Statistical entropy of quantum systems

Smitarani Mishra, Shaon Sahoo · 2024

Read Statistical entropy of quantum systems by Smitarani Mishra, Shaon Sahoo (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-15316.txt.

Introduction

Smitarani Mishra and Shaon Sahoo examine entropy in quantum systems in work from 2024. Classic formulas for entropy were built for classical systems, and their quantum base is still debated.

The authors ask when the von Neumann entropy can serve as a true measure of heat-related entropy. They show the match is not universal and rests on subtle assumptions that are often missed. They also revisit two common critiques, that the measure does not change with time and that it fails a key sum rule, and argue both can be addressed for heat systems. Tests use a small spin system.

Catalog record

CREATORSmitarani Mishra, Shaon Sahoo
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-15316

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Statistical entropy of quantum systems Smitarani Mishra, Shaon Sahoo Abstract Statistical formulations of thermodynamic entropy, such as those by Boltzmann and Gibbs, were originally developed for classical systems and are well understood in that context. However, the foundational aspects of quantum statistical mechanics remain an area of active debate and are yet to be fully understood. This work is motivated by the need to develop a comprehensive understanding of the statistical measures of thermodynamic entropy in quantum systems - a topic intimately connected to the phenomenon of quantum thermalization. In particular, we investigate the conditions under which the von Neumann entropy can be regarded as a valid statistical measure of thermodynamic entropy in quantum systems. This paper demonstrates that the equivalence between the von Neumann and thermodynamic entropies is not universal, but instead depends on several subtle and often overlooked assumptions. In this context, we also briefly revisit key criticisms of von Neumann entropy — particularly its time-invariance and subadditivity — and argue that these concerns can be meaningfully addressed in the setting of thermodynamic systems. To substantiate some arguments and to clarify some issues, we provide suitable numerical results from our analysis of a spin-1/2 system. keywords Statistical Entropy, von Neumann Entropy 1 Introduction Since the development of quantum mechanics, there has been an enormous progress in our understanding of how the quantum many-body systems behave. This progress saw some foundational questions being asked and at-least partially answered. One of such questions is on whether and how the statistical mechanics works for the quantum many-body systems Gogolin and Eisert (2016) ; D’Alessio et al. (2016) ; Reimann (2008) . This gives rise to the important field of quantum statistical mechanics (QSM). The thermodynamic (TH) entropy is a very important state function which helps us understand how a system approaches equilibrium besides playing a crucial role in studying equilibrium properties of a system Kardar (2012) . The usefulness of the TH entropy naturally calls for its appropriate quantum counterpart in QSM. The TH entropy, as defined by Clausius in the context of second law of thermodynamics, is a state function which takes the maximum value for a system in the equilibrium under fixed macroscopic conditions Kardar (2012) ; Mori et al. (2018) . For an isolated system, this entropy never decreases when the system undergoes some process. Thus any entropy defined in the similar spirit for a quantum system must be a state function and should increase (or remain constant) when the system undergoes a process. Boltzmann, and later Gibbs, showed us how the TH entropy can be calculated from the microscopic details using statistical approaches Kardar (2012) ; Pathria and Beale (2011) . For an isolated system, Boltzmann gave a formula (actually Planck first wrote down the explicit expression for the Boltzmann entropy) for the TH entropy in terms of the volume of the relevant phase space (or the number of associated microstates). For the open system, Gibbs on the other hand, using his ensemble theory, provided the formula for the TH entropy in terms of an appropriate probability distribution function in phase space. In Sec. 2 , we discuss in detail the conditions under which these statistical measures of the TH entropy are valid and applicable. While the Boltzmann and Gibbs entropies (the statistical entropies) are understood and analyzed for the classical systems, their quantum analogues for isolated and open quantum systems in equilibrium are often considered intuitively plausible Goldstein et al. (2019) ; Mori et al. (2018) , although a thorough and convincing justification is still required - an issue we address in Sec. 2 . A more subtle and open question concerns the appropriate quantum version of thermodynamic (TH) entropy for a subsystem of a larger quantum system. Specifically, we aim to understand whether the von Neumann (VN) entropy of a subsystem can be regarded as equivalent to its TH entropy. This question is particularly important because quantum thermalization - and the framework of the Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis (ETH) - is fundamentally defined in terms of subsystems or local observables. We organize our paper in the following way. In the next section (Sec. 2 ), we review the thermodynamic and the (classical) statistical entropies (Boltzmann’s and Gibbs’ versions), and discuss the conditions under which the thermodynamic and statistical entropies are equivalent. This is followed by a discussion on the suitable quantum versions of the statistical entropies. Subsequently, we show that these quantum versions of the statistical entropies can be expressed in a basis-independent form, which coincidentally looks exactly like the VN entropy formula. In Sec. 3 , we discuss the von Neumann entropy and its interpretations. The discussion also includes some major reservations about the entropy when it comes to representing the thermodynamic entropy, and how to address them meaningfully. Next, in Sec. 4 , we start with the VN entropy and analyze if and when it reduces to the TH entropy; this is contrary to what is done in Sec. 2 : there we start with the TH entropy and show how in the quantum domain it can be written in a basis-independent form (which, coincidentally, looks like the VN entropy formula). Besides, not only isolated and open systems, we also analyze the important case related to subsystem in Sec. 4 . We conclude our work in Sec. 6 . 2 Thermodynamic and statistical entropies In this section we first briefly review the thermodynamic (TH) entropy and the (classical) statistical (ST) entropies (both Boltzmann’s and Gibbs’ versions). Next, we try to understand under what conditions these entropies (TH and ST) are equivalent. Subsequently, we discuss how these statistical entropies can be reinterpreted in terms of the quantum variables. At the end of this section, we discuss how the quantum versions of the ST entropies can be expressed in a basis-independent form (which, coincidentally, looks like the VN entropy formula). 2.1 Entropy: from Clausius to Boltzmann and Gibbs The Clausius theorem or the Clausius inequality states that Kardar (2012) , for any cyclic transformation or thermodynamic process, \oint\frac{{\mkern 3.0mu\mathchar 22\mkern-12.0mud}q}{T}\leq 0 , where {\mkern 3.0mu\mathchar 22\mkern-12.0mud}q is the heat increment received by the system at temperature T . Here the equality sign works only for a reversible cycle and this helps us to define a thermodynamic (TH) state function, called entropy. Strictly speaking, this state function (thermodynamic entropy, S_{TH} ) is well defined only for a thermodynamic system in equilibrium. If a system in equilibrium at temperature T receives {\mkern 3.0mu\mathchar 22\mkern-12.0mud}q amount of heat reversibly and subsequently reaches an equilibrium again, then the difference in entropy between these two equilibrium phases would be dS_{TH}=\frac{{\mkern 3.0mu\mathchar 22\mkern-12.0mud}q}{T} . In contrast, if the process is irreversible, then dS_{TH}>\frac{{\mkern 3.0mu\mathchar 22\mkern-12.0mud}q}{T} . This shows, for any isolated system undergoing a process ( {\mkern 3.0mu\mathchar 22\mkern-12.0mud}q=0 ), the change in its entropy is dS_{TH}\geq 0 . The Boltzmann’s version of statistical entropy is defined by the number of accessible microstates \Omega of a system (with a fixed energy). For a gaseous system, this number is proportional to the phase-space volume available to the system in the given macrostate. Here the statistical entropy is defined as S_{BN}=k_{B}\ln{\Omega} with k_{B} being the Boltzmann (BN) constant Kardar (2012) ; Landau et al.

Read the complete text