Impact of reionization history on constraining primordial gravitational waves in future all-sky cosmic microwave background experiments
Hanchun Jiang, Toshiya Namikawa · 2024
Read Impact of reionization history on constraining primordial gravitational waves in future all-sky cosmic microwave background experiments by Hanchun Jiang, Toshiya Namikawa (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-15849.txt.
Introduction
Hanchun Jiang and Toshiya Namikawa study how doubt in the cosmos's second dawn affects our power to bound the waves sent out by the first burst of growth. Their paper is from two thousand twenty-four.
That dawn, when the first stars lit gas anew, leaves a large-scale mark in the glow left from the hot early cosmos. Sky-wide probes will read that mark to test the old waves. The team asks what goes wrong if the true past of that dawn has a unlike shape from the smooth form used to fit the data. With a probe like a planned space scope, they find the bounds stay much the same. The result calms a fear for such tests.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hanchun Jiang, Toshiya Namikawa |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-15849
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Impact of reionization history on constraining primordial gravitational waves in future all-sky cosmic microwave background experiments Hanchun Jiang, Toshiya Namikawa Abstract We explore the impact of the reionization history on examining the shape of the power spectrum of the primordial gravitational waves (PGWs) with the cosmic microwave background (CMB) polarization. The large-scale CMB generated from the reionization epoch is important in probing the PGWs from all-sky experiments, such as LiteBIRD. The reionization model has been constrained by several astrophysical observations. However, its uncertainty could impact constraining models of the PGWs if we use large-scale CMB polarization. Here, by expanding the analysis of Mortonson & Hu (2007), we estimate how reionization uncertainty impacts constraints on a generic primordial tensor power spectrum. We assume that CMB polarization is measured by a LiteBIRD-like experiment and the tanh model is adopted for a theoretical template when we fit data. We show that constraints are almost unchanged even if the true reionization history is described by an exponential model, where all parameters are within 68% Confidence Level (CL). We also show an example of the reionization history that the constraints on the PGWs are biased more than 68% CL. Even in that case, using E E -mode power spectrum on large scales would exclude such a scenario and make the PGW constraints robust against the reionization uncertainties. I Introduction Measurements of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies have extensively explored the origin of the universe. For example, observed CMB angular power spectra are in excellent agreement with the prediction of the \Lambda Cold-Dark-Matter ( \Lambda CDM) model. In the standard cosmological scenario, cosmic inflation, a period of rapid quasi-exponential expansion in the early universe brout1978creation ; kazanas1980dynamics ; starobinsky1980new ; guth1981inflationary ; sato1981first ; albrecht1982cosmology ; linde1982new , generates primordial density fluctuations through quantum fluctuations in the space-time metric mukhanov1981quantum ; guth1982fluctuations ; hawking1982development ; linde1982scalar ; starobinsky1982dynamics ; bardeen1983spontaneous , which will eventually become the structure of the universe. While the predicted primordial density fluctuations have already been tested by various astrophysical observations, the gravitational waves produced in the very early universe (primordial gravitational waves, PGWs) starobinskii1979spectrum ; rubakov1982graviton ; fabbri1983effect ; abbott1984constraints predicted by cosmic inflation remain unconfirmed. The most effective method for detecting PGWs is through the curl pattern ( B -modes) in CMB polarization maps, as linear-order density fluctuations do not generate B -modes but are sensitive to PGWs kamionkowski1997probe ; kamionkowski1997statistics ; seljak1997measuring ; seljak1997signature ; zaldarriaga1997all . The amplitude of the tensor power spectrum parameterized by the tensor-to-scalar ratio, r , provides insights into the energy scale of inflation davis1992cosmic ; kamionkowski2016quest ; achucarro2022inflation ; ade2021improved . Current CMB observations set upper limits on PGWs, refining inflationary models, with the best constraints from combined BICEP/Keck Array, Planck, and WMAP data, yielding r<0.032 at the pivot scale k_{\rm pivot}=0.05\, Mpc -1 at 95% Confidence Level (CL) Tristram:2022 . Currently, the Simons Observatory is observing the B -mode polarization precisely to reduce 68\% CL uncertainties of r to 0.002 Namikawa:2021gyh ; SimonsObservatory:2024:r . In the 2030s, LiteBIRD, a satellite designed for full-sky observations, aims at achieving the uncertainty to r below 0.001 litebird2023probing ; LiteBIRD:2023:delens . If current and future CMB experiments can yield an upper limit at r\sim 0.002 , it will constrain any single-field model with a characteristic potential scale larger than the Planck scale litebird2023probing . Next-generation CMB experiments aim to detect PGWs predicted by many inflationary models through large-scale B -mode signals, particularly at the reionization bump. This bump is shaped by Thomson scattering with free electrons during the reionization epoch, where neutral hydrogen was ionized by energetic photons from early luminous sources (see e.g. Natarajan:2014rra for a review). The amplitude and the exact shape of the bump are affected by the poorly constrained reionization history, making it crucial to address uncertainties from reionization history in PGW detection. CMB measurements have offered insights into the reionization epoch Lewis:2006ym ; WMAP7 ; Planck:2016mks ; Heinrich:2016ojb ; Hazra:2018eib ; Millea:2018bko ; Ahn:2020btj ; Qin:2020xrg . For example, Planck 2018 data constrains the optical depth to the CMB to \tau=0.054\pm 0.007 ( 68\% CL), corresponding to a reionization redshift z_{\rm re}=7.67\pm 0.73 ( 68\% CL) aghanim2020planck . This constraint is very close to that obtained recently with the Planck Public Release 4 Tristram:2023:PR4 . However, if we only use small-scale CMB measurements to avoid the uncertainties in the large-scale E -modes, recent constraints suggest \tau=0.080\pm 0.012 ( 68\% CL) giare2024measuring , indicating challenges in precision. High-redshift quasar and galaxy observations provide additional constraints. Gunn-Peterson troughs gunn1965density suggest reionization completed by z\sim 6 fan2006survey , while Lyman- \alpha optical depth fluctuations in quasar spectra bosman2022hydrogen and the inferred low mean free path of ionizing photons gaikwad2023measuring indicate a later completion around z\sim 5.2 . Measurements of the reionization history are even less precise, particularly regarding the time and spatial variations at higher redshifts Dai:2018nce . The Ly \alpha emission line, sensitive to neutral hydrogen, is a crucial probe ouchi2020observations , but Ly \alpha emitters (LAEs) at high redshifts ( z>7 ) are exceedingly rare, making it challenging to use these emitters to constrain the reionization history nakane2024lyalpha . In contrast, reconstructing reionization history with CMB needs an accurate polarization observation at large-angular scales to precisely measure the reionization bump Hu:2003gh ; Hazra:2018eib ; Watts:2020 ; Sakamoto:2022nth . These limitations leave a wide range of models viable under current constraints, highlighting significant uncertainties in our understanding of reionization. The uncertainties from the reionization history might affect the accuracy of reconstructing PGWs from polarization signals Mortonson:2007tb ; Lau:2013zea . Uncertainties in the reionization history could also impact the constraints on cosmology models beyond \Lambda CDM Paoletti:2020ndu and on the kinetic Sunayev Zel’dovich effect from reionization Gorce:2022cvb . Mortonson & Hu (2007) Mortonson:2007tb explore the impact of the reionization history on the constraints on r , assuming Planck or CMBPol experiment, as well as cosmic-variance limited cases. They assume r=0.3 or 0.03 as a fiducial parameter, both of which are almost excluded by the current B -mode measurements, so it is important to study again for r consistent with the current observation. Lau et al. (2013) Lau:2013zea investigated this problem in partial sky assuming Planck case. Several works have also studied the impacts of patchy reionization on the constraints on r jain2023framework ; mukherjee2019patchy ; jain2024disentangling . The present paper builds upon previous studies in two significant ways. First, we examine how uncertainties in the reionization history affect constraints on a generic primordial tensor power spectrum (PTPS). Previous studies typically assumed a standard scale-invariant spectrum for PTPS. However, full-sky CMB experiments, such as those targeting the B -mode signal, allow us to constrain the deviation of the tensor power spectrum from the standard PTPS parameterized by r . By measuring the B -mode power spectrum at both the reionization and recombination bumps, we can differentiate between various models of PGWs, such as the SU(2)-axion model LiteBIRD:2023zmo , and explore more general forms of the PTPS hiramatsu2018reconstruction . Second, we improve upon the experimental assumptions of previous studies. Earlier works considered CMB experimental configurations with significantly higher polarization noise than what is expected from upcoming missions or a cosmic-variance-limited scenario, making those assumptions unrealistic. In