Dynamics and universal scaling of Worthington jets in the cavity-free regime

Xingsheng Li, Jing Li · 2024

Read Dynamics and universal scaling of Worthington jets in the cavity-free regime by Xingsheng Li, Jing Li (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-16508.txt.

Introduction

Xingsheng Li and Jing Li studied Worthington jets in twenty twenty-four in the regime where a sphere strikes liquid without forming a cavity. These upward jets follow impacts in nature and industry; cavity collapse usually drives them, but here there is no cavity. Experiments identified three pinch-off modes for the rising jet.

Surprisingly, the mode boundaries did not depend on the sphere's wettability or density; the Rayleigh-Plateau instability sets them. From momentum and energy conservation the authors derived a scaling law for maximum jet height that matched experiments across conditions. Coupling self-similar solutions with a tip condition reproduced the jet's evolving shape, showing gravity-dominated dynamics tempered by surface tension. The jet here is fed by converging flow colliding behind the sphere.

Catalog record

CREATORXingsheng Li, Jing Li
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-16508

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Dynamics and universal scaling of Worthington jets in the cavity-free regime Xingsheng Li, Jing Li Abstract Worthington jets ejected after the impact of a solid or liquid object on a liquid surface have extensive applications in natural, industrial, and scientific contexts. Here, we present a combined experimental and theoretical investigation of the jet generated by sphere impact with no cavity formed. Experiments identify three distinct pinch-off modes, whose regime boundaries are independent of sphere wettability and density, and are theoretically determined by the Rayleigh–Plateau instability. From momentum and energy conservation, a new scaling law is derived for the dimensionless maximum jet height and agrees remarkably well with experiments across various impact conditions, thus validating its universal character and clarifying its dependence on the Froude, Weber, and Reynolds numbers as well as the density ratio. Coupling self-similar solutions with a kinematic condition at the jet tip yields good predictions for the evolution of jet height and shape, revealing gravity-dominated jet dynamics, with a modification from surface tension that is most pronounced without pinch-off. These findings demonstrate that the upward jet is sustained by the collision of converging flow behind the sphere, a generation mechanism fundamentally distinct from the cavity collapsing forced case. Usage Secondary publications and information retrieval purposes. Preprint: APS/123-QED I Introduction Worthington jets generated during the free surface impact of solid or liquid objects have diverse beneficial applications, ranging from human Olympic diving [ 38 ] and droplet manipulation [ 27 ] to spray cooling and painting [ 3 ] . At the same time, their uncontrolled occurrence can result in serious pesticide wasting [ 35 ] , air pollution [ 29 ] , and even the spread of pollutants and pathogens [ 24 ] . Given these dual influences, this impact problem has attracted sustained interest since Worthington’s pioneering work more than a century ago [ 52 ] . Extensive research has examined jets produced by various impact objects, including liquid droplets [ 30 , 26 , 47 , 10 ] , solid spheres [ 21 , 12 , 2 , 45 , 41 ] , and flat disks [ 5 , 19 , 18 ] . Similar phenomena have also been well investigated in the context of bubble bursting near a liquid surface [ 28 , 25 , 11 ] . Upon the impact of a solid body on a liquid surface, extensive research has focused on the air entrainment circumstance. In addition to the classical axisymmetric cavity, various complex phenomena have been reported, including the appearance of asymmetric cavities for spheres with heterogeneous wetting properties [ 49 ] , the formation of subsurface cavities and small droplets together with bubbles on the sphere surface due to the presence of a bubble layer resting on the surface of a water–surfactant mixture [ 42 ] , and the development of a three-dimensional crumpled morphology along the cavity wall resulting from the existence of an oil lens floating on the water [ 40 ] . As the axisymmetric air cavity collapses due to hydrostatic pressure with a local scaling exponent \gamma=d\ln{h_{0}/d}\ln{t^{\prime}} of the minimum radius h_{0} of the cavity [ 14 ] , the pinch-off eventually occurs at a single point, from which two jets are ejected upward and downward, respectively [ 18 ] . The upward Worthington jet has been verified to be driven by local flow around the base of the jet, which is forced by the colliding cavity wall, as explained by the theory of a collapsing void [ 17 ] . The Rayleigh–Plesset equation has been widely and effectively applied to model such cavity collapse dynamics [ 12 , 2 , 36 ] . In particular, Aristoff and Bush [2] developed a theoretical model to describe the evolution of cavity shape and obtained an analytical solution for pinch-off events, which shows excellent agreement with the experiments. They also reported that the cavity exhibits different sealing behaviors depending on the impact parameters, an observation that was later extended by Speirs et al. [41] to incorporate the effect of sphere wettability. Although this theory accurately captures cavity dynamics, it provides limited direct insight into the jet. Alternatively, boundary integral simulations provide another powerful approach to the cavity collapse problem and have advanced the physical understanding of associated jet formation [ 4 , 18 ] . Above the free surface, considerable attention has been paid to the splash crown, a visually striking and dynamically rich phenomenon that continues to attract scientific interest. Marston et al. [31] observed a buckling-type azimuthal instability of the crown, manifested as vertical striations. Eshraghi et al. [16] later developed a theoretical model to describe the trajectory and dynamics of the crown, revealing its dependence on cavity pressure difference, gravity, and surface tension. In the study of the effect of ambient gas on cavity formation, Williams et al. [51] found that the presence of gas delays crown sealing, thus affecting the condition for cavity formation. In contrast to the extensively studied cavity collapse and its related phenomena, analysis of the sphere impact problem with no cavity formed remains comparatively limited. A key theoretical contribution was made by Duez et al. [13] , who derived the critical condition for cavity formation. When no cavity is formed during the impact process, the jet generation mechanism is fundamentally different. As illustrated in Figs. 1 (a–c), the kinetic energy of the sphere is transferred directly to the surrounding liquid upon impact, providing the primary momentum to support the generation of the jet. In this regime, traditional models based on the Rayleigh–Besant problem are no longer applicable, and attention to this kind of jet is relatively sparse. Existing research has established only a basic relationship from an energy perspective, reporting that the maximum jet height is proportional to the release height [ 50 ] . Nevertheless, the detailed behavior of the jet, the parameters that govern the jet dynamics, and the underlying physical mechanisms have not yet been adequately clarified or explained. Despite limited prior studies, insights can be drawn from droplet impact problem [ 32 , 23 , 6 , 7 , 33 ] , where the resulting jet shape closely resembles the present observations (Figs. 1 (a–c)). Nevertheless, the underlying generation mechanisms differ fundamentally. In droplet impact, although the formed crater does not undergo the same pinch-off collapse, as does the cavity caused by traditional sphere impact, the resulting upward jet is still driven by crater retraction, a process clearly shown in Ref. [ 7 ] . As demonstrated in Refs. [ 32 , 6 , 23 ] , energy is accumulated and transferred to the jet via capillary waves that propagate and focus at the bottom of the receding crater, ultimately giving rise to a vertical jet shooting out. In the present work, we aim to systematically investigate Worthington jets generated by sphere impact on a liquid surface with no cavity formed, hereafter referred to as cavity-free jets. In Sec. II , the experimental procedure and the tested impact conditions are introduced. Section III presents a qualitative analysis of the observed jet behavior, reports a theoretical explanation for the identified pinch-off regimes, and a brief discussion of the critical condition for cavity formation. Section IV provides

Read the complete text