Quantum coherence and the invisible Universe: Subradiance as a dark matter mechanism
Martin Houde, Fereshteh Rajabi · 2024
Read Quantum coherence and the invisible Universe: Subradiance as a dark matter mechanism by Martin Houde, Fereshteh Rajabi (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-16663.txt.
Introduction
Martin Houde and co-authors float a startling candidate for dark matter: ordinary hydrogen that quantum teamwork renders invisible, in a 2024 paper. Galactic halos hold far more mass than their light explains. The authors show that hydrogen atoms in a warm gas, entangled together, can fall into subradiance, a cooperative state that suppresses their glow.
A subradiant gas hits dark matter's three tells at once: it does not emit, it lets passing light through, and it barely collides. Applied to hydrogen's twenty-one centimeter line in halo conditions, the suppressed emission and absorption cancel almost exactly. Cold cores of high-velocity clouds fit the picture, with temperatures near one hundred degrees and inferred dark-to-visible ratios around a hundred to one. The proposal needs no new particle, only familiar atoms behaving collectively.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Martin Houde, Fereshteh Rajabi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 85 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-16663
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum coherence and the invisible Universe: Subradiance as a dark matter mechanism Martin Houde, Fereshteh Rajabi Abstract We investigate the role of quantum entanglement and coherence in suppressing radiation and explore its implications for dark matter. Using Dicke’s framework, we demonstrate that entangled states in a gas at thermal equilibrium can lead to subradiance, trapping energy in dark quantum states and reducing radiation intensity. Applying this to the 21 cm line in dark matter halos, we find that quantum coherence renders the gas effectively dark. Moreover, entanglement results in a vanishing collision cross-section, consistent with the collisionless nature of dark matter observed in systems like the bullet cluster. We also show that absorption of incident radiation can exceed levels predicted by Beer’s law, which holds only in the absence of coherence. These findings suggest that quantum entanglement and coherence may explain the non-luminous behavior of matter in dark matter halos, offering a novel perspective on dark matter and advancing the understanding of astrophysical radiative processes. keywords entanglement, coherence, subradiance, dark matter 1 Introduction It has been known since Dicke’s original treatment of the spontaneous emission of coherent radiation Dicke 1954 that the interaction between atoms composing a gas 1 1 1 Although we focus on atoms in this paper, our analysis and discussions apply to molecular gases as well. through their common electromagnetic field leads to the formation of entangled quantum mechanical states, with significant implications for the spontaneous emission rates of photons emanating from the gas. As Dicke pointed out, atoms should not be considered as independent entities; instead, the entire gas must be treated as a single quantum mechanical system. While the material covered in his paper was broad, touching on several phenomena involving coherence and entanglement, much of the early work it inspired focused on superradiance. Superradiance is a fundamental radiation process Feld and MacGillivray 1980 in which the cooperative behavior of the atoms composing the gas leads to powerful bursts of coherent radiation. Indeed, superradiance can be thought of as “collective spontaneous emission,” where, instead of spontaneously emitting photons individually, the atoms cooperate in a coherent cascade of photon emission. Although the first experimental verification of superradiance occurred almost 20 years after Dicke’s work Skribanowitz et al. 1973 , astronomers remained largely unaware of this phenomenon and the intense research being conducted in the quantum optics community. This remained the case despite the earlier discovery of astronomical masers in the interstellar medium Weaver et al. 1965 and the complementarity between the maser action and superradiance Feld and MacGillivray 1980 ; F. Rajabi and M. Houde 2020 . It is only recently that superradiance has been studied in an astronomical context and used to explain intense flares from maser-hosting regions in diverse environments F. Rajabi and M. Houde 2016a ; F. Rajabi and M. Houde 2016b ; F. Rajabi and M. Houde 2017 ; Houde et al. 2018 ; Houde et al. 2019 ; Rajabi et al. 2019 ; F. Rajabi and M. Houde 2020 ; Rajabi et al. 2023 ; Houde et al. 2024 ; Rashidi et al. 2024 . Beyond improving our understanding and modeling of these systems, these studies have importantly established the presence of the type of coherence proposed by Dicke in astronomical media. Dicke’s 1954 paper Dicke 1954 also explicitly discussed another coherent radiation process, which later became known as subradiance. In contrast to superradiance, subradiance describes the suppression of photon emission compared to the typical spontaneous emission process. Dicke analyzed the trapping of energy in slow and dark quantum states and its consequences for the radiation intensity emanating from a gas. Subradiance was experimentally verified later than superradiance Pavolini et al. 1985 and has only recently been observed in large clouds of cold atoms Guerin et al. 2016 . The latter experimental result is particularly relevant to us as we explore the possible existence of subradiant systems in astrophysical contexts. More specifically, we ask the following question: Given that superradiance is known to occur in diverse astronomical environments, should we not also expect subradiance to be realized? We aim to answer this by exploring a possible link between subradiance and the presence of dark matter in the universe – one of the deepest mysteries in astrophysics since its manifestation in galactic rotation curves was discovered Rubin, Vera C. and Ford, Jr., W. Kent 1970 . 2 Results 2.1 Entangled quantum states and coherent behavior In this section we revisit parts of Dicke’s work and focus on the trapping of energy within an atomic ensemble. We first focus on a two-atom system at resonance with Atom 1 at -z_{0}/2 and Atom 2 at z_{0}/2 on the z -axis. Given that single-atom transitions take place between the lower \Ket{a} and upper \Ket{b} levels of energies -\hbar\omega_{0}/2 and \hbar\omega_{0}/2 , respectively, appropriate internal states for the two-atom problem consist of Dicke 1954 ; Dicke 1964 (see Appendices 5 and 8 ) \displaystyle\Ket{1,1} \displaystyle=\Ket{bb} (1) \displaystyle\Ket{1,0}_{\theta} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left(e^{i\frac{1}{2}kz_{0}\cos\theta}\Ket{ab}+e^{-i\frac{1}{2}kz_{0}\cos\theta}\Ket{ba}\right) (2) \displaystyle\Ket{1,-1} \displaystyle=\Ket{aa} (3) \displaystyle\Ket{0,0}_{\theta} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left(e^{i\frac{1}{2}kz_{0}\cos\theta}\Ket{ab}-e^{-i\frac{1}{2}kz_{0}\cos\theta}\Ket{ba}\right). (4) Following Dicke Dicke 1954 , the kets \Ket{r,m} are defined with the “cooperative” number r and “inversion” number m , which are analogous to quantum numbers for a system of coupled spin-1/2 particles, with r\geq 0 and \left|m\right|\leq r ( \Ket{r,m}_{\theta}=\Ket{r,m} when \cos\theta=0 ). Note that k=2\pi/\lambda with \lambda the radiation wavelength. Given equations ( 1 )-( 4 ) it is straightforward to calculate the spontaneous emission transition rates per unit solid angle between the different states \displaystyle\frac{d\gamma_{1,1\rightarrow 1,0_{\theta}}}{d\Omega} \displaystyle=2\frac{d\Gamma}{d\Omega} (5) \displaystyle\frac{d\gamma_{1,1\rightarrow 0,0_{\theta}}}{d\Omega} \displaystyle=0 (6) \displaystyle\frac{d\gamma_{1,0_{\theta}\rightarrow 1,-1}}{d\Omega^{\prime}} \displaystyle=2\cos^{2}\left[\frac{1}{2}kz_{0}\left(\cos\theta^{\prime}-\cos\theta\right)\right]\frac{d\Gamma}{d\Omega^{\prime}} (7) \displaystyle\frac{d\gamma_{0,0_{\theta}\rightarrow 1,-1}}{d\Omega^{\prime}} \displaystyle=2\sin^{2}\left[\frac{1}{2}kz_{0}\left(\cos\theta^{\prime}-\cos\theta\right)\right]\frac{d\Gamma}{d\Omega^{\prime}} (8) with d\Gamma/d\Omega the spontaneous emission rate per unit solid angle of a single independent atom, and \theta and \theta^{\prime} denoting the orientations of the first and second emitted photons, respectively, relative to the z -axis. The signatures of entanglement and coherence are displayed in equations ( 7 )-( 8 ). That is, the enhancement of the transitions rates by a factor of ‘2’ is due to the entangled nature of the states given in equations ( 2 ) and ( 4 ), while the disappearance of the argument in the cosine and sine functions (i.e., when \cos\theta^{\prime}=\cos\theta ) stems from coherence between the two emitted photons. We therefore find the existence of an angular correlation between successively emitted photons. More precisely, if the system starts in the \Ket{1,1} state, then after the emission of the first photon it will for sure end up in the symmetric \Ket{1,0}_{\theta} intermediate state. From there, we see that the second photon has a higher probability of being emitted in a direction where \cos\theta^{\prime}=\cos\theta to reach the \Ket{1,-1} ground state Dicke 1964 . We will soon be interested in situations where the system is in thermal equilibrium where all the states for a given m value are initially equally populated. We thus focus on the transition rates between the m=0 and m=-1 states given in equations ( 7 )-( 8 ). We can obtain the radiation intensity by, among other things, integrating these transition rates over the solid angle. Setting \cos\theta=0 , for simplicity, and initial conditions where the states \Ket{1,0}_{\theta} and \Ket{0,0}_{\theta} have equal but uncorrelated probabilities of occupation (of 1/2 ), we can study the intensity in two opposite limits (see