Subspaces with or without a common complement

Esteban Andruchow, Eduardo Chiumiento · 2024

Read Subspaces with or without a common complement by Esteban Andruchow, Eduardo Chiumiento (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-18113.txt.

Introduction

Esteban Andruchow and Eduardo Chiumiento ask when two subspaces of a Hilbert space can share one common complement. A complement fills a space alongside a subspace with no overlap; two subspaces may each have many, yet share none. Their 2024 paper sorts pairs of subspaces into those with a common complement and those without, inside the Grassmann manifold of all subspaces. Viewing subspaces through their projection operators turns the question into operator algebra. The set of pairs with a common complement proves open, and its connected pieces are examined.

Such structure results matter in operator theory, where changing subspaces is a daily move. Knowing the good set is open means small wobbles cannot destroy a shared complement. The authors map the boundary of the bad set as well. Their work gives a clean geometric picture of an algebraic question.

Catalog record

CREATOREsteban Andruchow, Eduardo Chiumiento
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE91 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-18113

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Subspaces with or without a common complement Esteban Andruchow, Eduardo Chiumiento Abstract Let ℋ {\cal H} be a separable complex Hilbert space. Denote by G ​ r ​ ( ℋ ) Gr({\cal H}) the Grassmann manifold of ℋ {\cal H} . We study the following sets of pairs of elements in G ​ r ​ ( ℋ ) Gr({\cal H}) : 𝚫 = { ( 𝒮 , 𝒯 ) ∈ G ​ r ​ ( ℋ ) × G ​ r ​ ( ℋ ) : ∃ 𝒵 ∈ G ​ r ​ ( ℋ ) ​ such that ​ 𝒮 ​ + ˙ ​ 𝒵 = 𝒯 ​ + ˙ ​ 𝒵 = ℋ } , {\bf\Delta}=\{({\cal S},{\cal T})\in Gr({\cal H})\times Gr({\cal H}):\exists{\cal Z}\in Gr({\cal H})\hbox{ such that }{\cal S}\dot{+}{\cal Z}={\cal T}\dot{+}{\cal Z}={\cal H}\}, which are pairs of subspaces that have a common complement, and 𝚪 = G ​ r ​ ( ℋ ) × G ​ r ​ ( ℋ ) ∖ 𝚫 , {\bf\Gamma}=Gr({\cal H})\times Gr({\cal H})\setminus{\bf\Delta}, which are pairs of subspaces that do not admit a common complement. We identify 𝒮 ∼ P 𝒮 {\cal S}\sim P_{\cal S} , the subspace 𝒮 {\cal S} with the orthogonal projection P 𝒮 P_{\cal S} onto 𝒮 {\cal S} . Thus we may regard 𝚫 {\bf\Delta} and 𝚪 {\bf\Gamma} as subsets of ℬ ⁡ ( ℋ ) × ℬ ⁡ ( ℋ ) {\cal B}({\cal H})\times{\cal B}({\cal H}) (here ℬ ⁡ ( ℋ ) {\cal B}({\cal H}) denotes the algebra of bounded linear operators in ℋ {\cal H} ). We show that 𝚫 {\bf\Delta} is open, and its connected components are parametrized by the dimension and codimension of the subspaces. The connected component of 𝚫 {\bf\Delta} having both infinite dimensional and co-dimensional subspaces is dense in the corresponding component of G ​ r ​ ( ℋ ) × G ​ r ​ ( ℋ ) Gr({\cal H})\times Gr({\cal H}) . On the other hand, 𝚪 {\bf\Gamma} is a (closed) C ∞ C^{\infty} submanifold of ℬ ⁡ ( ℋ ) × ℬ ⁡ ( ℋ ) {\cal B}({\cal H})\times{\cal B}({\cal H}) , and we characterize the connected components of 𝚪 {\bf\Gamma} in terms of dimensions and semi-Fredholm indices. We study the role played by the geodesic structure of the Grassmann geometry of ℋ {\cal H} in the geometry of both 𝚫 {\bf\Delta} and 𝚪 {\bf\Gamma} . Several examples of pairs in 𝚫 {\bf\Delta} and the connected components of 𝚪 {\bf\Gamma} are given in Hilbert spaces of functions. 2020 MSC: 47B02, 58B10, 58B20, 46E20 Keywords: common complement; Grassmann manifold; semi-Fredholm operator; geodesic; Hilbert space of functions. 1 Introduction These notes reflect on the paper [ 22 ] by M. Lauzon and S. Treil. These authors characterize pairs of (closed) subspaces {\cal S} and {\cal T} of a Hilbert space {\cal H} , which have a common complement {\cal Z} . That is, there exists a closed subspace {\cal Z}\subset{\cal H} such that {\cal S}\dot{+}{\cal Z}={\cal T}\dot{+}{\cal Z}={\cal H}, where the symbol \dot{+} stands for direct sum. In this paper we investigate geometric aspects of the set of all the pairs of subspaces having a common complement, and the set of all pairs that do not admit a common complement, Denote by {\cal B}({\cal H}) the algebra of bounded linear operators in a complex separable Hilbert space {\cal H} , {\cal P}({\cal H}) the subset of orthogonal projections, and Gr({\cal H}) the Grassmann manifold of {\cal H} . Throughout, we identify subspaces in Gr({\cal H}) with their corresponding orthogonal projections in {\cal P}({\cal H}) . Our objects of study will be the complementary sets {\bf\Delta}:=\{(P_{\cal S},P_{\cal T})\in{\cal P}({\cal H})\times{\cal P}({\cal H}):{\cal S}\hbox{ and }{\cal T}\hbox{ have a common complement}\}, and {\bf\Gamma}:=\{(P_{\cal S},P_{\cal T})\in{\cal P}({\cal H})\times{\cal P}({\cal H}):{\cal S}\hbox{ and }{\cal T}\hbox{ do not have a common complement}\}. The space {\cal P}({\cal H}) is a complemented C ∞ submanifold of {\cal B}({\cal H}) (see [ 13 , 28 ] ). Therefore it is natural to ask about the geometric structure of the sets {\bf\Delta} and {\bf\Gamma} . By an elementary argument, or using a result by J. Giol [ 20 ] , it can be shown that {\bf\Delta} is an open subset of {\cal P}({\cal H})\times{\cal P}({\cal H}) . Its complement {{\bf\Gamma}} is shown to be a (non complemented) closed C^{\infty} submanifold of {\cal P}({\cal H})\times{\cal P}({\cal H}) . Thus, both spaces have differentiable structure. We study how the geometry of these spaces relates to geometry of {\cal P}({\cal H}) . Specifically, concerning the geodesics of {\cal P}({\cal H}) , which have been thoroughly studied. We are also interested in the study of concrete examples of pairs of subspaces in {\bf\Delta} and {\bf\Gamma} in the context of Hilbert spaces of functions. Let us describe the contents of this paper. In Section 2 we recall preliminaries on common complemented subspaces obtained by M. Lauzon and S. Treil [ 22 ] , and also the results that were later proved by J. Giol [ 20 ] . We also state basic facts on the following aspects of projections: the geometry of {\cal P}({\cal H}) [ 13 , 28 ] , Halmos’ model for a pair of subspaces [ 18 ] , and the index of a pair of projections [ 9 ] . In Section 3 we study the structure of the set {\bf\Delta} , and show that {\bf\Delta} is an open subset of {\cal P}({\cal H})\times{\cal P}({\cal H}) . This is a consequence of a result by Giol [ 20 ] ; we give though an elementary proof of this fact. We characterize the connected components of {\bf\Delta} in terms of ranks and co-ranks, and the there is only one connected component {\bf\Delta}_{\infty} having subspaces of both infinite dimension and codimension. We show by using Halmos’ model that {\bf\Delta}_{\infty} is dense in the corresponding connected component of the (product) Grassmann manifold. In Section 4 we consider the structure of the set {\bf\Gamma} . The main result states that {\bf\Gamma} is a (closed) non complemented C^{\infty} submanifold of {\cal B}({\cal H})\times{\cal B}({\cal H}) . For 1\leq i,j\leq+\infty , denote by {\cal P}_{i,j} the connected component of {\cal P}({\cal H}) consisting of projections with rank i and co-rank j . We show that {\bf\Gamma} consists of the following parts: • {\cal P}_{i,j}\times{\cal P}_{k,l} , for i\neq k or j\neq l . • For pairs of projections in {\cal P}_{\infty,\infty} , {\bf\Gamma}_{1}=\{(P_{\cal S},P_{\cal T})\in{\bf\Gamma}:\dim{\cal S}\cap{\cal T}^{\perp}<\infty,\ \dim{\cal S}^{\perp}\cap{\cal T}<\infty\}. and {\bf\Gamma}_{\infty}=\{(P_{\cal S},P_{\cal T})\in\Gamma:\hbox{ only one of }{\cal S}\cap{\cal T}^{\perp},\ {\cal S}^{\perp}\cap{\cal T}\hbox{ has infinite dimension}\}. Moreover, {\bf\Gamma}_{1} splits in the following submanifolds, which are its connected components paramatrized by the integers as follows: {\bf\Gamma}_{1}^{n}=\{(P_{\cal S},P_{\cal T})\in{\bf\Gamma}_{1}:P_{\cal S}\big|_{\cal T}:{\cal T}\to{\cal S}\hbox{ is a Fredholm operator of index }n\},\ n\in\mathbb{Z}. The connected components of the submanifold {\bf\Gamma}_{\infty} are {\bf\Gamma}_{\infty}^{l}:=\{(P_{\cal S},P_{\cal T})\in{\cal P}({\cal H})\times{\cal P}({\cal H}):\dim{\cal S}\cap{\cal T}^{\perp}<\infty,\dim{\cal S}^{\perp}\cap{\cal T}=+\infty\} and {\bf\Gamma}_{\infty}^{r}:=\{(P_{\cal S},P_{\cal T})\in{\cal P}({\cal H})\times{\cal P}({\cal H}):\dim{\cal S}\cap{\cal T}^{\perp}=\infty,\dim{\cal S}^{\perp}\cap{\cal T}<+\infty\}. These results are based on previous results obtained in [ 5 ] . In Section 5 we discuss when geodesics of {\cal P}({\cal H})\times{\cal P}({\cal H}) remain inside {\bf\Delta} or {\bf\Gamma} along their paths. We give an example which shows that arbitrary close points in {\bf\Delta} may not

Read the complete text