Heading towards an Algebraic Heisenberg Cut

Mathias Van Den Bossche, Philippe Grangier · 2024

Read Heading towards an Algebraic Heisenberg Cut by Mathias Van Den Bossche, Philippe Grangier (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-16574.txt.

Introduction

Mathias Van Den Bossche and Philippe Grangier seek an algebra-based border between quantum and classical worlds. Their 2024 paper revisits the Heisenberg cut, the line where measurement happens. Older theorems by von Neumann split huge quantum systems into sectors. Those results need infinitely many parts, which invites doubt.

A simple photon polarization meter serves as the test case. Inside its photodiodes, electron avalanches swell toward the infinite limit. Before infinity, the device already behaves macroscopically and lands in one sector. The signal becomes a classical click at the same moment. The authors argue the infinite math stays under control in practice. That grounds a formalism many had set aside as too abstract.

Catalog record

CREATORMathias Van Den Bossche, Philippe Grangier
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-16574

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Heading towards an Algebraic Heisenberg Cut Mathias Van Den Bossche, Philippe Grangier Abstract In previous papers we have explained how a sequence of theorems by John von Neumann on infinite tensor products (ITP) can be understood as providing elements to support both sectorisation of the Hilbert space of large quantum systems, and a mechanism of self decoherence thereof. These two effects may help understanding the articulation of the classical and quantum realms. However, as they involve considering an infinite number of quantum degrees of freedom, legitimate concerns can be raised on their applicability. In this paper, we address explicitly the interface between both realms through the example of a simplified model of a photon polarisation measurement device. Guided by the fact that there is von Neumann sectorisation at infinity, and by the necessity of classical contexts to perform measurements, we show that this limit can be under control, and that although the full force of the sectorisation theorems requires taking the infinite limit, early signs of the macroscopic behaviour appear before infinity. In our example, this shows up in photodiodes through diverging electron avalanches that simultaneously make the system classical, localise it randomly in a macroscopic sector and provide a macroscopic signal. This lays the grounds for justifying the inclusion in quantum physics of the ITP formalism, which involves non-separable Hilbert spaces and potentially type-III von Neumann algebras. Such an approach could make sense of the quantum-classical transition as a primarily algebraic one. 1 Motivations Since the formalisation of quantum theory almost one century ago, the difference between what can be expected from a system in the quantum realm (if any) and what we are used to in the classical realm has been continuously raising questions at many levels. The core of the differences is located in the measurement process, that involves a macroscopic measurement device to extract information from the quantum system. We hold as key that this macroscopic aspect is not a spurious detail of the framework, but the structuring element that makes measurement contextual, and quantum physics intrinsically different from classical physics. This point of view developed in [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] and summarized in Annex 1 will be pursued in the present article. In a series of papers [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] we have argued that it could make sense to investigate what can be obtained from the properties of infinite tensor products (ITP) of N elementary Hilbert spaces, to describe the behaviour of quantum systems at the macroscopic limit N\rightarrow\infty . Of particular interest is a set of ‘sectorisation’ theorems by John von Neumann [ 9 ] that explain how ITP Hilbert spaces (i) break down into an uncountable number of orthogonal separable subspaces that we call sectors, defined so that their direct sum is the full ITP space 1 1 1 Von Neumann calls them ‘incomplete direct products’, i.e. incomplete tensor product in current terminology. The full (complete) tensor product is not only infinite but non-separable. and (ii) that these sectors are not connected by operators built from operators in each elementary Hilbert space. This implies a form of self-decoherence without tracing on external degrees of freedom. The algebras of operators that are relevant to describe the observables in this limit are not necessarily type-I von Neumann (W*-)algebras, as it would be the case for operators on the usual finite or countably-infinite dimension Hilbert spaces. Here, the ITP becomes nonseparable and up to type-III algebras may be required [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] . Even though considering the large N limit is common in statistical physics [ 10 ] , it needs to be checked when applied to a new case. This is even more true here since a qualitative change seems to appear only at infinity – which has always been a tricky topic to handle. In the present case, it means going beyond Streater and Wightman vulgate assumptions [ 11 , 12 ] , in particular by considering also non-separable Hilbert spaces , giving to the whole picture a fairly abstract mathematical content. In this paper we go back to physics, by considering a model of photon polarisation measurement device, simplified down to a Gedankenexperiment style, by removing all conventional sources of decoherence. We will focus on a direct, destructive measurement, but the calculation can be easily extended to an indirect, quantum non-demolition one (QND, see Annex 2). This will allow us to show how these mathematical considerations could be at the fundamental core of measurement processes, shedding light on the subtle articulation between the classical and the quantum worlds, that seem to require each other within a unified physical reality [ 13 ] . This article is organised the following way. We first define the notion of ‘sector parameter’ observable that allows labelling macroscopic states. We then introduce the simplified model that we consider to describe the avalanche photodiode (APD), which will be at the core of the polarisation measurement device. Next we build the avalanche quantum state, explore its large N properties, and analyse their consequence in the frame of the generic measurement model presented in [ 14 ] . We then introduce the sector parameter relevant to this case and we compute the large- N behaviour of its expectation value in the avalanche state. We finally discuss our results, explaining the subtlety of the limit and highlighting differences with previous attempts at modeling this kind of phenomena – in particular, how the usual Bohrian concept of complementarity is superseded by the much better defined notion of contextuality [ 7 ] . 2 Sector parameter In order to describe the interaction between a microscopic quantum system and a macroscopic measurement device, we need a tool to label the state of the resulting joint macroscopic system. We have shown in previous papers how the sectorisation theorems of von Neumann [ 9 ] can be used to understand the quantum states of macroscopic systems viewed as systems with a number N\rightarrow\infty of microscopic quantum elements. Our considerations on sector parameters are reminiscent of earlier works, e.g. by J. Bub [ 16 ] and K.K. Wan [ 17 ] , with the difference that we take explicitly care of the behaviour as a function of N, which yields interesting physics. Let \mathcal{S} be a system made of N quantum subsystems, each described by an ‘elementary’ Hilbert space \mathcal{H}_{\alpha},\alpha\in[N]:=\{0,1,...,N\} . The Hilbert space of \mathcal{S} is \mathcal{H}_{N}:=\otimes_{\alpha\in[N]}\mathcal{H}_{\alpha} . For a collection of elementary states, \{|\phi_{\alpha}\rangle,\alpha\in[N]\} we can define a state of \mathcal{S} in \mathcal{H}_{N} as |\Phi_{N}\rangle=\otimes_{\alpha\in[N]}|\phi_{\alpha}\rangle (1) In the large N limit, such a state will define a von Neumann sector of \mathcal{H}_{\infty} , which is spanned by |\Phi_{\infty}\rangle and all the states obtained by changing a finite number of |\phi_{\alpha}\rangle ’s in the tensor product [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 ] . In turn, changing an infinite number of tensor factors will lead to a sector different from that of |\Phi_{\infty}\rangle . By analogy with the order parameter in statistical physics, we define a ‘sector parameter’ as the N\rightarrow\infty limit of the observable associated to |\Phi_{N}\rangle by \hat{X}_{N}:=\frac{1}{N}\sum_{\alpha\in[N]}|\phi_{\alpha}\rangle\langle\phi_{\alpha}|\otimes_{\beta\in[N]\setminus\alpha}\hat{I}_{\beta} (2) where \hat{I}_{\beta} is the identity operator in

Read the complete text