Prime power coverings of groups

Michael Giudici, Luke Morgan, Cheryl E. Praeger · 2024

Read Prime power coverings of groups by Michael Giudici, Luke Morgan, Cheryl E. Praeger (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-15543.txt.

Introduction

Group theory asks how small a subgroup can be while still touching every class of special elements. Michael Giudici, Luke Morgan, and Cheryl Praeger tackle that question in this 2024 paper. The elements in focus have prime power order, meaning their repeated action cycles after a prime's power of steps. A covering subgroup must meet each family of such elements, where families are set by a larger group's symmetries.

A standing guess says the covering subgroup cannot be too small: its index is capped by a function of the outer group's size. That guess feeds into number theory questions about Brauer groups. The authors prove the guess when the subgroup's action on its own cosets has a strong transitivity trait. That case includes maximal subgroups. Their proof leans on a new bound tied to the classification of finite simple groups.

Catalog record

CREATORMichael Giudici, Luke Morgan, Cheryl E. Praeger
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-15543

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Prime power coverings of groups Michael Giudici, Luke Morgan, Cheryl E. Praeger Abstract For a finite group A A with normal subgroup G G , a subgroup U U of G G is an A A -prime-power-covering subgroup if U U meets every A A -conjugacy-class of elements of G G of prime power order. It is conjectured that | G : U | |G:U| is bounded by some function of | A : G | |A:G| , and this conjecture has number theoretic implications for relative Brauer groups of algebraic number fields. We prove the conjecture in the case that the action of G G on the set of right cosets of U U in G G is innately transitive. This includes the case where U U is a maximal subgroup of G G . The proof uses a new bound on the order of a nonabelian finite simple group in terms of its number of classes of elements of prime power order, which in turn depends on the Classification of the Finite Simple Groups. Keywords: covering subgroups, prime-power-covering, primitive groups 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification: 20B05, 20B15 1 Introduction A famous result of Jordan [ 12 ] asserts that every finite transitive permutation group on a set of size at least two contains a derangement (an element with no fixed points). This is equivalent to the statement that it is not possible to cover the elements of a finite group by the set of conjugates of a proper subgroup. To see the equivalence, given a group G with a subgroup U consider the action of G on the set of right cosets of U . Elements of G fix a point in this action precisely if they are conjugate to an element of U and so the guaranteed derangement is not contained in a conjugate of U . Jordan’s result has interesting applications in a wide variety of mathematical areas, see for example Serre’s article [ 22 ] . It has also motivated many questions about covering groups by conjugates of subgroups. One direction is to investigate how many conjugacy classes of subgroups are needed to cover the elements of a group. Such a covering is called a normal covering and the number of conjugacy classes involved is called the normal covering number . Groups with normal covering number two exist, for example when n and q are even, the symplectic group \mathrm{Sp}_{n}(q) can be covered by conjugates of its subgroups the orthogonal groups \mathrm{O}^{+}_{n}(q) and \mathrm{O}^{-}_{n}(q) . All finite simple groups with normal covering number two have recently been classified by Bubboloni, Spiga and Wiegel [ 3 ] who also gave an account of the many other areas of mathematics related to groups having normal covering number two. Another natural direction to explore is to allow images of the subgroup under automorphisms of the group. Given U<G\trianglelefteq A , we say that U is an A -covering subgroup of G if every element of G is A -conjugate to an element of U . Such coverings were explored by Brandl [ 2 ] and are connected to questions about Kronecker classes of fields, see [ 16 , 19 ] for a discussion of the links. Saxl [ 21 , Proposition 2] proved that a nonabelian finite simple group T has no proper \Aut(T) -covering subgroup and, building on work of Jehne [ 11 , Theorem 5 and Remark (6.4)] , showed that if M is Kronecker equivalent to a quadratic extension K of an algebraic number field k then M=K , answering a question posed in [ 11 ] . (For a finite extension K of an algebraic number field k , the Kronecker set of K over k is the set of all prime ideals of the ring of integers of k having a prime divisor of relative degree one in K ; and two finite extensions of k are Kronecker equivalent if their Kronecker sets have finite symmetric difference.) Neumann and the third author conjectured that the index in G of an A -covering subgroup of G is bounded by a function f of |A:G| , see [ 13 , Problem 11.71] and [ 19 , Conjecture 4.1] . The Neumann-Praeger Conjecture is equivalent to the following: for an extension L of a Galois extension K/k of degree n of algebraic number fields, if L and K are Kronecker equivalent over k then the degree of L over K is bounded above by a function of n . Saxl’s result implies that f(2)=1 . The third author proved this conjecture in the cases where U is a maximal subgroup of G [ 19 , Theorem 4.4] . Fusari, Harper and Spiga [ 5 ] have proved the conjecture where the A -chief length of G is bounded, correcting a subtle mistake in the first attempt of a proof of this result [ 19 , Theorem 4.6] . A surprising reformulation [ 14 , Question 6.1] of the Neumann–Praeger Conjecture relates the conjecture to the problem of bounding the degree of a permutation group whose derangement graph has no k -clique. This link is discussed in detail by Fusari, Previtali and Spiga (see [ 6 , Section 1.1] ) and they establish the veracity of [ 19 , Conjecture 4.1] in the case where the action of G on the set of right cosets of U is innately transitive, that is, has a transitive minimal normal subgroup [ 6 , Theorem 1.1] . Fein, Kantor and Schacher [ 4 , Theorem 1] proved a dramatic extension of Jordan’s result by showing that every finite transitive permutation group of degree at least two contains a derangement of prime power order. Whereas Jordan’s result is a simple application of the Orbit-Counting Lemma, the only known proof of [ 4 , Theorem 1] relies on the full strength of the Classification of the Finite Simple Groups. The motivation for this generalisation is that it is equivalent to the fact that the relative Brauer group of a nontrivial finite extension of global fields is infinite, see [ 4 , §3] . The result of Fein, Kantor and Schacher can also be rephrased to say that the set of elements of prime power order in a group cannot be covered by the set of conjugates of a proper subgroup. This rephrasing naturally lends itself to exploring the notion of an A -prime-power-covering subset as follows. For a subgroup U of a finite group A , and an element x\in A let x^{A}=\{x^{a}:a\in A\} denote the A -class of x , and let \mathcal{P}(U)=\{x\in U:|x|\ \text{is a prime power}\} denote the subset of elements of U of prime power order. We define P_{A}(U):=\{x^{a}:x\in\mathcal{P}(U),\ a\in A\} , the union of A -classes of elements of prime power order that intersect U nontrivially, and we call P_{A}(U) the A -prime-power-covering set of U . If subgroups U and G of A are conjugate then they have the same A -prime-power-covering sets. It is also possible for subgroups that are not A -conjugate to have this property. Perhaps the smallest example is A=\Alt(4) with G=C_{2}^{2} and U=C_{2} , and the following small examples from [ 16

Read the complete text