Hyperbolic Chamfer Distance for Point Cloud Completion and Beyond

Fangzhou Lin, Songlin Hou, Haotian Liu, Shang Gao, Kazunori D Yamada, Haichong K. Zhang · 2024

Read Hyperbolic Chamfer Distance for Point Cloud Completion and Beyond by Fangzhou Lin, Songlin Hou, Haotian Liu, Shang Gao, Kazunori D Yamada, Haichong K. Zhang (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-17951.txt.

Introduction

Fangzhou Lin and co-authors propose a new loss function for completing 3D point clouds, in a 2024 paper. A point cloud is a set of dots that map the shape of an object. Completion means filling in the parts a scan missed. The field grades results with Chamfer Distance, a score for how close two clouds sit.

That score is weak against stray outlier points, which can pull a model off course. The authors move the score into hyperbolic space and call it HyperCD. It gives more weight to point pairs that already sit close, and less to poor matches. Tests on three standard datasets show top results and smoother surfaces. The team also tries the score on rebuilding shapes from one image and on upsampling.

Catalog record

CREATORFangzhou Lin, Songlin Hou, Haotian Liu, Shang Gao, Kazunori D Yamada, Haichong K. Zhang
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-17951

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hyperbolic Chamfer Distance for Point Cloud Completion and Beyond Fangzhou Lin, Songlin Hou, Haotian Liu, Shang Gao, Kazunori D Yamada, Haichong K. Zhang Abstract Chamfer Distance (CD) is widely used as a metric to quantify difference between two point clouds. In point cloud completion, Chamfer Distance (CD) is typically used as a loss function in deep learning frameworks. However, it is generally acknowledged within the field that Chamfer Distance (CD) is vulnerable to the presence of outliers, which can consequently lead to the convergence on suboptimal models. In divergence from the existing literature, which largely concentrates on resolving such concerns in the realm of Euclidean space, we put forth a notably uncomplicated yet potent metric specifically designed for point cloud completion tasks: Hyperbolic Chamfer Distance (HyperCD). This metric conducts Chamfer Distance computations within the parameters of hyperbolic space. During the backpropagation process, HyperCD systematically allocates greater weight to matched point pairs exhibiting reduced Euclidean distances. This mechanism facilitates the preservation of accurate point pair matches while permitting the incremental adjustment of suboptimal matches, thereby contributing to enhanced point cloud completion outcomes. Moreover, measure the shape dissimilarity is not solely work for point cloud completion task, we further explore its applications in other generative related tasks, including single image reconstruction from point cloud, and upsampling. We demonstrate state-of-the-art performance on the point cloud completion benchmark datasets, i.e. PCN, ShapeNet-55, and ShapeNet-34, and show from visualization that HyperCD can significantly improve the surface smoothness, we also provide the provide experimental results beyond completion task. I Introduction Point clouds, easily obtainable yet fundamentally important, are pivotal in shaping today’s landscape of robotics and automation [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] , with applications ranging from scene modeling [ 4 ] , field measurement [ 5 ] to industrial designs [ 6 ] . However, raw data of point clouds captured by existing 3D sensors is usually incomplete and sparse due to factors such as occlusion, limited sensor resolution and light reflection [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] , which may adversely affect the performance of downstream tasks requiring high-quality representation, such as point cloud segmentation and detection. Researchers aim to resolve this challenge by reconstructing the full shape of an object or scene from incomplete raw point clouds. This task is referred to as point cloud completion [ 12 ] . During this effort, accurately determining the similarity of two collections of points becomes a crucial part of this task. (a) Euclidean (b) Hyperbolic Fig. 1: Illustration of point matching in the (a) Euclidean space and (b) hyperbolic space. With the position-aware embeddings in hyperbolic space, the mismatched point pairs in Euclidean space may be corrected, leading to better completion performance. Point cloud completion has long been regarded as a complex task due to the unordered and unstructured nature of point clouds (particularly those acquired from real-world environments).Recently, a variety of deep learning-based approaches have been introduced for point cloud completion, including supervised learning, self-supervised learning, and unsupervised learning [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] . Supervised learning, utilizing a general encoder-decoder architecture, has emerged as the predominant paradigm among researchers, delivering state-of-the-art performance across nearly all major benchmarks. Many related research centers on developing various structures within the encoder and decoder to enhance feature extraction and improve point cloud generation [ 19 , 20 , 11 , 1 , 21 ] , in Euclidean space. Unequal Point Importance in Point Clouds. The visual quality of point clouds is typically perceived by humans in a non-homogeneous manner, with greater emphasis placed on points featuring specific geometric structures, such as planes, edges, and corners, etc. For example, point clouds featuring smooth surfaces and sharp edges are generally considered more visually appealing compared to those lacking these characteristics [ 22 , 23 ] . This seemingly simple, yet nontrivial fact in point clouds, however, remains largely unexplored in the literature of point cloud completion. Chamfer distance (CD), as demonstrated in works such as [ 24 , 25 ] , is commonly employed in point cloud completion to quantify the dissimilarity in shape between two point clouds. This is achieved by computing the average distance from each point in one set to its nearest neighbor in the other set. As much as CD accurately represents the global dissimilarity between the prediction and ground truth, it assigns equal importance to the distances of all nearest-neighbor pairs from both sets, including outliers, which results in an increased sensitivity to outliers. Fig. 2: Illustration of (left) some distance metrics and (right) their corresponding gradients, where the dotted curves are used in \ell_{1} and \ell_{2} -CD, the dash ones are used in density-aware Chamfer distance (DCD) [ 25 ] , and the solid curves are special cases of our HyperCD. Density-aware Chamfer Distance (DCD) in Euclidean Space. To tackle the issue of equal weighting in CD, Wu et al. [ 25 ] recently introduced a DCD metric that examines the disparity in density distributions within point clouds. As shown in Fig. 1 (a), denser points in point clouds are more likely to have multiple matches, whereas sparser points may have fewer matches. The DCD metric incorporates this disparity by applying a weighting mechanism (inverse to the number of matches) to ensure that sparser points are assigned higher weights. Additionally, DCD employs an exponential approximation, based on the first-order Taylor expansion, to reduce sensitivity to outliers, as demonstrated in Fig. 2 . While empirical evidence suggests that DCD outperforms CD in point cloud completion, it might exhibit the following significant challenges: • Density-aware mechanism in DCD may assign higher weights to sparser points. It not only helps achieve accurate matches at the edges and corners, but also increases the likelihood of matching outliers, resulting in a suboptimal completion. • CD approximate functions hardly preserve good matches. From Fig. 2 , CD is susceptible to outliers due to its gradient, which assigns greater (or equal) weights to points located farther away. While DCD addresses this issue, it encounters challenges where the weights either decay too rapidly (exponentially) with the \ell_{1} distance or become excessively small for accurate matches (even zero for perfect matches) when using the \ell_{2} distance. Hyperbolic Chamfer Distance (HyperCD). To address the challenges in CD for point cloud completion, we propose that the key to success lies in gradually improving poor matches while maintaining strong ones throughout training. This approach, which we term "position-aware," focuses solely on point positions. Recent research has shown that hyperbolic space can effectively represent the inherent compositional nature of point clouds by using position-aware embeddings within tree-like geometric structures, as demonstrated in works such as [ 26 ] . This insight strongly motivates our exploration of CD within hyperbolic space. As shown in Fig. 1 (b), hyperbolic space offers greater flexibility than Euclidean distance for measuring distances between points, which may help address matching errors in CD. Furthermore, as depicted in Fig. 2 (left), various power functions in hyperbolic space (defined by \arccosh ) provide a closer approximation to CD than DCD. Additionally, the gradient curves of y=\arccosh(1+x) and y=\arccosh(1+x^{3}/3) closely resemble those of DCD, while the gradient curve of y=\arccosh(1+x^{2}/2)

Read the complete text