Eccentricity reduction of binary neutron star initial data with the entropy based flux limiting scheme
Georgios Doulis 1, Sebastiano Bernuzzi 2, Wolfgang Tichy 3 · 2024
Read Eccentricity reduction of binary neutron star initial data with the entropy based flux limiting scheme by Georgios Doulis 1, Sebastiano Bernuzzi 2, Wolfgang Tichy 3 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-17863.txt.
Introduction
Georgios Doulis and co-authors refine the starting data for neutron star merger simulations, where two dense stars spiral into each other. Clean starts matter because stray oval motion in the setup muddies the wave signals that detectors record. The team brings a sharp flow method to the setup stage itself.
Their method, the entropy based flux limiting scheme, had already sped the main merger runs and sharpened wave phase results. Here it shapes fresh starting data with reduced eccentricity for pairs of neutron stars. Fresh merger runs from that data reach up to fifth-order convergence in wave phase, the best level hoped for. Cleaner starts mean wave templates that match real events more closely. That in turn helps observatories weigh and locate the stars that made the waves.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Georgios Doulis 1, Sebastiano Bernuzzi 2, Wolfgang Tichy 3 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-17863
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Eccentricity reduction of binary neutron star initial data with the entropy based flux limiting scheme Georgios Doulis 1, Sebastiano Bernuzzi 2, Wolfgang Tichy 3 Abstract The construction of high-resolution shock-capturing schemes is vital in producing highly accurate gravitational waveforms from neutron star binaries. The entropy based flux limiting (EFL) scheme is able to perform fast converging binary neutron star merger simulations reaching up to fourth-order convergence in the gravitational waveform phase. In these results the EFL method was used only in the dynamical evolution of initial data constructed with the Lorene library. Here, we extend the use of the EFL method to the construction of eccentricity reduced initial data for neutron star binaries and present several new BNS simulations resulting from such initial data and show for the first time up to optimal fifth-order convergence in the gravitational waveform phase. pacs 04.25.D-, 04.30.Db, 95.30.Sf, 95.30.Lz, 97.60.Jd I Introduction Binary neutron star (BNS) coalescences are one of the confirmed [ 1 , 2 ] sources of gravitational waves (GWs) detected by the LIGO-VIRGO interferometers. Numerical relativity (NR) is able to produce merger waveforms that replicate these GWs accurately enough for BNS parameter estimation. The production of highly accurate numerical waveforms plays a vital role in understanding the properties of neutron star (NS) binaries during the inspiral, merger and postmerger regime. In this spirit, several high-resolution shock-capturing (HRSC) schemes [ 3 ] have been developed over the years aiming at increasing the accuracy and the convergence properties of the numerically produced waveforms. Going beyond second-order convergence is currently the major challenge for the existing HRSC schemes, which has been pointed out long ago, but addressed only in a few places [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ] . Here, we focus on a specific family of flux altering HRSC methods: the flux-limiters [ 8 ] , which have been proven very successful in dealing with shocks and suppressing spurious oscillations. In [ 9 ] a fast converging HRSC scheme that utilises the local entropy production in the design of an entropy based flux-limiter was proposed. The EFL scheme developed from an entropy method that started as an artificial viscosity method [ 10 , 11 ] and grew with time to a flux-limiting scheme [ 12 ] . In [ 12 ] , for the first time, entropy was used in the design of a flux-limiter. The EFL scheme, apart from overcoming the shortcomings of the method developed in [ 12 ] , is considerably more automated and simpler in its implementation. These features make the EFL method universally applicable to different special and general relativistic scenarios. The EFL scheme was successfully used in [ 9 ] to evolve several different BNS systems and managed to deliver up to fourth-order convergent waveforms in the dominant (2,2) -mode and in the subdominant (3,2) - and (4,4) -mode. In the present work we extend the use of the EFL method to the construction of BNS initial data through an eccentricity reduction procedure. In [ 9 ] , the EFL scheme was exclusively used for the temporal evolution of BNS initial data computed with the Lorene library [ 13 ] . Here, for the first time, we involve the EFL method in the eccentricity reduction procedure of initial data sets with the SGRID code [ 14 ] and study the effect of this action on the accuracy and the convergence properties of the produced merger waveforms. The article is structured as follows. Theoretical and numerical aspects of the EFL method are discussed in Sec. II . The way to perform eccentricity reduction in the construction of SGRID initial data is comprehensively detailed in Sec. III . Sec. IV contains our results of the first BNS simulations where the EFL method is not only used for the temporal evolution, but also in the eccentricity reduction of the initial data. Finally, we conclude in Sec. V . Throughout this work we use geometric units. We set c=G=1 and the masses are expressed in terms of solar masses M_{\odot} . II EFL Method We start from the equations of general relativistic hydrodynamics written in conservation form [ 15 ] : \partial_{t}\textbf{Q}+\partial_{i}\textbf{F}^{i}(\textbf{Q})=\textbf{S}, (1) where the summation is performed over the spatial dimensions and \displaystyle\frac{\textbf{Q}}{\sqrt{\gamma}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\rho\,W\left(1,h\,Wu_{j},h\,W-1-\frac{p}{\rho W}\right)=\left(D,S_{j},\tau\right), \displaystyle\frac{\textbf{F}^{i}}{\sqrt{\gamma}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(\mathrm{v}^{i}D,\mathrm{v}^{i}S_{j}+\alpha p\delta^{i}_{j},\mathrm{v}^{i}\tau+\alpha pu^{i}\right), \displaystyle\frac{\textbf{S}}{\sqrt{\gamma}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\alpha\,\left(0,\Gamma^{\mu}_{\nu j}\,T^{\nu}_{\mu},\alpha\,[T^{0\mu}\,\partial_{\mu}\ln\alpha-\Gamma^{0}_{\mu\nu}T^{\mu\nu}]\right) are the vectors of the conserved variables, the physical fluxes and the sources, respectively. In the above definitions we introduced the rest-mass density \rho , the pressure p , the 3-velocity u^{i} of the fluid, the specific enthalpy h=1+\epsilon+p/\rho with \epsilon the specific internal energy, the Lorentz factor W=(1-u_{i}u^{i})^{1/2} , the determinant \gamma of the 3-metric \gamma_{ij} , the lapse function \alpha , the shift vector \beta^{i} , the Kronecker delta \delta^{i}_{j} , the notation \mathrm{v}^{i}=\alpha u^{i}-\beta^{i} , the energy-momentum tensor T_{\mu\nu} and the Christoffel symbols \Gamma^{\lambda}_{\mu\nu} associated with the metric g_{\mu\nu} . The EFL method is based on the idea of expressing the numerical fluxes resulting from the semi-discretisation of ( 1 ) as a superposition of an unstable and a stable flux. As discussed in [ 9 ] the former is approximated by a high-order accurate flux and the latter by a low- or high-order accurate flux. The weight regulating the superposition of the two fluxes is computed from the entropy produced by the conservation law under study. In essence, the entropy of the system is a “shock detector” that is used as a switch indicating when to move from the unstable high-order scheme to the stable one. In accordance with [ 9 ] , we use the conservative finite-difference formula \partial_{x}F^{x}_{i}=\frac{\hat{f}_{i+1/2}-\hat{f}_{i-1/2}}{h} (2) to approximate the spatial derivative of the x component, \textbf{F}^{x} , of the physical flux appearing in ( 1 ). 1 1 1 In the following, we restrict the presentation to one dimension. A multidimensional scheme is obtained by considering fluxes in each direction separately and adding them to the r.h.s. In the formula above F^{x} is one of the components of \textbf{F}^{x} with F^{x}_{i}=F^{x}(x_{i}) , \hat{f}_{i\pm 1/2} are the numerical fluxes at the cell interfaces and h is the spatial grid spacing. In order to construct a flux-limiter, the numerical fluxes in ( 2 ) have to be split into two contributions in the usual way [ 3 ] : \hat{f}_{i\pm 1/2}=\theta_{i\pm 1/2}\hat{f}^{\,\mathrm{HO}}_{i\pm 1/2}+(1-\theta_{i\pm 1/2})\hat{f}^{\,\mathrm{LO}}_{i\pm 1/2}. (3) The quantities entering the r.h.s of ( 3 ) read: • f^{\,\mathrm{HO}} is a high-order (HO) unstable numerical flux used in regions where the numerical solution is smooth. • f^{\,\mathrm{LO}} is a high- or low-order (LO) stable numerical flux used in regions where the numerical solution develops non-smooth features. Notice that in order to be consistent with previous work [ 9 , 16 ] , we keep the notation LO although in the following we use exclusively a stable high-order scheme to approximate f^{\,\mathrm{LO}} . • \theta\in[0,1] is a continuous weight function indicating how much from the numerical fluxes f^{\,\mathrm{HO}} and f^{\,\mathrm{LO}} to use at every instance. Specifically, the flux \hat{f}^{\,\mathrm{HO}} is constructed using the Rusanov Lax-Friedrichs flux-splitting technique, with reconstruction carried out on the characteristic fields [ 17 , 7 ] . A fifth-order central unfiltered stencil is always used for reconstruction. The flux \hat{f}^{\,\mathrm{LO}} is estimated using