Modeling the effect of grain boundary diffusivity and trapping on hydrogen transport using a phase-field compatible formulation Published in: International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 55 (2024) 1445–1455

Abdelrahman Hussein, Byungki Kim, Tom Depover, Kim Verbeken · 2024

Read Modeling the effect of grain boundary diffusivity and trapping on hydrogen transport using a phase-field compatible formulation Published in: International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 55 (2024) 1445–1455 by Abdelrahman Hussein, Byungki Kim, Tom Depover, Kim Verbeken (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-18974.txt.

Introduction

Abdelrahman Hussein and three co-authors wrote a 2024 paper on how hydrogen moves through metals and gets trapped at grain boundaries. Grain boundaries are the seams between crystals inside a metal. Trapped hydrogen at those seams is widely blamed for cracking and failure in hydrogen service.

Experiments struggle to watch such fast processes directly. The team built computer models of crystal patches using the phase-field method, which represents the seams naturally. Their new formulation tracks diffusion and trapping together in full kinetic detail. Two knobs were varied: how fast hydrogen moves along a seam, and how strongly the seam binds it. Stronger binding raised the hydrogen held at seams. In flow tests, faster seam diffusion raised the flux, and stronger binding did so too, a surprise the paper explores.

Catalog record

CREATORAbdelrahman Hussein, Byungki Kim, Tom Depover, Kim Verbeken
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-18974

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modeling the effect of grain boundary diffusivity and trapping on hydrogen transport using a phase-field compatible formulation Published in: International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 55 (2024) 1445–1455 Abdelrahman Hussein, Byungki Kim, Tom Depover, Kim Verbeken Abstract Hydrogen grain boundary (GB) trapping is widely accepted as the main cause for hydrogen induced intergranular failure. Several studies were conducted to unveil the role of GBs on hydrogen transport; however, a clear understanding is yet to be attained. This is due to the limitations of the state-of-the-art experimental procedures for such highly kinetic processes. In this study, we aim at providing a deeper understanding of hydrogen-GB interactions using full-field representative volume element (RVE). The phase-field method is chosen for generating RVEs, since it is the an appropriate numerical tool to represent GBs. A novel fully-kinetic formulation for hydrogen diffusion and GB trapping is presented, which is compatible with the phase-field based RVEs. GB diffusivity ( D gb D_{\mathrm{gb}} ) and trap-binding energy ( E gb E_{\mathrm{gb}} ) were used as parameters to understand the interactions between diffusion and GB trapping. Uptake and permeation simulations were performed with constant and gradient occupancy boundary conditions respectively. In both cases, increasing E gb E_{\mathrm{gb}} , increased the hydrogen GB occupancy. The permeation simulations showed that the hydrogen flux along the GBs increased with increasing both, D gb D_{\mathrm{gb}} and, surprisingly, E gb E_{\mathrm{gb}} . Since trapping increases the hydrogen occupancy along GBs, it also increases the occupancy gradients, resulting in a higher flux. This led to the conclusion that, in the case of an external occupancy gradient, GB trapping and diffusion cooperate, rather than compete, to increase the hydrogen flux. On the other hand, the decisive factor for the retention of hydrogen at the GBs in permeation simulations was D gb D_{\mathrm{gb}} rather than E gb E_{\mathrm{gb}} . 1 Introduction Hydrogen embrittlement (HE) is one of the long-standing problems for structural materials. The topic is gaining increasing momentum driven by the quest for a sustainable energy carrier. One of the challenges in handling hydrogen is that it can negatively impact the integrity and durability of the infrastructure used in storage and transport, increasing the risk of catastrophic failure [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] . The complexity of HE analysis lies in the multitude of hydrogen-microstructure interactions. Interface and GB trapping is believed to be the most important factor leading to the hydrogen enhanced decohesion damage mechanism (HEDE), which is the term describing the infamous hydrogen mediated intergranular damage. As such, understanding the equilibrium and kinetics of hydrogen-GB trapping is key to understanding the HEDE mechanism [ 5 ] . Including hydrogen trapping effects to Fick’s second law of diffusion [ 6 ] was achieved in 1963 by McNabb and Foster [ 7 ] . In 1970, Oriani [ 8 ] presented the thermodynamic equilibrium between hydrogen in lattice and trapping sites, which is a form of the McLean isotherm. Under the postulate of local equilibrium, i.e. very fast trapping kinetics, and low hydrogen lattice solubility, a simpler equation than that of McNabb and Foster was achieved. The main difference between both models is that the McNabb and Foster model is more general and can represent transient trapping, while Oriani’s model can be used for slower time-scale processes compared to trapping. Bhadeshia et al. [ 9 ] termed both equations as kinetic and local-equilibrium schemes respectively. These schemes have been widely used for the analysis of hydrogen permeation and thermal desorption spectroscopy analysis to extract apparent diffusivity, trap-binding energy and trap-density [ 10 , 11 ] . In 1989, Sofronis and McMeeking [ 12 ] included the effect of mechanical stresses in Oriani’s local-equilibrium scheme and used it to analyze the hydrogen diffusion near a blunting crack-tip. This has been the core for all subsequent diffusion-coupled mechanics studies [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] . Full-field mesoscale models that explicitly represent microstructure features are gaining increasing interest in recent years [ 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] as they support and can provide deeper understanding for experimental results since they can locally resolve hydrogen microstructure interactions, which are difficult to resolve experimentally [ 23 ] . Regarding hydrogen GB diffusivity and trapping, several studies were reported in the literature [ 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 ] . These studies were based on RVEs generated primarily by Voronoi tesselation and were solved using the finite element method, which requires tricky meshing strategies especially for GBs and triple junctions. More importantly, the GBs were treated as separate materials, which required different equations for lattice and GB regions. A plausible alternative to the geometric approach for RVE generation used in the aforementioned discussion is the physics approach based on the phase-field method [ 28 ] . Phase-field based RVEs are particularly convenient for mesoscale modeling of hydrogen-microstructure interactions since explicit microstructure features, like GBs, can be identified from the phase-field order-parameters. The approach is widely used in modeling the effect of segregation on GB dynamics [ 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 ] . A static phase-field based RVE, i.e. without considering further evolution of the order-parameters, can be used in modeling hydrogen GB interactions. To the best of our knowledge, Zhang et al. [ 33 ] presented the only attempt for such approach. However, in their formulation, they did not address the equilibrium properties, and thus, proper connection to the trap-binding energy values. Furthermore, the diffusion equation was not presented, leading to the requirement of unnecessary thermodynamic parameters. This led to non-linear steady-state concentration baseline profile, which we believe is not correct since it contradicts the straight-line baseline profile predicted by Fick’s first law of diffusion. In this work, we address these drawbacks with a focus on the profile of the double-obstacle potential used in the multiphase-field method [ 34 ] and present expressions for both equilibrium and kinetic cases. In section 2 , from an expression of the volumetric free energy functional, we derive an expression for the equilibrium hydrogen distribution as well as a fully kinetic mass transport equation, both in terms of occupancy (\theta) . The transformation from the unitless occupancy \theta to concentration c (in units of \mathrm{mol/m^{3}} ) in post processing as well as the implication of the phase-field numerical GB thickness are briefly discussed. In section 3 we apply the model to a 2D polycrystalline RVE and perform uptake and permeation simulations where we investigate the effect of trap-binding energy \Delta E_{\mathrm{gb}} and GB diffusivity D_{\mathrm{gb}} . The interaction of diffusion and trapping is thoroughly discussed in section 4 in terms of full-field and RVE averaged results. 2 Modeling GB segregation and trapping in the phase-field framework 2.1 Total free energy functional The main variable of the phase-field models is the order parameter vector \phi_{i} , i=1,\dots,N describing the spatial distribution of number of grains N . The total free energy functional that describes the total energy of the system including segregation 1 1 1 We use the terms segregation and trapping interchangeably effect can be expressed as F=\int_{V}\Bigl[f^{\mathrm{ch}}+f^{\mathrm{trap}}_{\mathrm{gb}}+f^{\mathrm{intf}}\Bigr]dV (1) where f^{\mathrm{ch}} is the chemical free energy density accounting for the energy of the homogenous system, in

Read the complete text