Optimal Convergence Rates for Neural Operators

Mike Nguyen, Nicole Mücke · 2024

Read Optimal Convergence Rates for Neural Operators by Mike Nguyen, Nicole Mücke (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-17518.txt.

Introduction

Mike Nguyen and Nicole Mücke analyze how fast two-layer neural operators learn, using the neural tangent kernel framework. Neural operators are used as fast stand-ins for the solution maps of partial differential equations. Good theory for their generalization has lagged behind practice.

Working in the kernel regime, the authors derive convergence rates for early-stopped gradient descent that match known optimal rates in kernel regression. They also bound how many hidden neurons and second-stage samples are needed. A supporting result shows any operator a neural operator can approximate also lies within reach of the kernel space. Simulations on the Poisson equation illustrate the theory.

Catalog record

CREATORMike Nguyen, Nicole Mücke
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE195 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-17518

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Optimal Convergence Rates for Neural Operators Mike Nguyen, Nicole Mücke Abstract We introduce the neural tangent kernel (NTK) regime for two-layer neural operators and analyze their generalization properties. For early-stopped gradient descent (GD), we derive fast convergence rates that are known to be minimax optimal within the framework of non-parametric regression in reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces (RKHS). We provide bounds on the number of hidden neurons and the number of second-stage samples necessary for generalization. To justify our NTK regime, we additionally show that any operator approximable by a neural operator can also be approximated by an operator from the RKHS. A key application of neural operators is learning surrogate maps for the solution operators of partial differential equations (PDEs). We consider the standard Poisson equation to illustrate our theoretical findings with simulations. 1 Introduction Operator learning has emerged as a transformative methodology in machine learning, focusing on learning mappings between spaces of functions. This approach is particularly powerful for surrogate modeling tasks in fields like uncertainty quantification, inverse problems, and design optimization, where the goal often involves approximating complex operators, such as the solution operator of partial differential equations (PDEs). Learning linear operators. A classical field where learning linear operators arises is functional data analysis (FDA), particularly in functional linear regression with functional responses, also known as function-to-function regression. FDA focuses on understanding and modeling data best described as functions rather than discrete points. Unlike traditional data, where observations might be scalar or vector-valued, functional data are represented by smooth curves, surfaces, or other continuous objects. These functions are typically observed over a continuum, such as time, space, or wavelength, and are inherently infinite-dimensional ( Febrero-Bande et al., 2024 ; Morris, 2015 ) . The model can be seen as a generalization of multivariate regression, where the regression coefficient is now an unknown operator. A standard approach to this problem involves applying Tikhonov regularization (see Benatia et al. (2017) ), with classical rates of convergence resembling a typical bias-variance trade-off. The framework of learning operators extends naturally to nonparametric approaches, such as conditional mean embeddings (CMEs) in reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces (RKHS). In these settings, the goal is to represent conditional distributions as operators acting on functions, enabling the integration of probabilistic modeling with functional data analysis ( Klebanov et al., 2020 ; Park and Muandet, 2020 ; Grünewälder et al., 2012 ) . Conditional mean embeddings generalize the idea of representing conditional expectations as operators in RKHS, bridging the gap between statistical learning of distributions and operator learning. In Li et al. (2022) classical Tikhonov regularization has also been analyzed in this setting, and optimal convergence rates have been established. These approaches have inspired further research, as highlighted in Mollenhauer et al. (2022) , where the problem of learning linear operators is placed into the broader framework of supervised learning in random design and analyzed through the family of spectral regularization methods, encompassing the earlier examples as special cases. This line of work is advanced in Meunier et al. (2024) and Li et al. (2024) , which establish upper bounds for the finite-sample risk of general vector-valued spectral algorithms. These results are applicable to both well-specified and misspecified scenarios, where the true regression function may lie outside the hypothesis space, and achieve minimax optimality across various regimes. Learning non-linear operators. The extension of linear techniques for operator learning into non-linear contexts has been realized through innovative approaches incorporating neural networks, enabling greater flexibility and efficiency in handling complex functional relationships. In Shimizu et al. (2024) , the authors introduce a method that integrates deep learning into CME by leveraging an end-to-end neural network (NN) optimization framework. The approach replaces the computationally expensive Gram matrix inversion required in traditional CME methods with a kernel-based objective, significantly improving scalability and computational efficiency. For non-linear function-on-function regression, Rao and Reimherr (2023) proposes a novel framework featuring a continuous hidden layer with continuous neurons to model functional responses. Two strategies, function-on-function direct neural networks and function-on-function basis neural networks, are developed to enhance flexibility in modeling complex functional relationships. While demonstrating strong empirical performance through simulations and real data applications, this method lacks theoretical learning guarantees. Shi et al. (2024) presents a functional deep neural network architecture with a fully data-dependent dimension reduction strategy. The architecture comprises three steps: a kernel embedding for integral transformation using a smooth, data-driven kernel; a projection step using eigenfunction bases for dimension reduction; and a deep ReLU network for prediction. This approach is accompanied by theoretical analyses, including approximation and generalization error bounds, providing robust theoretical support for the method. These developments highlight the significant advancements in non-linear operator learning, driven by neural network-based frameworks that blend theoretical rigor with practical flexibility and scalability. Another key application area for learning non-linear operators mapping between function spaces is solving partial differential equations (PDEs), where the solution operators that connect initial or boundary conditions to the PDE’s solution are of particular interest ( Boullé and Townsend, 2023 ) . Understanding and approximating these operators is essential, as they encapsulate the underlying dynamics of the system being studied ( Gonon et al., 2024 ; Tarantola, 2005 ) . Traditional approaches for approximating operators, especially for solving PDEs, have been well-established for decades. Techniques such as the Finite Element Method (FEM), Finite Difference Method (FDM), and Finite Volume Method (FVM) are classical methods employed to estimate these operators ( Hughes, 2003 ) . These methods discretize the problem space into manageable subdomains, enabling numerical approximations of the solution. While highly effective, they have notable limitations. A primary drawback is their computational cost, which increases exponentially with the problem’s dimensionality, a phenomenon known as the curse of dimensionality. Additionally, these methods require detailed discretization of the underlying function space, which can be challenging to achieve for high-dimensional or complex geometries. Another significant challenge arises when dealing with inverse problems or noisy data, where classical methods often struggle with stability and robustness ( Strang and Fix, 1973 ) . As a result, there has been a growing interest in novel operator estimation techniques that incorporate machine learning, and more specifically, neural networks. Neural networks offer the capability to learn complex patterns and relationships from data, making them well-suited for operator learning tasks that might be intractable via traditional methods Goodfellow et al. (2016) . A particularly intriguing development is the emergence of neural network-based operator learning techniques, which can be broadly categorized into ”encoder/decoder” architectures and neural operators. Both categories of methods have demonstrated remarkable success in operator learning, showcasing their ability to handle high-dimensional inputs, complex geometries, and noisy data. Encoder/Decoder Operators. This framework typically involves three key stages: encoding the input function into a finite-dimensional parameter space, mapping these parameters using neural network architectures, and subsequently decoding the parameters back into a functional representation. The encoding phase often employs parameterization techniques where the function is projected onto a lower-dimensional basis, allowing for computationally feasible manipulation. Spectral Neural Operators represent a prominent example utilize transformations such as Fourier or wavelet transforms to convert input functions into spectral coefficients, delivering notable robustness and efficiency, particularly in scenarios featuring periodic behaviors Fanaskov and Oseledets (2024) . In parallel, PCA Operators utilize Principal Component

Read the complete text