Anomalous electroweak physics unraveled via evidential deep learning
Brandon Kriesten, T. J. Hobbs · 2024
Read Anomalous electroweak physics unraveled via evidential deep learning by Brandon Kriesten, T. J. Hobbs (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-16286.txt.
Introduction
Brandon Kriesten and his co-author Hobbs bring a new machine learning tool to particle physics in a 2024 paper. Physicists test many models for how neutrinos hit matter, and they need fair ways to tell where models agree or clash. The authors use a method that splits doubt into doubt from data and doubt from lack of knowledge.
They build several test cases for odd neutrino behavior and map them next to a standard data set. The tool marks where models overlap and flags cases that fall outside the known range. That map can help future searches focus on open ground and rule models out with more speed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Brandon Kriesten, T. J. Hobbs |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-16286
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Anomalous electroweak physics unraveled via evidential deep learning Preprint: ANL-192025 Brandon Kriesten, T. J. Hobbs Abstract The ever-growing ecosystem of beyond standard model (BSM) calculations and parametrizations has motivated the development of systematic methods for making quantitative cross-comparisons over the wide range of possible models, especially with controllable uncertainties. In this setting, the language of uncertainty quantification (UQ) furnishes useful metrics for assessing statistical overlaps and discrepancies among BSM and related models. In this study, we leverage recent machine learning (ML) developments in evidential deep learning (EDL) for UQ to separate data (aleatoric) and knowledge (epistemic) uncertainties in a model-discrimination setting. We construct several potentially BSM-motivated scenarios for the anomalous electroweak interaction (AEWI) of neutrinos with nucleons in deep inelastic scattering ( ν \nu DIS). These scenarios are then quantitatively mapped, as a demonstration, alongside Monte Carlo replicas of the CT18 PDFs used to calculate the Δ χ 2 \Delta\chi^{2} statistic for a typical multi-GeV ν \nu DIS experiment, CDHSW. Our framework effectively highlights areas of model agreement and provides a classification of out-of-distribution (OOD) samples. By offering the opportunity to quantitatively understand model overlaps, the approach presented in this work can help facilitate efficient BSM model exploration and exclusion for future New Physics searches. I Introduction Following the completion of the standard model (SM), there has been an efflorescence of beyond SM (BSM) theory developments Fox:2022tzz and parallel empirical tests at high-energy facilities. As the landscape of BSM theory and searches has steadily grown in complexity, theoretical methods for discriminating among models and quantifying their differences using robust statistics have enjoyed renewed interest. Problematically, BSM frameworks often have numerous model- or parametrization-specific degrees of freedom, making it difficult to establish a tangible, statistical representation in which to distinguish or compare among the range of possible scenarios on a common footing. While effective field theory (EFT)-based methods like SMEFT Brivio:2017vri attempt to ameliorate this issue by offering an operator basis of fixed dimension to which UV-complete models might be mapped, practical analyses generally assume a truncation in the EFT expansion and fit only a subset of the available operators. As one favorable approach, it can be advantageous to reduce the dimensionality of parameter spaces spanned by BSM models to tractably calculable projections Hallin:2024gmt wherein commonalities and distinctions among these models might be statistically evaluated relative to available HEP data. In this study, we present a novel realization of this approach, leveraging recent advances in evidential deep learning (EDL) to statistically separate BSM models in a generalizable example involving simple parametric variations in electroweak theory; a critical aspect of the approach we demonstrate is the possibility of constructing mappings to inform such model discriminations with a notion of uncertainty quantification (UQ) in the model separation. Quantifying statistical commonalities among BSM scenarios along the lines shown in our calculation below presents an opportunity to enhance the understanding of New Physics signatures in an apples-to-apples setting. We demonstrate our EDL-based model separations in the specific instance of neutrino deeply inelastic scattering ( \nu DIS). Neutrino interactions play a valuable role in the HEP landscape Ackermann:2022rqc , spanning a wide kinematical range from GeV-scale accelerator-based oscillation searches, to TeV-scale collider studies, to extraterrestrial ultra high-energy signals from astrophysical neutrinos measured in the thousands of EeV. Meanwhile, charge-current (CC) \nu DIS not only informs contemporary knowledge of the structure of QCD matter within the SM, but is also sensitive to a variety of BSM scenarios Arguelles:2022tki , including generalized neutrino interactions (GNI), leptoquarks, and hidden dimensions. Furthermore, the experimental observation that neutrino flavor eigenstates mix, and thus neutrinos have non-zero mass, demonstrates the incompleteness of the SM in the neutrino sector. A traditional setting for exploring the interplay of QCD effects and possible BSM signatures has been the technique of global analysis. In the case of QCD analyses of parton distribution functions (PDFs) Alekhin:2017kpj ; Hou:2019efy ; Bailey:2020ooq ; NNPDF:2021njg , which have often sought to extract sensitive information on, e.g. the strange content of the proton from \nu DIS, calculations often involve a range of subtleties Accardi:2016qay ; Hou:2019efy ; Bailey:2020ooq ; NNPDF:2021njg ; Risse:2023wxr ; Candido:2023utz . For example, because of the weak nature of the neutrino-nucleon interaction, heavy targets such as lead, iron, or tungsten are used to achieve higher statistics; therefore, nuclear corrections are needed to separate the pure collinear proton PDF from nuclear effects. Furthermore, QCD global analyses involving neutrino data are complicated by possible tensions between \nu DIS data and charged-lepton DIS Muzakka:2022wey . These various challenges improve, but do not vanish, when correlated uncertainties are taken into account; this fact, together with the potential BSM sensitivity of \nu DIS leaves strong motivation for continuing refinement of the (B)SM theory for \nu DIS. Given these persistent questions, many new searches are planned such as the Forward Search Experiment at the LHC (FASER \nu ) FASER:2018bac ; FASER:2019dxq ; FASER:2021mtu ; Feng:2022inv and the near detector of the deep underground neutrino detector, DUNE-ND, DUNE:2016hlj ; DUNE:2022aul to search for potential BSM signatures. To confront this complicated landscape, we leverage recent developments in evidential deep learning (EDL) and related UQ techniques (see Ref. DBLP:journals/corr/abs-2110-03051 for an overview), not only to classify the BSM models in question, but also to define uncertainty metrics which we repurpose as a measure of model distinction and overlap. In particular, we use Dirichlet Prior Networks (DPNs) malinin2018predictiveuncertaintyestimationprior for this classification (or model discrimination) task to simultaneously separate the BSM scenarios, measure the degree of statistical overlap among them, and quantify the lack of knowledge regarding these scenarios in an effective model space. Additionally, the DPN can determine when a sample is completely out-of-distribution (OOD) — indicating that no other model samples resemble it — through a separate statistic. We connect these challenges to three types of uncertainties: aleatoric uncertainty, which arises from data label overlap; epistemic uncertainty, stemming from a lack of knowledge or data in particular regions; and distributional uncertainty, which indicates whether a sample lies outside the training distribution (and is therefore OOD) — effectively defining the boundaries of in-distribution sampling. These uncertainty measures can be written in closed form through the parameters of the Dirichlet distributions, facilitating efficient computation of uncertainty metrics in high-dimensional domains. We note that these methods have the potential to complement other ML approaches, such as Gaussian Mixture Models Yan:2024yir . In this manuscript, we address the challenge of disentangling BSM signatures by using an effective latent space of low dimensionality — specifically, a two-dimensional plane of \Delta\chi^{2}/N_{\mathrm{pt}} ( i.e. , per datum) for Q^{2}\!\leq\!10 and Q^{2}\!>\!10 GeV 2 , separating the theoretical description of \nu DIS into low- and high- Q^{2} regions. The novelty of our approach lies in providing quantifiable measures of model separation, overlap, and identification of OOD behavior in this basis. Our approach successfully classifies BSM models with a high degree of accuracy and provides robust uncertainty estimates, demonstrating its effectiveness in distinguishing models of approximate parametric similarity. In terms of the practical aspects of our calculation, we construct three distinct electroweak parameter combinations based on deviations of charge-current electroweak couplings, which we generically term anomalous electroweak interaction (AEWI) scenarios, and deploy evidential learning methods to explore statistical relationships in distinguishing among them. These