The Unique Helium Nova V445 Puppis Ejected ≫ \gg 0.001 M ⊙ in the Year 2000 and Will Not Become a Type Ia Supernova Facilities: DASCH, ZTF, APASS, AAVSO, TESS
Bradley E. Schaefer · 2024
Read The Unique Helium Nova V445 Puppis Ejected ≫ \gg 0.001 M ⊙ in the Year 2000 and Will Not Become a Type Ia Supernova Facilities: DASCH, ZTF, APASS, AAVSO, TESS by Bradley E. Schaefer (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-17286.txt.
Introduction
Bradley Schaefer studies V445 Puppis, the only known helium nova, in a 2024 paper. In such a star, helium-rich gas piles onto a white dwarf until it burns in a flash. Some had hoped this path could end in a Type Ia supernova. Schaefer pulls a long record of sky data to weigh the star and track its orbit.
The orbit runs near 1.87 days, and the partner star is a swollen giant stripped of its outer hydrogen. The orbit grew a touch longer across the 2000 burst. That shift means the burst threw off far more mass than the dwarf had gained. So the dwarf loses mass each cycle and cannot grow toward a supernova. A check of 136 normal Type Ia blasts, none with a giant partner, backs the same verdict.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bradley E. Schaefer |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-17286
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Unique Helium Nova V445 Puppis Ejected ≫ \gg 0.001 M ⊙ in the Year 2000 and Will Not Become a Type Ia Supernova Facilities: DASCH, ZTF, APASS, AAVSO, TESS Bradley E. Schaefer Abstract V445 Puppis is the only known example of a helium nova, where a layer of helium-rich gas accretes onto the surface of a white dwarf in a cataclysmic variable, with runaway helium burning making for the nova event. Speculatively, helium nova can provide one path to produce a Type Ia supernova (SNIa), within the larger framework of single-degenerate models. Relatively little has been known about V445 Pup, with this work reporting the discovery of the orbital period near 1.87 days. The companion star is 2.65 ± \pm 0.35 R ⊙ in radius as an evolved giant star stripped of its outer hydrogen envelope. The orbital period immediately before the 2000 eruption was P pre P_{\rm pre} =1.871843 ± \pm 0.000014 days, with a steady period change of (-0.17 ± \pm 0.06) × \times 10 -8 from 1896–1995. The period immediately after the nova eruption was P post P_{\rm post} =1.873593 ± \pm 0.000034 days, with a P ˙ \dot{P} of ( − - 4.7 ± \pm 0.5) × \times 10 -8 . The fractional orbital period change ( Δ P / P \Delta P/P ) is + + 935 ± \pm 27 ppm. This restricts the mass of the gases ejected in the nova eruption to be ≫ \gg 0.001M ⊙ , and much greater than the mass accreted to trigger the nova. So the white dwarf is losing mass over each eruption cycle, and will not become a SNIa. Further, for V445 Pup and helium novae in general, I collect observations from 136 normal SNIa, for which any giant or sub-giant companion star would have been detected, yet zero companions are found. This is an independent proof that V445 Pup and helium novae are not SNIa progenitors. I Introduction With insight, the existence, nature, and properties of ‘helium novae’ were predicted in 1989 by Kato, Saio, & Hachisu (1989). The idea is that a white dwarf (WD) in a cataclysmic variable (CV) might accrete helium-rich gas, which accumulates until a helium shell flash powers a normal-looking nova eruption. The accumulated helium might come from accretion off a giant star stripped of its outer hydrogen-rich envelope, or from a degenerate star made mostly of helium (like for an AM CVn star). The ejecta of a helium nova should be essentially hydrogen-free. Helium novae might be a separate path to create a Type Ia supernova (SNIa), see Kato & Hachisu (2003) and Kato et al. (2008). One of the premier open questions in modern astrophysics concerns the nature of the progenitors of normal SNIa systems (the Progenitor Problem), see Maoz, Filippo, & Nelemans (2014) for a review. The progenitors certainly are a close binary star with one member being a CO WD. One popular solution to the Progenitor Problem is that the companion star of the CO WD is a second WD, hence there are two degenerate stars in the binary for the so-called double-degenerate (DD) model. The other popular solution is to have the companion being a normal non-degenerate star, hence the binary has only one degenerate star for a so-called single-degenerate (SD) model. V445 Pup (Nova Puppis 2000) was discovered in eruption on 30 December 2000 by K. Kanatsu (Kanatsu 2000). Prediscovery images show the star to be in quiescence up until 26 September 2000, and at 8.8 mag (nearly the discovery magnitude) on 23 November (Ashok & Banerjee 2003). The peak magnitude might be near 8.8 or possibly substantially brighter. The eruption spectra were startling for the utter lack of any hydrogen lines, and this is the key point for identifying V445 Pup as a helium nova (Kato & Hachisu 2003). Otherwise, the strong emission lines of various metals resembles that of slow novae. The light curve faded from peak by 3 magnitudes ( t_{3} ) in 240 days, like for slow novae. In February 2004 at McDonald Observatory, while seeking a photometric time series to discover an orbital period, I was startled to find that V445 Pup appeared \sim 6 mags fainter in the R band than before the nova eruption. V445 Pup had gone into a dust-dip (like for DQ Her and for D-class novae) caused by dust formation in the dense ejecta. Startlingly, this dust dip was uniquely and extraordinarily deep (getting to 6 mag fainter than pre-eruption) and long lasting (it has only recovered to V =17 even 24 years later). So the ejected shell must be very massive. Startlingly, Woudt et al. (2009) found a fast-expanding finely-structured symmetrical bipolar nebula, expanding at speeds up to 8450 km s -1 . This places the Earth close to the equatorial dust disk, which causes the deep dust dip. In all, we have a unique and extreme nova, with V445 Pup being the only known example of a helium nova. Other than the recognition as a helium nova, little is known about the fundamental nature of V445 Pup. The orbital period is not known 1 1 1 Goranskij et al. (2010) used old plates from Moscow and Sonneberg to claim a periodicity of 0.650654 days. But this is just one peak amongst 15 roughly-equal alias peaks ranging from 0.39 to 3.74 days, with plotted folded light curves for most. Their chosen alias was selected because they liked the Lafler-Kinman periodogram and they saw an insignificant dip that they took to be an eclipse. . Modelers (Kato et al. 2008, Shen & Bildsten 2009, Brooks et al. 2015) expect orbital periods from roughly one hour (for AM CVn systems) to several days (for stripped giant companions). The distance is poorly determined. The spectral energy distribution (SED) of the pre-eruption star has been variously fit to that of an A0 V star (Goranskij et al. 2010) or an accretion disk (Ashok & Banerjee 2003), but this was constructed with magnitudes from 5 widely separated times, such that the plot is disjointed and can only be a bad fit to any blackbody or power law. Rather, the only useable information is that the SED does not suffer any large turnover in the B -band, so the stellar temperature of the companion must be > 10,000 K. The mass of the dust formed in the ejecta has been estimated from the infrared flux (Ashok & Banerjee 2003, Lynch et al. 2004, Banerjee et al. 2023), but any such estimate has uncertainties of > 3 orders-of-magnitude due to the usual uncertainties in dust temperature, distance, as well as the dust composition and size distribution. Further, to go from any such badly-known measure of the dust mass to the mass of the ejecta would require a dust fraction that is uncertain by orders of magnitude. Goranskij et al. (2010) were even suggesting that the original WD had been completely destroyed by the nova eruption. As the only known example of a helium nova, V445 Pup has long excited theorists anxious to find an SD progenitor (e.g., McCully et al. 2014, Kool et al. 2023). But there has been no useful observational advance since 2010. Kato et al.