Systematic discrepancies between reference methods for non-covalent interactions within the S66 dataset
Benjamin X. Shi, Flaviano Della Pia, Yasmine S. Al-Hamdani, Angelos Michaelides, Dario Alfè, Andrea Zen · 2024
Read Systematic discrepancies between reference methods for non-covalent interactions within the S66 dataset by Benjamin X. Shi, Flaviano Della Pia, Yasmine S. Al-Hamdani, Angelos Michaelides, Dario Alfè, Andrea Zen (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-16405.txt.
Introduction
Shi, Della Pia, Al-Hamdani, Michaelides, Alfè, and Zen compare in twenty twenty-four two gold-standard quantum methods on a benchmark set of weakly bound molecule pairs. Such gentle attractions rule crystals, surfaces, and solutions, so both methods are trusted to price them. Running one method across all sixty-six pairs for the first time, they set its energies against the other's published values.
A clear pattern emerged: the Monte Carlo method binds charge-driven pairs more strongly, and dispersion-driven pairs more weakly, than the coupled-cluster method. The gap size tracked the pair's mix of the two force types. Two pairs showed the split most starkly and are offered as cheap test cases. The authors aim the findings at method developers.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Benjamin X. Shi, Flaviano Della Pia, Yasmine S. Al-Hamdani, Angelos Michaelides, Dario Alfè, Andrea Zen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 27 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-16405
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Systematic discrepancies between reference methods for non-covalent interactions within the S66 dataset Preprint: AIP/123-QED Benjamin X. Shi, Flaviano Della Pia, Yasmine S. Al-Hamdani, Angelos Michaelides, Dario Alfè, Andrea Zen Abstract The accurate treatment of non-covalent interactions is necessary to model a wide range of applications, from molecular crystals to surface catalysts to aqueous solutions and many more. Quantum diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) and coupled cluster theory with single, double and perturbative triple excitations [CCSD(T)] are considered two widely-trusted methods for treating non-covalent interactions. However, while they have been well-validated for small molecules, recent work has indicated that these two methods can disagree by more than 7.5 7.5\, kcal/mol for larger systems. The origin of this discrepancy remains unknown. Moreover, the lack of systematic comparisons, particularly for medium-sized complexes, has made it difficult to identify which systems may be prone to such disagreements and the potential scale of these differences. In this work, we leverage the latest developments in DMC to compute interaction energies for the entire S66 dataset, containing 66 medium-sized complexes with a balanced representation of dispersion and electrostatic interactions. Comparison to previous CCSD(T) references reveals systematic trends, with DMC predicting stronger binding than CCSD(T) for electrostatic-dominated systems, while the binding becomes weaker for dispersion-dominated systems. We show that the relative strength of this discrepancy is correlated to the ratio of electrostatic and dispersion interactions, as obtained from energy decomposition analysis methods. Finally, we have pinpointed model systems: the hydrogen-bonded acetic acid dimer (ID 20) and dispersion-dominated uracil–cyclopentane dimer (ID 42), where these discrepancies are particularly prominent. These systems offer cost-effective benchmarks to guide future developments in DMC, CCSD(T) as well as the wider electronic structure theory community. I Introduction Non-covalent interactions play a crucial role in many areas of science. These interactions govern the structure of molecular crystals Beran 2016 (e.g., in pharmaceutical drugs), biomolecules Riley and Hobza 2011 like DNA and proteins and are relevant to supramolecular Raynal et al. 2014 science and nanotechnology. Planas et al. 2013 ; Poloni, Smit, and Neaton 2012 They also underlie important processes across chemistry and biology, from protein-ligand binding Du et al. 2016 , to catalytic reactions, both on the surface R. Rehak et al. 2020 and in solution. Raynal et al. 2014 Understanding and unlocking new processes for these applications will increasingly rely on accurate computational modeling tools that can treat non-covalent interactions. Müller-Dethlefs and Hobza 2000 Two methods of choice for modeling non-covalent interactions are quantum diffusion Monte Carlo Foulkes et al. 2001 (DMC) and coupled cluster theory Bartlett and Musiał 2007 with single, double and perturbative triple excitations [CCSD(T)]. While these methods may not be as affordable as density functional theory Mattsson et al. 2004 (DFT), the reference data they provide are pivotal for benchmarking and parametrizing the density functional approximations (DFAs) necessary for practical routine simulations. For example, the local density approximation (LDA) and many extensions build upon a DMC-based parametrization of the correlation energy, Ceperley and Alder 1980 while CCSD(T) interaction energy datasets have helped aid in the development of many modern dispersion corrections. Grimme 2006 ; Grimme et al. 2010 ; Grimme et al. 2016 ; A. Price, Otero-de-la-Roza, and R. Johnson 2023 In particular, the applicability of these methods to larger systems have rapidly expanded in recent years, arising from computer hardware improvements and, more importantly, algorithmic/methodological developments to both DMC Zen et al. 2016 ; Krogel 2016 ; Bennett et al. 2017 ; Bennett et al. 2018 ; Annaberdiyev et al. 2018 ; Zen et al. 2019 ; Needs et al. 2020 ; Nakano et al. 2020 ; Kent et al. 2020 ; Nakano et al. 2023 and CCSD(T). Riplinger and Neese 2013 ; Riplinger et al. 2016 ; Ma and Werner 2018 ; Nagy, Samu, and Kállay 2018 ; Nagy and Kállay 2019 ; Masios et al. 2023 ; Jiang et al. 2024 ; Ye and Berkelbach 2024 DMC and CCSD(T) solve the Schrödinger equation to model the systems with distinct approaches and corresponding approximations. Despite these differences, there are many examples where DMC and CCSD(T) have come into alignment. For example, besides small molecules, Dubecký et al. 2013 ; Řezáč et al. 2015 ; Raghav et al. 2023 agreement has been obtained for graphene bilayer binding energies Mostaani, Drummond, and Fal’ko 2015 , molecular crystal lattice energies, Zen et al. 2018 ; Della Pia et al. 2022 ; Della Pia et al. 2024 molecule-surface interactions Karalti et al. 2012 ; Al-Hamdani, Alfè, and Michaelides 2017 ; Tsatsoulis et al. 2017 ; Al-Hamdani et al. 2017 ; Brandenburg et al. 2019 ; Shi et al. 2023 and vacancy formation energies. Shi et al. 2022 Recently, this agreement has been shown to start to falter Al-Hamdani et al. 2021 ; Schäfer et al. 2024 ; Ballesteros, Dunivan, and Lao 2021 ; Villot et al. 2022 for large dispersion-bound molecules, with differences as large as 7.5\, kcal/mol for a buckyball-ring ( \mathrm{C}_{60}@[6]\mathrm{CPPA} ) complex. The origin of the discrepancy between DMC and CCSD(T) for large dispersion-bound molecules is a topic of current debate, Schäfer et al. 2024 ; Fishman et al. 2024 ; Lambie et al. 2024 ; Lao 2024 particularly on the validity of the perturbative triples (T) contribution in CCSD(T). Schäfer et al. Schäfer et al. 2024 have suggested that part of this discrepancy arises from missing contributions in (T) that can be accounted by the (cT) approach. In addition, Semidalas et al. Semidalas, Boese, and Martin 2025 have reported non-trivial discrepancies between CCSD(T) and post-CCSD(T) methods such as CCSDT(Q). Conversely, Lambie et al. Lambie et al. 2024 have found that CCSD(T) does not differ significantly against CCSDT(Q) using the Pariser-Parr-Pople (PPP) model Pariser and Parr 1953a ; Pariser and Parr 1953b ; Pople 1953 for large conjugated systems. Similarly, Fishman et al. Fishman et al. 2024 and Lao Lao 2024 report only a slight overbinding of CCSD(T) against CCSDT(Q) that cannot explain the discrepancy against DMC. Understanding these discrepancies between DMC and CCSD(T) for large molecules requires cross-validating these methods across systematic datasets, particularly those involving medium to large sized molecules Sure and Grimme 2015 ; Ballesteros, Dunivan, and Lao 2021 ; Grimme 2012 which sample a range of non-covalent interactions. While DMC and CCSD(T) have both been compared (to great agreement) for the A24 Řezáč and Hobza 2013 and S22 Jurečka et al. 2006 datasets of small molecular complexes, DMC has not been frequently applied to study medium-sized datasets. In particular, it has not been used to study the S66 dataset, Řezáč, Riley, and Hobza 2011a a compilation of 66 dimers that probes the two major types of non-covalent interactions: dispersion and hydrogen-bonding together with those of mixed character. As well as covering a range of interactions, many of the molecules considered form the building blocks for larger biomolecules along different binding configurations. Furthermore, the parallel-displaced benzene dimer Sinnokrot and Sherrill 2004 is included in this set of complexes, making it an interesting modeling challenge. Such a dataset has been pivotal towards benchmarking Goerigk, Kruse, and Grimme 2011 ; Gao et al. 2016 ; Peng et al. 2016 ; Yu and Wang 2020 ; Grimme et al. 2021 ; Ehlert et al. 2021 ; Müller, Hansen, and Grimme 2023