Covariant LTB collapse in models of loop quantum gravity

Martin Bojowald, Erick I. Duque, Dennis Hartmann · 2024

Read Covariant LTB collapse in models of loop quantum gravity by Martin Bojowald, Erick I. Duque, Dennis Hartmann (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-18054.txt.

Introduction

Martin Bojowald, Erick Duque, and Dennis Hartmann analyse gravitational collapse in loop quantum gravity models. Their twenty twenty-four paper uses Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi space-times with marginal binding. Collapse models test whether quantum effects can soften extreme gravity. Emergent modified gravity gives a covariant setting for those effects.

Earlier vacuum models with similar changes showed bouncing behaviour. Matter-filled collapse tells a different story here. The detailed analysis finds a physical singularity still forms. That singularity removes the bounce seen in empty space-times. The result limits hopes that these modifications always resolve collapse. Readers interested in quantum gravity gain a careful check on when new effects help and when they do not.

Catalog record

CREATORMartin Bojowald, Erick I. Duque, Dennis Hartmann
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE95 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-18054

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Covariant LTB collapse in models of loop quantum gravity Martin Bojowald, Erick I. Duque, Dennis Hartmann Abstract Models of gravitational collapse provide important means to test whether non-classical space-time effects motivated for instance by quantum gravity can be realized in generic ways in physically relevant situations. Here, a detailed analysis of marginally bound Lemaître–Tolman–Bondi space-times is given in emergent modified gravity, which in particular includes a covariant formulation of holonomy modifications usually considered in models of loop quantum gravity. As a result, generic collapse in this setting is shown to imply a physical singularity that removes the bouncing behavior seen in vacuum space-times with the same type of modifications. I Introduction Black holes present a fascinating problem in general relativity and possible extensions such as modified or quantum gravity. Being described by a small parameter space, they appear as rather simple objects from a classical perspective. However, it is often postulated that quantum effects should start to dominate near the singularity of a black hole, where curvature is large and divergences lead to undefined quantities in the classical theory. Various approaches to quantum gravity have therefore suggested modifications of the classical behavior of space-time with the main goal of resolving physical singularities. Unraveling the mysteries of black holes requires an understanding of their formation. The conditions and mechanisms that cause the collapse of matter to a black hole are numerous. In this paper, we shall focus on the Lemaître–Tolman–Bondi (LTB) collapse model of dust matter within emergent modified gravity, extending the original analysis with canonical methods given in [ 1 , 2 ] . We leave the critical collapse of scalar fields to a future paper. Both types of collapse models are well-established and have been studied from different perspectives. LTB collapse is of interest in the present paper in order to study a manifestly covariant model of matter collapse in which partial analytical results are available. Emergent modified gravity [ 3 , 4 ] is an approach to modified gravity crucially based on the canonical formulation of general relativity. Because canonical expressions do not require space-time integrals, they impose weaker assumptions on the basic setup than space-time scalars required for effective space-time actions. As a result, new theories of modified gravity are available, at least in spherical symmetry and polarized Gowdy systems [ 5 ] , even if one works at the classical derivative order of equations of motion and does not include higher time derivatives or extra fields. The space-time geometries resulting from solutions of the theory are Riemannian, but the line element is not directly given by one of the fundamental fields and instead has to be derived from the field equations. Couplings to perfect fluids, scalar matter, and the electromagnetic field have been derived in [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] . Prior studies of black holes in emergent modified gravity or related approaches [ 9 ] have revealed interesting results, such as the potential for non-singular behavior [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] or, for a special set of modifications, dynamical signature change of metric components at classical scales [ 13 ] which demonstrates the non-standard nature of new space-time solutions. Collapse models have been analyzed in an Oppenheimer–Snyder version [ 6 ] , and already in LTB models [ 14 , 15 ] . The latter models were restricted to a subset of modification functions, in particular with a constant holonomy length, that are known to lead to large deviations from classical behavior even on small curvature scales. One of the main aims of our work is to provide a sufficiently general formulation and analysis of LTB models that also includes decreasing holonomy lengths. Emergent modified gravity includes modification functions that clarify the appearance of holonomy modifications of loop quantum gravity [ 16 ] . It therefore provides a unique systematic way of turning preliminary constructions that implement loop effects in a fixed gauge or in a deparameterized theory into fully covariant space-time models. (Alternative constructions of a limited set of such models have been presented in [ 17 ] . However, as discussed in [ 18 ] , they are special cases of emergent modified gravity and do not constitute a systematic derivation of modified gravity within a reliable setting of effective field theory.) In particular, emergent modified gravity can be used to identify problems in LTB models of loop quantum gravity, such as non-covariance in the recent [ 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] , and amend them by including symmetry-restoring terms in the Hamiltonian constraint. It is important to note that emergent modified gravity is not a quantum theory, though some modifications may be motivated by it, in the present case of interest by loop quantum gravity (LQG). However, the theory is non-classical in the sense that it is inequivalent to general relativity. In the following, we use the term classical to refer to general relativity. In particular, the classical limit of emergent modified gravity is defined as general relativity. An issue that has been discussed extensively is the physical meaning of shell-crossing singularities and potential shock waves that may occur at a turning point of collapse, a possible cure of the classical curvature singularity. A careful analysis has been given in [ 21 ] where it was found important to compare results from different choices of coordinates and space-time slicings. However, the same paper pointed out that available models had not been shown to be covariant, which would be an important prerequisite to any physical analysis of space-time effects. Here, we complete the discussion by constructing a corresponding formulation that is explicitly shown to be covariant. Our main result is surprising: While covariance can be restored, we find that LTB models with modifications motivated by loop quantum gravity have a physical, rather than shell-crossing, singularity even though corresponding vacuum models are generically non-singular. A similar result with dust [ 6 ] and scalar matter [ 7 ] had already been found in emergent modified gravity, and [ 14 , 15 ] extended this effect to LTB collapse (with constant holonomy length). The latter papers then introduced a conformal transformation to a non-singular solution and argued that this should be the physical one. A second aim of the present paper is to critically examine this proposal, which we find inadmissible when seen from the perspective of a modified theory rather than a single modified solution. The result of a generic re-appearance of physical singularities in LTB collapse raises important questions about the reliability of singularity resolution or other effects found in simple models of loop quantum gravity. It highlights the importance of constructing fully covariant space-time models whenever a space-time analysis based on effective line elements is performed: The singular behavior can be traced back to a crucial factor in the space-time metric that had been missed in non-covariant models. It is also important to include a generic set of modification functions in one’s class of theories, such that all potential effects at the same order of derivatives can be included. Emergent modified gravity fulfills this condition from the point of view of effective field theory. Our construction of LTB models in emergent modified gravity

Read the complete text