn, it necessarily implies the occurrence of correlated pressure fluctuations possessing a bounded velocity of propagation. It is important to underline that the results by Chow and Hermans are grounded on the classical approach to fluctuation-dissipation relations, namely on the validity of eq. ( 1 ) and on the representation of the stochastic forcings as white-noise processes. Assuming, as physically correct and statistically relevant, this ”regularity ansatz” of the acoustic effects, an equivalent regularity ansatz should be extended, by consistency, to the other contributions involved in the fluctuation-dissipation characterization of particle dynamics. Specifically, the simplification of \delta -correlated stochastic forcing (white-noise processes), should be removed on equal footing. And this, ultimately questions the physical validity of the Langevin condition eq. ( 1 ), as an acceptable approximation at least for liquids. The inclusion of correlated and more regular stochastic forcings, replacing the \delta -correlated distributional derivatives of Wiener processes, in particle hydromechanic equations is also consistent with the hydrodynamic picture of fluid-inertial effects, giving rise to coherent and correlated motion of fluid elements in the neighbourhood of the moving solid object (the Darwin paths) [ 21 ] . It is also consistent with a principle of mutual coupling between physical systems: the thermal force {\bf R}(t) originates also from the velocity fluctuations occurring in the fluid medium due to the motion of the colloidal particle, and therefore it is expected, especially in liquids, that {\bf R}(t) should be correlated with the previous velocity history of the particle itself. In this regard, the Langevin condition eq. ( 1 ) should be viewed as a long-term approximation for time-scales much larger than the characteristic dissipation and internal stress propagation times. However, the inclusion of correlated forcings in the particle equation of motion and ultimately in fluctuation-dissipation theory, should be performed with great caution, and should be compatible with some fundamental form of fluctuation-dissipation condition confirmed by the experiments. This condition, at equilibrium, is given by the global fluctuation-dissipation relation, that enabled Einstein to extract from the analysis of Brownian motion trajectories, the Avogadro number, subsequently confirmed experimentally by Perrin and by many others [ 22 , 23 , 24 ] . In this article we show that, introducing correlated stochastic forcings within the basic fluctuational patterns defined in part I, the global fluctuation-dissipation relation is preserved under very loose assumptions (essentially related to a normalization condition) in any complex fluid medium for which particle diffusion is asymptotically regular (i.e., the particle mean square displacement is asymptotically a linear function of time). The effect of correlated stochastic forcings within the fluctuational patterns is twofold: (i) compared to the white-noise driven counterparts, a transition is observed from fractal to regular velocity fluctuations; (ii) correlations induce the occurrence of an added mass in any fluid dynamic conditions (including the case of compressible hydrodynamics). These results are indeed in agreement with the recent experimental results on highly resolved Brownian motion in liquids [ 8 , 13 , 14 ] . Within the extension of fluctuation-dissipation theory developed in this article,

Read the complete text