Projections and teleportation of operator quenches in CFT

Zsolt Gyongyosi, Timothy J. Hollowood and S. Prem Kumar · 2024

Read Projections and teleportation of operator quenches in CFT by Zsolt Gyongyosi, Timothy J. Hollowood and S. Prem Kumar (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-17059.txt.

Introduction

Zsolt Gyongyosi, Timothy Hollowood, and Prem Kumar study teleportation after a local jolt in a two-dimensional field theory in two thousand twenty-four. New black hole ideas use maps that shrink space and post-picked outcomes to recover lost information. The authors build a lab-like test of that idea inside conformal field theory.

A local operator jolt is paired with a projection of part of space onto a special boundary state. Math maps turn the setup into a theory with a boundary, where entropies can be computed two ways. The two systems act in distinct ways. Entropy results show a surprise pattern in the replica count: teleportation does occur, but not at the best rate, since the projector is not tuned for it.

Catalog record

CREATORZsolt Gyongyosi, Timothy J. Hollowood and S. Prem Kumar
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE74 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-17059

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Projections and teleportation of operator quenches in CFT Zsolt Gyongyosi, Timothy J. Hollowood and S. Prem Kumar Abstract Motivated by recent proposals for information recovery from black holes via non-isometric maps and post-selection in an effective description, we set up and investigate a teleportation scenario in a 2d CFT involving a local operator quench and projection on a portion of space onto a Cardy state with the theory in the vacuum state. Using conformal invariance the system can be mapped to CFT with boundary (BCFT). Rényi entropies for spatial intervals in the projected state can then be computed as a function of the location of the quench, either using the replica method, or using twist fields, the latter employing universal results for correlators at large c c . We find qualitatively distinct behaviours in the two systems. Our replica computations reveal a surprising universal n n dependence of Rényi entropies which implies that teleportation does occur but is not optimal as would be expected because the projector is not especially tuned. We also find that the curious n n dependence of the Rényi entropies means that the limit to the von Neumann entropy is not straightforward. 1 Introduction One approach to resolving the black hole information loss paradox is the so-called ‘final state proposal’ of Horowitz and Maldacena [ 2 ] (see also [ 3 ] for a thorough analysis). The idea is that at the level of the effective theory, on a Cauchy slice that includes what would be the classical singularity there is a projection on the quantum state along the singularity onto a maximally mixed state of the infalling modes \bar{V} (left-moving on the Penrose diagram) and the infalling partners P of the outgoing Hawking modes A (right-moving on the Penrose diagram): see figure 1 . Since the infalling partner modes P and the outgoing Hawking modes A are entangled, such a projection has the effect of teleporting the infalling quantum state to the outgoing Hawking radiation and so the ‘information’ of the infalling modes is returned via the radiation. A rather puzzling feature is that in order for the teleportation to be 100% efficient requires a very specific type of projector that is tuned to the entangled state of the A and P modes. Of course, such a projection violates the usual rules of quantum mechanics and leads to the instantaneous, acausal transfer of quantum information out of the black hole. 1 1 1 This is unlike the teleportation protocol in quantum mechanics which involves a measurement, and so a family of projections (in the simplest case) that can all be realized with certain probabilities. Since all possibilities are summed over, for a causally separated observer, there is no breakdown of casuality in this case. It is only after the measurement result has been revealed and then communicated is it meaningful to post select the state. For a single projection, the state of a causally separated observer can be instantaneously changed. \mathscr{I}^{+} \mathscr{I}^{-} horizon singularity entanglement A P \bar{V} Figure 1 : The diagram shows an outgoing Hawking mode A and its entangled partner P falling into the singularity. There is an infalling system \bar{V} . In the final state projection scenario, a projection at the singularity onto a maximally mixed state of P and \bar{V} teleports the state of \bar{V} to the outgoing Hawking radiation A . A refinement of the idea of final state projection, has recently been proposed in [ 4 ] . This more recent work provides a reason why the effective theory would be subject to a projection even when the underlying microscopic description is perfectly consistent with unitarity and also naturally solves the puzzle of the specificity of the projector. In order to understand this, we need to think how the effective theory is related to the microscopic theory at the level of a Hilbert space description. One would expect that the Hilbert space of the effective theory {\cal H}_{\text{eff}} is mapped into the Hilbert space of the microscopic theory {\cal H}_{\text{micro}} . Usually one would expect that this map, V , would be isometric , so preserving inner products. The intuition being that {\cal H}_{\text{micro}} would be expected to be vastly bigger than {\cal H}_{\text{eff}} . It is this intuition that breaks down for an evaporating black hole. As the black hole evaporates {\cal H}_{\text{micro}} , with dimension order e^{S_{\text{BH}}} , is reducing while the dimension of {\cal H}_{\text{eff}} is order e^{S_{\text{rad}}} , where S_{\text{rad}} is the entropy of the radiation. It is precisely at the Page time that the dimension of the microscopic Hilbert space is actually smaller than the space needed to describe the semi-classical excitations on the black hole interior: something must give. The map V cannot preserve the inner product of states and so is actually a non-isometric map. A non-isometric map can be realized as a unitary map followed by a projection. So once again we have a projection which can teleport information from the infalling state to the Hawking radiation. What is novel is that in this scenario the projections occur in an ongoing fashion, little-by-little, as the black hole evaporates rather than at the singularity. It is particularly noteworthy that, the fact that there is a perfectly unitary microscopic description implies that at the effective level, teleportation occurs with prefect efficacy. The original final state hypothesis and its refinement in the effective theory motivate us to investigate projections in QFT and specifically their ability to teleport information between causally disconnected regions. Rather remarkably, as described initially in [ 5 , 6 ] and then in [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] , certain kinds of projections on some local region can be described in conformal field theories (CFTs) in 1+1 dimensions by using conformal transformation to map the projection set-up to a boundary conformal field theory (BCFT) set-up which have been thoroughly explored (e.g. see monograph [ 10 ] ). In this set up, the projections are to a special set of states in the CFT known as Cardy states [ 11 ] . These states are rather remarkable in that, unlike the vacuum state, they have no spatial entanglement, rather they have maximal entanglement between the chiral and anti-chiral sectors, or between the left- and right-moving sectors in Minkowski space [ 12 ] . In this sense, they are analogue of the final state projectors in the black hole scenario which are maximally entangled between the infalling modes \bar{V} (so left-moving in figure 1 ) and the partners of the Hawking modes P (so right-moving in figure 1 ). In order to understand how projections can lead to the non-local flow of quantum information, we will consider their effect on an ‘operator quench’ [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] . Before delving into the field theory scenario, let us describe how this works in the context of finite dimensional quantum system. In the model, there is a quantum system, which consists of two subsystems A and P , in a pure entangled state |\psi\rangle . There is an additional quantum system \bar{V} , the analogue of the infalling system in the state |\gamma\rangle . We then act

Read the complete text