On the improved performances of FLUKA v4-4.0 in out-of-field proton dosimetry
Alexandra-Gabriela Şerban, Juan Alejandro de la Torre González, Marta Anguiano, Antonio M. Lallena, Francesc Salvat-Pujol · 2024
Read On the improved performances of FLUKA v4-4.0 in out-of-field proton dosimetry by Alexandra-Gabriela Şerban, Juan Alejandro de la Torre González, Marta Anguiano, Antonio M. Lallena, Francesc Salvat-Pujol (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-18314.txt.
Introduction
Serban and co-authors check in 2024 how well a new release of a physics code matches dose maps for proton beams. The code, FLUKA, is used to plan proton care and shield work. A new scatter model for protons at low energy came with the release and needed a direct test.
Dose maps in a water tank were made for three beam strengths, with old and new code runs set side by side. The new run matched the tank data far more closely. The team shows where proton scatter shapes each zone of the map. Beam and shape details must be set with care.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alexandra-Gabriela Şerban, Juan Alejandro de la Torre González, Marta Anguiano, Antonio M. Lallena, Francesc Salvat-Pujol |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-18314
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the improved performances of FLUKA v4-4.0 in out-of-field proton dosimetry Alexandra-Gabriela Şerban, Juan Alejandro de la Torre González, Marta Anguiano, Antonio M. Lallena, Francesc Salvat-Pujol Abstract A new model for the nuclear elastic scattering of protons below 250 250 MeV has been recently included in FLUKA v4-4.0 , motivated by the evaluation of radiation effects in electronics. Nonetheless, proton nuclear elastic scattering plays a significant role also in proton dosimetry applications, for which the new model necessitated an explicit validation. Therefore, in this work a benchmark has been carried out against a recent measurement of radial-depth maps of absorbed dose in a water phantom under irradiation with protons of 100 100 MeV, 160 160~ MeV, and 225 225 MeV. Two FLUKA versions have been employed to simulate these dose maps: v4-3.4 , relying on a legacy model for proton nuclear elastic scattering, and v4-4.0 , relying on the new model. The enhanced agreement with experimental absorbed doses obtained with FLUKA v4-4.0 is discussed, and the role played by proton nuclear elastic scattering, among other interaction mechanisms, in various regions of the radial-depth dose map is elucidated. Finally, the benchmark reported in this work is sensitive enough to showcase the importance of accurately characterizing beam parameters and the scattering geometry for Monte Carlo simulation purposes. 1 Introduction FLUKA [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] is a general-purpose code for the Monte Carlo (MC) simulation of coupled hadronic and electromagnetic radiation showers in complex geometries. It can transport over 60 particles species with energies from the keV to the PeV domain, with neutrons exceptionally tracked down to 0.01 meV. Naturally, FLUKA is routinely employed in a wide variety of applications, ranging from accelerator design and operation [ 4 ] , to associated radiation protection studies [ 5 , 6 ] , the assessment of radiation effects in electronics [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] , and medical applications [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] , to name but a few. Recent studies assessing the production of single-event-upsets in electronic devices under proton irradiation revealed a significant FLUKA underestimation for proton energies between 1 and 10 MeV [ 13 ] . This shortcoming was attributed to a too simplistic model for the nuclear elastic scattering of protons up to FLUKA version v4-3.4 [ 14 ] (included). In FLUKA v4-4.0 (released on Feb. 14, 2024), a new model for the nuclear elastic scattering of protons from Coulomb barrier up to 250 MeV was included [ 15 ] , relying on a partial-wave analysis of experimental angular distributions [ 16 , 17 ] . This model significantly improved FLUKA’s capability to evaluate single-event-upset production in electronic devices under irradiation by protons with energies from 1 to 100 MeV [ 15 , 18 ] . Nuclear elastic scattering of protons plays a significant role, not only for the assessment of radiation effects in electronics [ 15 , 19 , 20 ] , but also in proton dosimetry [ 21 ] . Indeed, proton nuclear elastic scattering contributes to the angular spread of proton showers in matter, and therefore has a direct effect on depth-dose maps, especially out-of-field (and thus on the dose delivered to nearby healthy tissue). A wide range of benchmarks was carried out prior to the public release of FLUKA v4-4.0 to validate its new model for proton nuclear elastic scattering [ 15 ] . Among them, a dedicated FLUKA simulation of a recent measurement of radial-depth ( r - z ) maps of dose absorbed in a water phantom under proton irradiation [ 22 ] was performed. The aim of this work, done on behalf of the FLUKA.CERN Collaboration, is twofold: on the one hand, to showcase the improved performances of FLUKA v4-4.0 with respect to v4-3.4 in capturing features across various regions of the aforementioned experimental r - z dose maps and, on the other hand, to emphasize the importance of accurately characterizing the radiation source and the scattering geometry for MC simulation purposes. In Section 2 , the experimental setup used to measure the aforementioned r - z dose maps [ 22 ] is summarized. Next, in Section 3 , the proton source adopted in the corresponding FLUKA simulations is explicitly detailed and the rest of the simulation setup (geometry and scoring) is documented. In Section 4 , the agreement between experimental r - z dose maps and those simulated with FLUKA v4-3.4 and v4-4.0 is discussed, putting particular emphasis on the significant role played by proton nuclear elastic scattering in various regions of the r - z dose maps. In Section 5 , the virtues and shortcomings of the Fermi-Eyges proton beam definition adopted in [ 22 ] are outlined, and a procedure is proposed to capture features of the angular distribution beyond the Gaussian core that the Fermi-Eyges theory focuses on. Finally, in Section 6 , a summary and conclusions are provided. Additionally, a general overview of the role played by proton nuclear elastic scattering and other relevant interaction mechanisms in the r - z maps of absorbed dose in water under proton irradiation is provided in the Appendix . 2 Experimental radial-depth dose maps In a recent work [ 22 ] , detailed r - z maps of dose absorbed in a water phantom under irradiation with 100 MeV, 160 MeV, and 225 MeV protons were reported. In this section, a summary of the experimental setup aspects necessary for the FLUKA simulations below is provided; further details are deferred to the original reference [ 22 ] . The aforementioned r - z maps of absorbed dose were measured with a two-dimensional array of 1020 ionization chambers arranged in a square grid and placed in a water phantom of 40 cm length. The diameter of each cylindrical chamber was 0.42 cm and the center of the considered proton beam coincided with the center of one ionization chamber, as further detailed in [ 22 ] . The reported uncertainties at each experimental point were 2.5 % in the absorbed dose, \pm 0.07 cm in depth, and \pm 0.01 cm in the radial position. Moreover, the experimental r - z dose maps were not given in absolute units: they were normalized to the dose at 3 cm on the beam axis. N.B.: For the 100 MeV proton beam, at the radial distance of 2.29 cm, the labels on the y axis are inaccurate in the original reference. Correct experimental absorbed doses have been provided directly by the authors of the original paper [ 22 ] . 3 FLUKA simulation setup In [ 22 ] , the spatial profile and angular distribution of the proton beam at the entrance of the water phantom are characterized relying on the Fermi-Eyges theory [ 23 , 24 , 25 ] . In this approach, the probability density to find a proton at a position \bm{r} after a path length s is parametrized as: \Phi(s;\bm{r},\theta_{x},\theta_{y})=F(z;x,\theta_{x})F(z;y,\theta_{y}), (1) where \displaystyle \displaystyle F(z;x,\theta_{x})=\frac{1}{4\pi\sqrt{B(z)}} (2) \displaystyle\times\exp\left(-\frac{A_{0}(z)x^{2}-2A_{1}(z)x\theta_{x}+A_{2}(z)\theta^{2}_{x}}{4B(z)}\right) is the probability density for a proton at depth z to have a transverse position x and an angle \theta_{x} between the direction of motion projected on the xz plane and the z axis; similarly for the projections on the