Large baseline quantum telescopes assisted by partially distinguishable photons
Subhrajit Modak, Pieter Kok · 2024
Read Large baseline quantum telescopes assisted by partially distinguishable photons by Subhrajit Modak, Pieter Kok (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-16571.txt.
Introduction
Subhrajit Modak and Pieter Kok weigh, in 2024 work, two flaws in a quantum plan to stretch scope arrays. The plan shares lone light grains between sites, where they meet star grains and sharpen the view. Two asks were open: how the star mode's thin fill bites, and how blurred sameness between shared and star grains cuts reach.
Blurred sameness proved mild, they find. Thin fill bit hard: as helper grain counts rose, the scope's feel fell fast. The pair frame the trade for builders of such arrays: chase pure sameness less, and mind the star's thin stream more.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Subhrajit Modak, Pieter Kok |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-16571
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Large baseline quantum telescopes assisted by partially distinguishable photons Subhrajit Modak, Pieter Kok Abstract Quantum entanglement can be used to extend the baseline of telescope arrays in order to increase the spatial resolution. In one proposal by Marchese and Kok [Phys. Rev. Lett. 130 , 160801 (2023)], identical single photons are shared between receivers, and interfere with a star photon. In this paper we consider two outstanding questions: i) what is the precise effect of the low photon occupancy of the mode associated with the starlight, and ii) what is the effect on the achievable resolution of imperfect indistinguishability (or partial distinguishability) between the ground and star photons. We find that the effect of distinguishability is relatively mild, but low photon occupancy of the optical mode of the starlight quickly deteriorates the sensitivity of the telescope for higher auxiliary photon numbers. Large baseline imaging is a well-known technique for improving the resolution of telescopes Dravins 2016 ; Czupryniak et al. 2023 ; Brown et al. 2023 ; Bojer et al. 2022 . It has recently been used to resolve the spatial features of a black hole in the radio frequency (RF) spectrum Akiyama et al. 2019 , with a baseline comparable to the diameter of the Earth. This was possible because antennas can track both the amplitude and phase of RF waves and reconstruct the wave propagation characteristics. In contrast, at optical frequencies the amplitude and phase information must be retrieved via interferometry, which severely limits the baseline of optical telescopes. Light collected in the telescopes must travel through light pipes or optical fibers, which practically limits the baseline due to construction constraints or photon losses, respectively. Quantum technologies can be used to improve the performance of telescopes by choosing the optimal quantum observable Kolobov 2007 ; Tsang et al. 2016 ; Tsang 2019 ; Pearce et al. 2017 ; Howard et al. 2019 ; Lupo et al. 2020 ; Zanforlin et al. 2022 or extending the baseline using quantum repeater protocols Gottesman et al. 2012 and quantum error correction Huang et al. 2022 . Recently, Marchese and Kok proposed a repeaterless method to extend the baseline of a telescope by employing multiple single-photon sources at the ground level that interfere at the receiver sites with photons originating from astronomical objects Marchese and Kok 2023 (see Fig. 1 ). This minimizes the distance traveled by the photons that carry information about the astronomical objects and allows for redundancy in the ground-based photons to combat transmission losses over large distances. In this paper we address two outstanding open questions that arose from Ref. Marchese and Kok 2023 : i) what is the precise effect of the low photon occupancy of the mode associated with the starlight, and ii) what is the effect on the achievable resolution of imperfect indistinguishability (or partial distinguishability) between the ground and star photons. This paper is organised as follows. In Sec. I we recall the technical details of the repeaterless quantum telescope of Ref. Marchese and Kok 2023 and include the analysis of partially distinguishable photons. In Sec. III we establish the achievable resolution for the telescope, taking into account single mode photon occupancy. We conclude in Sec. IV . Figure 1: The proposal of Ref. Marchese and Kok 2023 : two receivers, A and B , separated by a distance L , receive photons from a point-like astronomical object and from sources S_{2}\ldots S_{N} located midway between the receivers. The path length of the star photon is kept short by co-locating the interferometers U with the receivers. The photons sent from sources S_{2} to S_{N} experience reduced transmission \eta^{2}\leq 1 due to fiber losses. The measurement statistics are used to estimate the declination angle \theta , encoding the position of the star. I The Quantum Telescope Protocol We assume that a point-like astronomical object, such as a distant star, is sufficiently far away that the incoming light can be effectively approximated by a plane wave. A photon from this object will arrive in two receivers of the telescope, A and B separated by a distance L , in the superposition state \displaystyle\ket{\psi_{\rm in}}=\frac{\ket{1}_{A}\ket{0}_{B}+e^{i\phi}\ket{0}_{A}\ket{1}_{B}}{\sqrt{2}}\,, (1) where \phi=kl=kL\sin\theta is the phase difference between the two receivers due to the path difference l that originates from the direction \theta of the incoming wave with wave number k (see Fig. 1 ). The star photon is collected by the receivers A and B , and interferes locally at the receivers with N ground-based photons in interferometers U . The creation and annihilation operators of the ground-based modes are \{a^{\dagger}_{n},a_{n}\} and \{b^{\dagger}_{n},b_{n}\} , and the input state becomes \begin{split}|\psi\rangle_{\rm{tot}}^{\rm{in}}=&\left(\dfrac{1}{2}\right)^{\frac{N}{2}}\prod_{n=1}^{N}\left(a^{\dagger}_{n}+e^{i\phi\delta_{n,1}}b^{\dagger}_{n}\right)|0\rangle\,,\end{split} (2) where the Kronecker delta ensures a the phase \phi in mode 1, the starlight mode. Here |0\rangle is the vacuum state. The interferometers U implement a discrete quantum Fourier transform (QFT), and detecting D\leq N photons allows one to reconstruct the probability distributions P_{\mathbf{d}}(\phi) in the presence of losses, where \mathbf{d} indicates the detector signature. Ref. Marchese and Kok 2023 showed that this distribution contains a significant amount of information about the phase \phi , and therefore the angular position of the star \theta . We assume perfect number-resolving detectors. The Fisher information, which measures the information about \phi in the probability distribution, is given by Marchese and Kok 2023 F_{N}(\phi)=\sum_{\mathbf{d}}^{\sigma_{N}}P_{\mathbf{d}}(\phi)\left(\dfrac{\partial\text{ln}P_{\mathbf{d}}(\phi)}{\partial\phi}\right)^{2}\,, (3) where \sigma_{N} is the total number of possible detector outcomes. Including transmission losses for the ground photons, the Fisher information reduces to F_{N}^{\rm{loss}}=\sum_{k=0}^{N-1}p^{k}(1-p)^{N-1-k}\binom{N-1}{k}F_{N-k}^{{}^{\prime}}. (4) where F_{N-k}^{{}^{\prime}} is the Fisher information for D=N-k detected photons, k is the number of photons lost, and p is the probability of a single photon loss. We assume that the loss on the star photon is negligible, and that the dominant loss is from the fiber transmission losses over long distances. In the case of no loss ( p=0 ), the Fisher information still depends on \phi , as shown in Fig. 2 for N\geq 3 . Hence the optimal arrangement is to include a variable phase shift in one receiver that balanced the interferometer in such a way that the receivers ‘point’ to the source, i.e., \phi\sim 0 . Figure 2: The dependence of the Fisher information on \phi for various numbers N of photons in the setup under the ideal condition of no loss (black: N=2 , green: N=3 , and red: N=4 ). The Fisher information increases with the photon number as F_{N}(\phi)=1-1/N . II Distinguishability of photons Next, we will consider how the distinguishability between photons affects the Fisher information. We take the star photon as the reference photon, and study how imperfect mode matching of the ground-based photons to the star photon affects the resolution. Our approach is as follows: the spatio-temporal characteristics of the star photon are labeled with index \mu . A ground-based photon in a single mode a_{j} with a slightly different spatio-temporal character can then be described by a mode that is superposition of mode a^{\mu} and an orthogonal mode a^{\nu}_{j} . These modes have corresponding mode operators that satisfy the usual bosonic commutation relation: [\hat{a}^{\mu},\hat{a}^{\dagger\nu}]=[\hat{b}^{\mu},\hat{b}^{\dagger\nu}]=\delta_{\mu\nu} and [\hat{a}^{\mu},\hat{a}^{\nu}]=[\hat{b}^{\mu},\hat{b}^{\nu}]=0 . There are two possibilities: all the ground-based photons may be different from the star photon but identical to each other, or all the ground-based photons