Building transport models from baroclinic wave experimental data
M. Agaoglou, V. J. García-Garrido, U. Harlander, A. M. Mancho · 2024
Read Building transport models from baroclinic wave experimental data by M. Agaoglou, V. J. García-Garrido, U. Harlander, A. M. Mancho (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-17581.txt.
Introduction
Agaoglou and three co-authors build transport models from a lab model of the atmosphere in a 2024 paper. Their experiment is a rotating annulus, a ring of fluid that spawns baroclinic eddies like those in mid-latitude weather. The team wanted to know which invisible curves steer the flow and block mixing.
They cleaned the data with a standard pattern-finding method and also built a simple motion model from a few measured values. On both, they applied Lagrangian descriptors, a tool that exposes attracting curves in the flow. Those curves matched the transport patterns seen in the experiment well. The study shows simple models can capture the real barriers that organize eddy-driven movement.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M. Agaoglou, V. J. García-Garrido, U. Harlander, A. M. Mancho |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-17581
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Building transport models from baroclinic wave experimental data Preprint: AIP/123-QED M. Agaoglou, V. J. García-Garrido, U. Harlander, A. M. Mancho Abstract \textcolor blackIn this paper we study baroclinic waves both from the experimental and the theoretical perspective. We obtain data from a rotating annulus experiment capable of producing a series of baroclinic eddies similar to those found in the mid-latitude atmosphere. We analyze the experimental outputs using two methods. First, we apply a technique that involves filtering data using Empirical Orthogonal Function (EOF) analysis, which is applied to both velocity and surface temperature fields. The second method relies on the construction of a simple kinematic model based on key parameters derived from the experimental data. To analyze eddy-driven fluid transport, we apply the method of Lagrangian descriptors to the underlying velocity field, revealing the attracting material curves that act as transport barriers in the system. These structures effectively capture the essential characteristics of the baroclinic flow and the associated transport phenomena. Our results show that these barriers are in good agreement with the transport patterns observed in the rotating annulus experiment. In particular, we observe that the structures obtained from the kinematic model, or the one derived in terms of filtered velocities, perform well in this regard. Keywords: Baroclinic waves, Empirical Orthogonal Function analysis, Karhunen-Loève decomposition, Kinematic model, Invariant manifolds, Lagrangian descriptors I Introduction Baroclinic instability is a significant contributor to the variability of mid-latitude weather. Baroclinic waves develop in a nearly geostrophic flow where the wind above the Ekman layer is blowing parallel to the temperature isotherms with a nonzero temperature gradient across the flow. This gradient produces a vertical shear in the geostrophic flow that becomes unstable when a critical threshold of the temperature gradient is exceeded. Then a small initial perturbation superimposed on the flow will grow, and this situation is known as a state of baroclinic instability Pedlosky 1989 . In the atmosphere, this instability often occurs in the mid-latitudes, between 30 and 60 degrees latitude, where the polar air mass meets the warmer subtropical air mass. This instability is responsible for most of the day-to-day variability in weather in mid-latitude regions and plays a fundamental role also for non-terrestrial planetary atmospheres Read et al. 2020 . The wave patterns of the mid-latitude weather typically have a frontal system with warm and cold fronts and are associated with rain, snow, wind, and changes in temperature. To understand this instability and how the atmospheric circulation transports heat from equatorial to polar latitudes in the mid-latitude dynamics of the Earth’s atmosphere, an elegant laboratory experiment was designed in the 1950s Fowlis and Hide 1965 . This experiment consists of a differentially heated rotating annulus where a jet is indirectly forced by a radial temperature gradient. The jet is baroclinically unstable and has many features in common with the jets in planetary atmospheres Read, Sommeria, and Young 2019 since baroclinic waves dominate the experimental flow. The experiment contains a cylinder with a cooled inner and heated outer wall placed on a rotating platform. Although the cylindrical geometry differs from the sphere, the differential heating mimics the Earth’s temperature difference between the tropics and the poles. Different wave regimes have been identified in this setting depending on the strength of the heating and the rate of rotation. These can be classified by pro-grade propagating waves of different wavenumbers and quasi-chaotic regimes where waves and small-scale vortices coexist. Over the years many aspects of atmospheric flows have been covered using the rotating annulus experiment. During the first years linear baroclinic instability was identified as a key process of large-scale dynamics Fowlis and Hide 1965 . Moreover, nonlinear regime transitions and bifurcations to chaotic flows have been analyzed Morita 1990 . Of interest was also the nonlinear saturation of baroclinic waves Hart 1981 , wave-mean flow, and wave-wave interactions Früh and Read 1997 . Also vascillations and low-frequency variability Lindzen, Farrell, and Jacqmin 1981 have been investigated intensively. Recently, secondary instabilities of the baroclinic jet and the generation of internal gravity waves have been studied Rodda and Harlander 2020 . The studies have been done with a flat bottom (f-plane) or with a bottom cone leading to a linear increase of fluid depth towards the outer cylinder Vincze et al. 2014 . The latter is called topographic \beta -plane and it simulates the Earth’s changing Coriolis parameter with latitude ( \beta -plane). A review of findings from the differentially heated rotating annulus experiment summarizing many aspects mentioned above can be found in Read et al. 2014 . When baroclinic waves develop, either in the atmosphere, the ocean, or lab experiments, they give rise to mixing and heat transport phenomena across the jet stream. Experimental studies have been conducted to investigate the intricate interactions between the baroclinic waves, mixing, and the transport of heat or other tracers across these jets. For instance, Sommeria, Meyers, and Swinney 1989 injected dye in the fluid of a rotating annulus to show that the jet acts as a barrier to tracer transport, similar to the southern stratospheric polar night jet may act as a barrier to the transport of trace gases from lower to polar latitudes. They reveal a striking barrier to mixing across the jet and such barriers prohibit trajectories from crossing the meandering jet flow. In Keane, Read, and King 2014 , stirring properties of the rotating annulus flow were investigated showing that finite scale Lyapunov exponents correctly identify barriers between different flow regimes. These studies connect well to others like Joseph and Legras 2002 ; de la Cámara et al. 2010 ; de la Cámara et al. 2012a ; de la Cámara et al. 2013 ; García-Garrido et al. 2017 ; Curbelo et al. 2017 ; Curbelo et al. 2019a ; Curbelo et al. 2019b exploring transport and mixing phenomena occurring in the antarctic polar vortex in the southern stratosphere using reanalysis data. Additional experiments on mixing on azimuthal jets in a rapidly rotating annular tank have also been performed in Behringer, Meyers, and Swinney 1991 . This paper aims to study this phenomenon further, both from the experimental and theoretical point of view. The experimental setup, as is usually done in this field, \textcolor blackconsists of a rotating annulus experiment with differential heating in the radial direction achieved by cooling the vertical interior and heating the vertical exterior wall. Recently, some variations with respect to the thermal forcing has been discussed Scolan and Read 2017 ; Swarnakar, Bhattacharya, and Balasubramanian 2023 that show some interesting new phenomena. However, as a distinctive feature in our case, the measuring instruments will simultaneously collect the temperature of the surface and the horizontal velocity in a horizontal plane below it. In order to examine the experimental results from a theoretical perspective, we will adopt simplified models that effectively capture the essential characteristics of baroclinic instability and the associated transport phenomena. Rather than solving the complete set of governing equations, these simplified models provide a framework to analyze and understand the key features of the system. By employing such models, we can focus on the fundamental dynamics and gain insights into the mechanisms underlying baroclinic instability and the transport processes occurring across it. Among the simplified models employed