Orthospectrum and simple orthospectrum rigidity: finiteness and genericity.
Nolwenn Le Quellec · 2024
Read Orthospectrum and simple orthospectrum rigidity: finiteness and genericity. by Nolwenn Le Quellec (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-15034.txt.
Introduction
Nolwenn Le Quellec asks whether a surface's shape can be heard in the lengths of its shortest crosswise paths, in work from 2024. For compact hyperbolic surfaces with boundary, the orthospectrum lists the lengths of arcs that meet the boundary at right angles at both ends.
Le Quellec proves that only finitely many surfaces can share the same simple orthospectrum, and likewise for the full orthospectrum. Generic surfaces, in a precise sense, are completely determined by either list. The one-holed torus is pinned down by its simple orthospectrum alone. A corrected version of the paper fixes an error in one proof while keeping the main results intact.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nolwenn Le Quellec |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 112 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-15034
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Orthospectrum and simple orthospectrum rigidity: finiteness and genericity. Nolwenn Le Quellec Abstract Abstract . We study the orthospectrum and the simple orthospectrum of compact hyperbolic surfaces with geodesic boundary. We show that there are finitely many hyperbolic surfaces sharing the same simple orthospectrum and finitely many hyperbolic surfaces sharing the same orthospectrum. Then, we show that generic surfaces are determined by their orthospectrum and by their simple orthospectrum. We conclude with the example of the one-holed torus which is determined by its simple orthospectrum. AI Statement . This work was completed without use of artificial intelligence. The author does not consent for all or part of this work to be used for training of artificial intelligence models. 1 Introduction In a by now famous paper [ 17 ] , Kac asked "Can one hear the shape of a drum?". The question can be formalized mathematically using the fact that the sound made by a drum is linked to the frequencies at which a drumhead vibrates, that is, the spectrum of the Laplacian. Kac’s question then becomes: "Does the spectrum of the Laplacian of a planar domain determine the domain itself?". This question was then also asked for general Riemannian manifolds. In the case of closed hyperbolic surfaces, Huber and Selberg (see [ 8 , Chapter 7.1] ) showed that the Laplacian spectrum determines and is determined by the length spectrum, which is the set of lengths of closed geodesics counted with multiplicities. This shifted the question to "Does the length spectrum of a hyperbolic surface determine the metric up to isometry?". In 1978, Vignéras provided the first example of isospectral non-isometric closed hyperbolic surfaces [ 32 ] showing that the answer to the question is negative, and in 1985, Sunada gave a general criterion to construct isospectral non-isometric manifolds [ 30 ] . On the other hand, McKean proved that there is a finite number of isospectral non-isometric hyperbolic surfaces [ 22 ] . In 1979, Wolpert showed that a generic hyperbolic surface is determined by its length spectrum [ 33 ] . In 1985, Haas proved that the one-holed hyperbolic torus with a fixed boundary length is determined by the length spectrum [ 14 ] , and later Buser and Semmler removed the condition on the boundary length [ 7 ] . In the case of the simple spectrum (where only the simple closed geodesics are considered) the question is still open: there are no known examples of non-isometric hyperbolic surfaces with the same simple length spectrum. There is, however, a result by Baik, Choi and Kim showing that generic hyperbolic surfaces are also determined by their simple length spectrum [ 2 ] . In 1993, Basmajian introduced the orthospectrum of hyperbolic surfaces with boundary, defined as the set of lengths of geodesic arcs orthogonal to the boundary (called orthogeodesics) counted with multiplicities [ 3 ] . This object, analogous to the length spectrum, aims at taking the boundary of a surface more into account. In particular, Basmajian gave a formula to compute the boundary length of a hyperbolic surface from its orthospectrum [ 3 ] . Motivated by Kac’s question, Masai and McShane considered the analogous problem for the orthospectrum: "Does the orthospectrum of a hyperbolic surface determine the metric up to isometry?". They showed that there is a finite number of non-isometric hyperbolic surfaces with one boundary component sharing the same orthospectrum [ 21 ] . In the same paper, they showed that the one-holed torus is determined by its orthospectrum. They also gave a general construction for isospectral non-isometric hyperbolic surfaces, thus answering the question in the negative. In this paper, we investigate further Masai and McShane’s question, both for the orthospectrum and the simple orthospectrum. With the simple orthospectrum define as the multiset of lengths of simple orthogeodesics, counted with multiplicities. Note that even if the orthospectrum and simple orthospectrum seem related, there is no known way to deduce one from the other. Denoting by \mathcal{O}(X) and \mathcal{O}_{S}(X) the orthospectrum and the simple orthospectrum of a hyperbolic surface X , our main results are the following. Theorem 3.2 . Let S_{g}^{b} be a compact, genus g surface of negative Euler characteristic with b boundary components. Let X be a hyperbolic structure on S_{g}^{b} with geodesic boundary. Then, up to isometry, there is a finite number of hyperbolic structures Y on S_{g}^{b} such that \mathcal{O}(Y)=\mathcal{O}(X). This theorem extends Masai and McShane’s result from surfaces with a single boundary component to surfaces with several boundary component. The proof is based on Masai and McShane’s proof. The following theorem states a variation of this result for the simple orthospectrum. Theorem 3.3 . Let S_{g}^{b} be a compact, genus g surface of negative Euler characteristic with b boundary components. Let X be a hyperbolic structure on S_{g}^{b} with geodesic boundary. Then, up to isometry, there is a finite number of hyperbolic structures Y on S_{g}^{b} such that \mathcal{O}_{S}(Y)=\mathcal{O}_{S}(X). The proof of this theorem is inspired by the compactness argument in Masai and Mcshane’s proof, an argument that dates back to Wolpert, but the way we show that the set of hyperbolic surfaces with the same simple orthospectrum is compact is completely different. Instead of relying on orthogeodesics with one self-intersection as Masai and McShane do, our proof uses arc and curve counting results by Bell and Mirzahani. We also establish an analogue of Wolpert’s result both for the orthospectrum and the simple orthospectrum. Theorem 4.1 . Generic surfaces in \mathrm{Teich}(S_{g}^{b}) are determined, up to isometry, by their orthospectrum. Similarly, generic surfaces in \mathrm{Teich}(S_{g}^{b}) are also determined, up to isometry, by their simple orthospectrum. We were inspired by Wolpert’s proof of the generic determination by the length spectrum. Main differences between the proofs lie in the preparation and the use of a different type of coordinates for the Teichmüller space in the main part of the proof. Finally, we show: Theorem 5.2 . Let T and T^{\prime} be two hyperbolic structures with geodesic boundary on the one-holed torus. Then T and T^{\prime} are isometric if and only if \mathcal{O}_{S}(T)=\mathcal{O}_{S}(T^{\prime}) . This paper is organized as follows. We recall in Section 2 properties of hyperbolic surfaces and geodesics that will be needed in the rest of the paper. In Section 3 , we prove Theorem 3.2 and Theorem 3.3 . We prove Theorem 4.1 in Section 4 . Finally, in Section 5 we show Theorem 5.2 . Acknowledgments . We appreciate the support, guidance and help of Federica Fanoni and Stéphane Sabourau, both PhD advisors of the author, in particular for their help in the writing. The author would also like to thank Nhat Minh Doan for finding a mistake in the first version of the paper and Marie Trin for her help to understand curve counting results. 2 Preliminaries 2.1 Curves and arcs on surfaces. Throughout this paper, S_{g}^{b} will denote an orientable, compact, genus g surface of negative Euler characteristic with b>0 boundary components. Moreover, arcs are always defined with endpoints on the boundary and closed curves are always considered primitive. Definition 2.1 . A closed curve on S_{g}^{b} is essential if it is not homotopic to a boundary component or to a point. It is simple if it