The Classical Super-Phaserotation Infrared Triangle Classical Logarithmic Soft Theorem as Conservation Law in (scalar) QED
Sangmin Choi, Alok Laddha, Andrea Puhm · 2024
Read The Classical Super-Phaserotation Infrared Triangle Classical Logarithmic Soft Theorem as Conservation Law in (scalar) QED by Sangmin Choi, Alok Laddha, Andrea Puhm (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-16149.txt.
Introduction
Sangmin Choi, Alok Laddha, and Andrea Puhm wrote this 2024 theoretical physics paper on a hidden symmetry of electromagnetism. Earlier work tied a universal rule about very soft photons to an endless set of phase rotations acting on matter at the edge of spacetime. Each rotation carries a conserved charge.
Here the team extend those charges to all orders in the coupling strength. They prove that keeping the charges conserved is exactly the classical rule for soft photon emission found by others in 2019. They also widen the matching memory formulas from particles to full matter fields. The result completes a three-way link among symmetry, conservation, and observable effects, known as an infrared triangle.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sangmin Choi, Alok Laddha, Andrea Puhm |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 98 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-16149
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Classical Super-Phaserotation Infrared Triangle Classical Logarithmic Soft Theorem as Conservation Law in (scalar) QED Sangmin Choi, Alok Laddha, Andrea Puhm Abstract The universality of the logarithmic soft photon theorem in four dimensions can be traced to an infinite-dimensional asymptotic symmetry which acts as a local phase rotation on matter as we have shown in [ 1 ] . Here we extend our earlier results for the charges associated to these superphaserotations to all orders in the coupling and prove that their conservation is exactly the classical logarithmic soft photon theorem discovered by Saha, Sahoo and Sen [ 2 ] . We furthermore generalize the formulae for the associated electromagnetic displacement memory and its tail from particles to scalar matter fields. This completes the classical superphaserotation infrared triangle. 1 Introduction and summary A detailed understanding of asymptotic symmetries in gauge theories and gravity has been a topic of resurgent interest over the past decade. These symmetries imply universal soft factorization theorems that are common to all theories with the same gauge group but with arbitrary matter content and generic interactions. An example is the set of theories with U(1) gauge group where the photon is the massless gauge boson. In all such theories, scattering processes involving a low-energy photon obey Weinberg’s soft photon theorem whose universality (theory-independence) is a consequence of an (infinity) of conservation laws associated to superphaserotations 1 1 1 In the literature these asymptotic symmetries are usually referred to as “large gauge transformations”. To avoid any association with gauge redundancies we will instead refer to them as superphaserotations since they act on charged matter fields as local rotations of the phase. with an angle-dependent symmetry parameter. Over the past five years, thanks to the efforts of Sahoo, Sen and their collaborators [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 2 , 6 , 7 ] , a new understanding of universal factorisation theorems in effective field theories with U(1) gauge group and in gravitational effective theories has emerged. This class of factorisation theorems are known as logarithmic soft theorems . When an amplitude is expanded in the energy of the gauge boson, beyond the leading Weinberg pole the soft factors have logarithmic dependence in the energy. Unlike the subleading soft theorems of tree-level amplitudes which have power-law dependence on the soft energy, the logarithmic soft theorems are universal in the same sense as Weinberg’s (leading) soft theorem. Hence their interpretation as conservation laws will lead us to the discovery of a new class of symmetries of scattering in four dimensions. Building on our earlier results [ 1 ] , we initiate a systematic analysis of the relationship between logarithmic soft photon theorem and asymptotic symmetries. Our goal in this paper is to show that the so-called classical logarithmic soft photon theorem in (scalar) QED, which arises in the scattering of classical massive objects, is equivalent to the conservation law associated to superphaserotations. 2 2 2 It is expected that a carefully taken classical limit of the full sub-leading factorization theorem in QED will reproduce the classical log soft theorem. For recent progress in this direction see [ 8 , 9 ] . We will, moreover, prove that this conservation law is exact to all orders in the electromagnetic coupling . The infrared physics described by soft theorems and asymptotic symmetries has yet another incarnation in the form of memory effects. The classical logarithmic soft factor [ 2 ] can also be interpreted as the so-called tail to the electromagnetic velocity memory [ 2 ] . Here we generalize the formula for the tail memory to the case where matter is described by a massive scalar field. This completes the classical infrared triangle associated to superphaserotation symmetry which is summarised in Figure 1 . classical logarithmic soft photon theorem tail to the electromagnetic velocity memory superphaserotation Figure 1: Classical superphaserotation infrared triangle. In a companion paper [ 10 ] , we show that the universality of the logarithmic soft graviton theorem and the associated tail to the gravitational memory is due to the underlying superrotation symmetry of four dimensional asymptotically flat spacetimes; this yields the first infrared triangle in gravity where the long-range nature of gravitational interactions is taken into account. See also [ 11 ] . We will now highlight the main results obtained in this work on infrared effects in scalar QED and place them in the context of known soft physics. Power-law soft photon theorems. Scattering processes involving an external photon factorize when the momentum of the photon k^{\mu}=\omega q^{\mu} is taken soft . The leading soft photon theorem is the statement that in the limit \omega\to 0 an (N+1) -particle amplitude factorizes into an N -particle amplitude without that soft photon times a soft factor that comes with a pole in the soft energy \omega{\cal M}_{N+1}(\{p_{i}\};(\omega,q,\ell))={S}_{-1}(\{p_{i}\};(q,\ell)){\cal M}_{N}(\{p_{i}\}), (1) The leading soft photon factor [ 12 ] given by S_{-1}=e\sum_{i=1}^{N}\frac{Q_{i}p^{\mu}_{i}\varepsilon_{\mu}}{q\cdot p_{i}} (2) is universal (theory-independent) as it only depends on the charges and momenta of the hard particles but not the details of the interactions. The leading soft theorem receives no corrections from loops. There is a subleading soft photon theorem due to Low [ 13 ] which can be expressed as (1+\omega\partial_{\omega}){\cal M}_{N+1}(\{p_{i}\};(\omega,q,\ell))={S}_{0}(\{p_{i}\};(q,\ell)){\cal M}_{N}(\{p_{i}\}), (3) with the subleading soft factor for minimally coupled scalar and spinor QED S_{0}=-ie\sum_{i=1}^{N}\frac{Q_{i}q_{\mu}\varepsilon_{\nu}J_{i}^{\mu\nu}}{q\cdot p_{i}}. (4) Unlike ( 2 ) the soft factor S_{0} is not universal but gets corrected by (a short list of) effective operators with three-point interactions [ 14 ] . Moreover, loop corrections lead to the appearance of logarithms in the soft expansion which render the subleading tree-level soft theorem ambiguous. Logarithmic soft photon theorems. In scalar QED it was shown [ 5 , 2 , 15 ] that given the existence of a well-defined soft expansion to all orders in the loop expansion, the ratio between an (N+1) -point amplitude with a soft photon and the N -point amplitude without that photon is infrared-finite. Its soft expansion is given by \frac{{\cal M}_{N+1}(p_{1},\dots,p_{N};(\omega,q,\ell))}{{\cal M}_{N}(p_{1},\dots,p_{N})}=\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}\omega^{n}(\ln\omega)^{n+1}{S}^{(\ln\omega)}_{n}+\dots (5) The n=-1 term is the leading (Weinberg) soft factor {S}^{(\ln\omega)}_{-1}\equiv{S}_{-1} while for n\geq 0 the soft expansion differs from the tree-level one. It was shown in [ 5 , 15 ] that not only the leading but also the subleading soft factor S^{(\ln\omega)}_{0}\neq S_{0} is universal and uniquely fixed by the charges and the momenta of the scattering states. The logarithmic soft factor may be split as [ 5 ] {S}^{(\ln\omega)}_{0}={S}^{(\ln\omega)}_{0,{\rm classical}}+\Delta{S}^{(\ln\omega)}_{0,{\rm quantum}}. (6) The classical log soft photon factor is given by {S}^{(\ln\omega)}_{0,{\rm classical}}=-ie^{3}\sum_{i=1}^{N}\frac{\varepsilon_{\mu}q_{\nu}Q_{i}}{q\cdot p_{i}}\sum_{j\neq i,\eta_{i}\eta_{j}=1}\frac{Q_{i}Q_{j}}{4\pi}\frac{p_{i}^{2}p_{j}^{2}\left[p^{\mu}_{i}p^{\nu}_{j}-p^{\mu}_{j}p^{\nu}_{i}\right]}{\left[(p_{i}\cdot p_{j})^{2}-p_{i}^{2}p_{j}^{2}\right]^{3/2}} (7) and can be derived from purely classical scattering. It has its origin in the late time electromagnetic radiation due to the acceleration of the charged particles via long-range electromagnetic interactions and is universal in that it is independent of the theory and the nature of external particles. In the quantum computation there is an additional contribution \displaystyle\begin{aligned} \Delta{S}^{(\ln\omega)}_{0,{\rm quantum}}&=e^{3}\sum_{i=1}^{N}\frac{\varepsilon_{\mu}q_{\nu}Q_{i}}{q\cdot p_{i}}\left(p^{\mu}_{i}\partial^{\nu}_{p_{i}}-p^{\nu}_{i}\partial^{\mu}_{p_{i}}\right)\\ &\quad\sum_{j\neq i}\frac{Q_{i}Q_{j}}{8\pi^{2}}\frac{(p_{i}\cdot p_{j})}{\sqrt{(p_{i}\cdot p_{j})^{2}-p_{i}^{2}p_{j}^{2})}}\ln\left(\frac{p_{i}\cdot p_{j}+\sqrt{(p_{i}\cdot p_{j})^{2}-p_{i}^{2}p_{j}^{2}}}{p_{i}\cdot p_{j}-\sqrt{(p_{i}\cdot p_{j})^{2}-p_{i}^{2}p_{j}^{2}}}\right).\end{aligned} (8) This quantum log soft factor is also expected to be universal but has been computed directly from one-loop amplitudes in scalar QED and arises from the region where the loop momentum is large compared to the soft energy \omega but small compared to the