Irreducible Three–Loop Vacuum–Polarization Correction in Muonic Bound Systems
Gregory S. Adkins, Ulrich D. Jentschura · 2024
Read Irreducible Three–Loop Vacuum–Polarization Correction in Muonic Bound Systems by Gregory S. Adkins, Ulrich D. Jentschura (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-17535.txt.
Introduction
Gregory Adkins and Ulrich Jentschura tackle a fine correction in atomic physics in a 2024 paper. They study muonic bound systems, where a heavy muon orbits a nucleus. Tiny shifts in energy levels test how well theory matches nature. Their target is a three-loop effect from empty space itself.
They compute the part of that effect that cannot be broken into simpler pieces. The work covers light nuclei across a small range of charges. The shift turns out to be as large as other corrections that workers already take seriously. Their method also removes a source of doubt that troubled earlier calculations, making the result cleaner to use.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gregory S. Adkins, Ulrich D. Jentschura |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 27 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-17535
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Irreducible Three–Loop Vacuum–Polarization Correction in Muonic Bound Systems Gregory S. Adkins, Ulrich D. Jentschura Abstract Three-loop electronic vacuum-polarization corrections due to irreducible diagrams are evaluated for two-body muonic ions with nuclear charge numbers 1 ≤ Z ≤ 6 1\leq Z\leq 6 . The corrections are of order α 3 ( Z α ) 2 m r \alpha^{3}(Z\alpha)^{2}\,m_{r} , where α \alpha is the fine-structure constant and m r m_{r} is the reduced mass. Numerically, the energy corrections are found to be of the same order-of-magnitude as the largest of the order α 2 ( Z α ) 6 m r \alpha^{2}(Z\alpha)^{6}m_{r} corrections, and are thus phenomenologically interesting. Our method of calculation eliminates numerical uncertainty encountered in other approaches. I Introduction Energy corrections to bound states of muonic ions due to electronic vacuum-polarization effects are known to be numerically large, due to the smallness of the generalized Bohr radius of the muonic ions. For the n -loop energy shift E^{(n)} , one obtains the estimates E^{(n)}\sim\alpha^{n}(Z\alpha)^{2}\,m_{r} , where \alpha is the fine-structure constant, Z is the nuclear charge number, and m_{r} is the reduced mass of the two-body system. In particular, the two-loop vacuum-polarization contributions to the 2P – 2S energy shift in muonic hydrogen has recently been re-evaluated in Ref. [ 1 ] . From the irreducible two-loop diagrams, one obtains a contribution of 1.25298 meV [see Eq. (71) of Ref. [ 1 ] ], while, from the reducible diagram, one obtains 0.25495 meV [see Eq. (72) of Ref. [ 1 ] . These results confirm the two-loop corrections obtained in Ref. [ 2 ] . The sum of the two-loop contributions is about five times larger than the energy shift corresponding to the so-called proton radius puzzle [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . Hence, it is of interest to consider the three-loop vacuum polarization effect for the bound states in muonic ions. The scalar vacuum polarization function \Pi^{(3)}(q^{2}) describing the irreducible three-loop vacuum-polarization diagrams has been discussed in its asymptotic (short-distance, high q^{2} ) limit in the context of the Gell–Mann Low \psi function (see Ref. [ 6 ] ) and for the Callan–Symanzik renormalization group (see Ref. [ 7 ] ). The evaluation of three-loop vacuum-polarization corrections in bound systems relies on knowledge of \Pi^{(3)}(q^{2}) beyond the asymptotic (short-distance) regime. The three-loop vacuum polarization spectral density function {\rm Im}\big[\,\Pi^{(3)}_{\rm R}(q^{2})\big] has recently been evaluated analytically [ 8 ] . Using the spectral density, the full three-loop vacuum polarization function \Pi^{(3)}_{\rm R}(q^{2}) can be conveniently obtained using a subtracted dispersion relation. For muonic bound states, the evaluation of three-loop energy corrections has been discussed in Refs. [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] . Here, we are concerned with the evaluation of the irreducible three-loop contribution, which, from the point of view of quantum field theory, probably constitutes the conceptually most interesting, gauge-invariant, subset of three-loop corrections. This paper is organized as follows. Some relevant properties of the spectral function of three-loop vacuum-polarization function are discussed in Sec. II , before we consider the numerical evaluation of the three-loop energy shifts in Sec. III . Conclusions are reserved for Sec. IV . We use natural units in this paper with \hbar=c=\epsilon_{0}=1 . In addition, we use the “West-Coast” convention for the space-time metric: g_{\mu\nu}={\rm diag}(1,-1,-1,-1) , where \mu,\nu=0,1,2,3 . Figure 1: The irreducible three-loop vacuum-polarization diagrams are shown, with the fermion lines denoting the virtual electrons and virtual positrons. Figure 2: The two-fermion threshold contribution to the imaginary part of the three-loop vacuum-polarization function is given as Q_{2m}(q^{2}) in Eq. ( 8 ). It has an integrable singularity at the threshold q^{2}=(2m_{e})^{2} [see Eq. ( 9 )]. Figure 3: Same as Fig. 2 , but for the four-fermion threshold contribution Q_{4m}(q^{2}) . It ramps up smoothly from the threshold at q^{2}=(4m_{e})^{2} [see Eq. ( 11 )]. Table 1: Three-loop energy shifts due to irreducible three-loop diagrams are given for muonic bound systems in the range 1\leq Z\leq 6 of nuclear charge numbers, given in units of meV. The numerical uncertainties are \pm 1 in the least significant digit shown. Bound System n nS nP nD nF \mu H n=1 -2.5148\times 10^{-2} — — — n=2 -2.6243\times 10^{-3} -6.5673\times 10^{-4} — — n=3 -7.5797\times 10^{-4} -2.0310\times 10^{-4} -1.0841\times 10^{-5} — n=4 -3.1704\times 10^{-4} -8.6759\times 10^{-5} -6.0104\times 10^{-6} -1.1495\times 10^{-7} \mu D n=1 -2.7476\times 10^{-2} — — — n=2 -2.8541\times 10^{-3} -7.7875\times 10^{-4} — — n=3 -8.2386\times 10^{-4} -2.3863\times 10^{-4} -1.4109\times 10^{-5} — n=4 -3.4454\times 10^{-4} -1.0167\times 10^{-4} -7.7703\times 10^{-6} -1.6478\times 10^{-7} \mu^{3} He n=1 -1.6343\times 10^{-1} — — — n=2 -1.8071\times 10^{-2} -1.2009\times 10^{-2} — — n=3 -5.0874\times 10^{-3} -3.1380\times 10^{-3} -7.0445\times 10^{-4} — n=4 -2.1163\times 10^{-3} -1.2868\times 10^{-3} -3.3621\times 10^{-4} -2.8701\times 10^{-5} \mu^{4} He n=1 -1.6550\times 10^{-1} — — — n=2 -1.8348\times 10^{-2} -1.2280\times 10^{-2} — — n=3 -5.1618\times 10^{-3} -3.2020\times 10^{-3} -7.3004\times 10^{-4} — n=4 -2.1470\times 10^{-3} -1.3124\times 10^{-3} -3.4757\times 10^{-4} -3.0182\times 10^{-5} \mu^{6} Li n=1 -4.3559\times 10^{-1} — — — n=2 -5.6686\times 10^{-2} -4.7059\times 10^{-2} — — n=3 -1.5350\times 10^{-2} -1.1362\times 10^{-2} -4.9511\times 10^{-3} — n=4 -6.3292\times 10^{-3} -4.5635\times 10^{-3} -2.0785\times 10^{-3} -3.8702\times 10^{-4} \mu^{7} Li n=1 -4.3712\times 10^{-1} — — — n=2 -5.6952\times 10^{-2} -4.7315\times 10^{-2} — — n=3 -1.5418\times 10^{-2} -1.1421\times 10^{-2} -4.9946\times 10^{-3} — n=4 -6.3569\times 10^{-3} -4.5864\times 10^{-3} -2.0950\times 10^{-3} -3.9191\times 10^{-4} \mu^{9} Be n=1 -8.5559\times 10^{-1} — — — n=2 -1.2644\times 10^{-1} -1.1033\times 10^{-1} — — n=3 -3.3769\times 10^{-2} -2.6421\times 10^{-2} -1.6351\times 10^{-2} — n=4 -1.3764\times 10^{-2} -1.0410\times 10^{-2} -6.2674\times 10^{-3} -1.9036\times 10^{-3} \mu^{10} Be n=1 -8.5699\times 10^{-1} — — — n=2 -1.2672\times 10^{-1} -1.1057\times 10^{-1} — — n=3 -3.3842\times 10^{-2} -2.6482\times 10^{-2} -1.6410\times 10^{-2} — n=4 -1.3793\times 10^{-2} -1.0433\times 10^{-2} -6.2875\times 10^{-3} -1.9134\times 10^{-3} \mu^{10} B n=1 -1.4392\times 10^{0} — — — n=2 -2.3119\times 10^{-1} -2.0220\times 10^{-1} — — n=3 -6.2396\times 10^{-2} -4.9895\times 10^{-2} -3.7513\times 10^{-2} — n=4 -2.5110\times 10^{-2} -1.9292\times 10^{-2} -1.3586\times 10^{-2} -5.7294\times 10^{-3} \mu^{11} B n=1 -1.4411\times 10^{0} — — — n=2 -2.3158\times 10^{-1} -2.0253\times 10^{-1} — — n=3 -6.2507\times 10^{-2} -4.9987\times 10^{-2} -3.7610\times 10^{-2} — n=4 -2.5153\times 10^{-2} -1.9326\times 10^{-2} -1.3619\times 10^{-2} -5.7509\times 10^{-3} \mu^{12} C n=1 -2.2111\times 10^{0} — — — n=2 -3.7447\times 10^{-1} -3.2349\times 10^{-1} — — n=3 -1.0354\times 10^{-1} -8.3630\times 10^{-2} -7.0401\times 10^{-2} — n=4 -4.1215\times 10^{-2} -3.1862\times 10^{-2} -2.4732\times 10^{-2} -1.3145\times 10^{-2} \mu^{13} C n=1 -2.2132\times 10^{0} — — — n=2 -3.7490\times 10^{-1} -3.2384\times 10^{-1} — — n=3 -1.0368\times 10^{-1} -8.3739\times 10^{-2} -7.0519\times 10^{-2} — n=4 -4.1266\times 10^{-2} -3.1902\times 10^{-2} -2.4772\times 10^{-2} -1.3177\times 10^{-2} II Analytic Derivation Our calculations make extensive use of the spectral function of three-loop vacuum polarization, which was recently obtained expressed in terms of generalized polylogarithms in Ref. [ 8 ] . The irreducible three-loop diagrams are shown in Fig. 1 . We use the vacuum-polarization function in the conventions of Ref. [ 1 ] and assume it to be renormalized on-shell so that \Pi_{\rm R}(0)=0 . We consider the expansion \Pi_{\rm R}(q^{2})=\Pi_{\rm R}^{(1)}(q^{2})+\Pi_{\rm R}^{(2)}(q^{2})+\Pi_{\rm R}^{(3)}(q^{2})+\dots\,, (1) where the superscript denotes the loop order. Each order separately fulfills the subtracted dispersion relation \Pi_{\rm R}^{(n)}(q^{2})=\frac{q^{2}}{\pi}\int_{4m_{e}^{2}}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}q^{\prime 2}\frac{{\rm Im}\,\big[\Pi^{(n)}_{\rm R}(q^{\prime 2}+\mathrm{i}\epsilon)\big]}{q^{\prime 2}(q^{\prime 2}-q^{2})}\,. (2) where care has been taken to fulfill the condition that \Pi_{\rm R}^{(n)}(q^{2}) needs to vanish for zero q^{2} . We