“From Unseen Needs to Classroom Solutions”: Exploring AI Literacy Challenges & Opportunities with Project-Based Learning Toolkit in K-12 Education

Hanqi Li, Ruiwei Xiao, Hsuan Nieu, Ying-Jui Tseng, Guanze Liao · 2024

Read “From Unseen Needs to Classroom Solutions”: Exploring AI Literacy Challenges & Opportunities with Project-Based Learning Toolkit in K-12 Education by Hanqi Li, Ruiwei Xiao, Hsuan Nieu, Ying-Jui Tseng, Guanze Liao (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-17243.txt.

Introduction

Hanqi Li and co-authors wrote a 2024 paper on teaching AI literacy across school subjects with a project based toolkit. The team talked with teachers and co-designed lessons using art, music, and chatbot labs. Teachers liked how the tools sparked creative and critical work.

They also worried about wrong or untrustworthy AI output, and about ethics in class. Gaps in time, gear, and skill, for staff and students alike, limit what can run. The authors distill what makers of school AI tools must fix: flexible kits that adapt to many subjects and skill levels, with honesty about limits built in.

Catalog record

CREATORHanqi Li, Ruiwei Xiao, Hsuan Nieu, Ying-Jui Tseng, Guanze Liao
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-17243

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

“From Unseen Needs to Classroom Solutions”: Exploring AI Literacy Challenges & Opportunities with Project-Based Learning Toolkit in K-12 Education Hanqi Li, Ruiwei Xiao, Hsuan Nieu, Ying-Jui Tseng, Guanze Liao Abstract As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes increasingly central to various fields, there is a growing need to equip K-12 students with AI literacy skills that extend beyond computer science. This paper explores the integration of a Project-Based Learning (PBL) AI toolkit into diverse subject areas, aimed at helping educators teach AI concepts more effectively. Through interviews and co-design sessions with K-12 teachers, we examined their current AI literacy levels and how these teachers adapt AI tools like the AI Art Lab, AI Music Studio, and AI Chatbot into their course designs. While teachers appreciated the potential of AI tools to foster creativity and critical thinking, they also expressed concerns about the accuracy, trustworthiness, and ethical implications of AI-generated content. Our findings reveal the challenges teachers face, including limited resources, varying student and instructor skill levels, and the need for scalable, adaptable AI tools. This research contributes insights that can inform the development of AI curricula tailored to diverse educational contexts. Figure 1: The AI Music Studio, one of our three Project-Based Learning (PBL) tools, enables students to generate customized music based on teacher-provided rubrics. (From left to right) Students first define the task objective and input the rubric, then personalize the content with key details (e.g., name, relationship, favorite qualities, and music genre). The system generates a song with audio playback and lyrics reflecting their inputs. A demo can be accessed on Figma ( https://shorturl.at/Ra5EQ ). Introduction As accessible Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools have gained increasing interest among K-12 educators in incorporating AI literacy into their classrooms. K-12 educators recognize the need to teach students about its capabilities and limitations ( Ng et al. 2023a ) . Existing AI education efforts focus on dedicated curricula and professional learning for teachers ( Amplo and Butler 2023 ; Lee and Perret 2022 ) . However, many teachers face challenges, such as limited AI knowledge, time constraints, and resource availability, especially outside of computer science classes ( Walsh et al. 2023 ; Song et al. 2022 ) . Scalable and adaptable resources are needed to help teachers incorporate AI into their lessons without requiring deep technical expertise. To address these challenges, the Active AI team explored the development of modular AI resources, combined with Project Based Learning (PBL), which has brought positive feedback in student learning ( Kong, Cheung, and Tsang 2024 ) , so that teachers can adapt to their subjects, allowing them to introduce AI literacy in more flexible units ( Tseng et al. 2024b ) . We conducted interview and co-design sessions with teachers from various backgrounds to investigate three key questions: • RQ1: What is the AI literacy level of K-12 teachers? • RQ2: How do IT and interdisciplinary course instructors design lesson plans using our PBL toolkit? • RQ3: How do differences in teachers’ and students’ backgrounds influence their perspectives on AI tools, student performance, and course design? To answer these questions, this paper presents a formative empirical evaluation of teachers’ perspectives on AI literacy, providing insights that can inform the development of adaptable AI tools to support AI literacy education across diverse subject areas. Related Works AI Literacy Curriculum As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes increasingly integral to a wide array of applications, it is essential for K–12 students to understand how to interact with these technologies and recognize their capabilities and limitations ( Ng et al. 2023a ; Eguchi, Okada, and Muto 2021 ) . Prior work has investigated AI curricula beyond computer science and programming, focusing on creative, human-centered aspects of AI ( Eaton et al. 2018 ; Walsh et al. 2023 ) . These cross-disciplinary AI curricula aim to make AI education more accessible to students from various backgrounds. Many researchers have launched co-design collaborations to develop AI literacy curricula ( Williams et al. 2023 ; Amplo and Butler 2023 ; Bilstrup et al. 2022 ) . Amplo and Butler 2023 highlighted the importance of profound collaborations with teachers, where educators play an active role in shaping the curriculum while gaining more knowledge about the field. Such partnerships empower teachers as creators that could tailor new curricula to student needs and interests, instead of just implementers of AI curricula ( Lee and Perret 2022 ; DiPaola et al. 2023 ) . For example, Walsh et al. 2023 found that literacy and STEM teachers with minimal AI experience were able to adapt an AI ethics curriculum, suggesting that AI knowledge is not a prerequisite for curricular co-design. Co-designing AI education curricula with cross-disciplinary high school teachers has been shown to enhance the relevance and adaptability of the curriculum ( Lin and Van Brummelen 2021 ) . Lin and Van Brummelen 2021 also engaged teachers to co-design integrated AI curricula for K-12 classrooms and found that teachers need additional scaffolding in AI tools and curriculum to facilitate ethics and data discussions, and value supports for learner evaluation and engagement, peer-to-peer collaboration, and critical reflection. Project-Based Learning in AI Literacy Project-Based Learning (PBL) is an active, student-centered form of instruction characterized by autonomy, constructive investigations, goal-setting, collaboration, communication, and reflection within real-world practices ( Kokotsaki, Menzies, and Wiggins 2016 ; Condliffe 2017 ) . Collaborative PBL, which combines interdisciplinary problem-solving and artifact creation, is a common approach in AI literacy education. ( Ng et al. 2023b ; Tseng et al. 2024a ) . Several studies have implemented PBL in AI literacy education with positive outcomes. Kong, Cheung, and Tsang 2024 developed an AI literacy framework and evaluated a literacy course for senior secondary students using a PBL approach, finding that students improved in AI problem-solving ability, empowerment, and ethical understanding. Jeon 2023 investigated middle school students’ AI literacy through a PBL program and confirmed efficacy in both cognitive and affective gains. Ng, Su, and Chu 2024 fostered secondary school students’ AI literacy through making AI-driven recycling bins in a PBL intervention, demonstrating positive impacts on motivation, AI literacy, and collaboration. However, many AI literacy PBL implementations are not scalable due to resource constraints, lack of trained educators, and the complexity of AI topics ( Walsh et al. 2023 ) . Song et al. 2022 highlighted that AI knowledge and technical skills are limited not only for students but also for school teachers, especially in rural areas. Druga et al. ( Druga, Otero, and Ko 2022 ) proposed that future AI curricula move from singular activities and demos to more holistic designs that include support, guidance, and flexibility for how AI technology, concepts, and pedagogy play out in the classroom. Researchers also emphasized the need for sustainable approaches to inform the planning of quality AI curricula, as educators and experts have found designing AI-related curricula a challenge ( Chiu 2021 ; Cu and Fujimoto 2022 ) . Our research aims to bridge this gap by developing a high-fidelity prototype that serves as a tangible interface for facilitating teacher interviews. The toolkit is designed to generate hands-on PBL AI tool exploration activities that teachers can seamlessly integrate into their lesson plans, regardless of their prior AI experience. This approach promotes accessible

Read the complete text