Broken symmetry solutions in one-dimensional lattice models via many-body perturbation theory

Matteo Quinzi, Tommaso Chiarotti, Marco Gibertini, Andrea Ferretti · 2024

Read Broken symmetry solutions in one-dimensional lattice models via many-body perturbation theory by Matteo Quinzi, Tommaso Chiarotti, Marco Gibertini, Andrea Ferretti (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-15020.txt.

Introduction

Matteo Quinzi, Tommaso Chiarotti, Marco Gibertini, and Andrea Ferretti hunt for broken-symmetry states in one-dimensional lattice models using many-body perturbation theory. Their 2024 paper solves the Dyson equation fully self-consistently, through an algorithmic inversion method built on sums of poles. The testbed is the one-dimensional Hubbard model, and the approximation is the GW method, a standard way to dress electrons with screening.

With local interactions the method behaves as expected. Adding long-range Coulomb forces sets two ordered states against each other: antiferromagnetism, where neighboring spins alternate, and a charge density wave, where charge bunches in a pattern. The authors also solve a companion equation. It recovers the non-interacting system with the same charge density, and lets them size up a jump in the effective potential that feeds the fundamental gap. In some cases that jump dominates the gap entirely.

Catalog record

CREATORMatteo Quinzi, Tommaso Chiarotti, Marco Gibertini, Andrea Ferretti
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE82 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-15020

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Broken symmetry solutions in one-dimensional lattice models via many-body perturbation theory Matteo Quinzi, Tommaso Chiarotti, Marco Gibertini, Andrea Ferretti Abstract In this work we study self-consistent solutions in one-dimensional lattice models obtained via many-body perturbation theory. The Dyson equation is solved in a fully self-consistent manner via the algorithmic-inversion method based on the sum-over-poles representation (AIM-SOP) of dynamical operators. In particular, we focus on the GW approximation, analyzing the spectral properties and the emergence of possible magnetic- or charge-density-wave broken symmetry solutions. We start by validating our self-consistent AIM-SOP implementation by taking as test case the one-dimensional Hubbard model. We then move to the study of antiferromagnetic and charge density wave solutions in one-dimensional lattice models, taking into account a long-range Coulomb interaction between the electrons. We show that moving from local to non-local electronic interactions leads to a competition between antiferromagnetic and charge-density-wave broken symmetry solutions. Complementary, by solving the Sham-Schlüter equation, we can compute the non-interacting Green’s function reproducing the same charge density of the interacting system. In turn, this allows for the evaluation of the derivative discontinuity of the Kohn-Sham (KS) potential, showing that its contribution to the fundamental gap can become dominating in some of the studied cases. I Introduction One-dimensional systems constitute an optimal playground to study the effect of electronic correlations at a reduced computational cost with respect to systems of higher dimensionality. A recent study of one-dimensional hydrogen chains Motta et al. 2020 has shown how the presence of long-range Coulomb repulsion between the electrons can give rise to a rich phase diagram, including antiferromagnetic (AFM) domains and metal-to-insulator (MIT) transitions. Furthermore one-dimensional quasi-metals constitute a prototypical example of Peierls transitions Peierls 1929 , where a periodic lattice distortion destabilizes the metallic phase leading to an insulating state with a lower total energy. However it has been recently pointed out that the same systems can host a purely electronic charge density wave (CDW) that does not involve a structural symmetry breaking Barborini et al. 2022 . This electronic CDW, which destabilizes the one-dimensional quasi-metal by opening a small energy gap could be related to an excitonic mechanism Sherrington and Kohn 1968 ; Varsano et al. 2017 . However studies performed on one-dimensional Hubbard chains Hubbard 1963 have shown that an approximate treatment of the electron-electron repulsion can lead to unphysical solutions with a broken symmetry ground state Joost et al. 2022 ; Honet et al. 2022 : this is the case of antiferromagnetic (AFM) solutions found via many-body perturbation theory Fetter and Walecka 1971 ; Martin et al. 2016 ; Stefanucci and van Leeuwen 2013 , while an analytical treatment of one-dimensional Hubbard clusters predicts a non-magnetic (NM) ground state Lieb and Wu 1968 ; Lieb and Wu 2003 (also referred to as a paramagnetic state in the literature Honet et al. 2022 ). In the framework of MBPT, the information about the charged excitations of the interacting system is encoded in the one-particle Green’s function (GF), with the effect of the electronic interaction described by the non-local and dynamical self-energy operator \Sigma(\omega) . For conserving approximations Baym and Kadanoff 1961 ; Baym 1962 , the MBPT problem can also be recast in a functional formulation via the Luttinger-Ward Luttinger and Ward 1960 and Klein Klein 1961 functionals, which ultimately require the Dyson equation to be solved in a self-consistent way. Despite the potential of MBPT, density functional theory (DFT) Hohenberg and Kohn 1964 in its Kohn-Sham formulation (KS-DFT) Kohn and Sham 1965 is still one of the mostly used tools in electronic structure calculations Marzari et al. 2021 . The bridge between the MBPT framework and the KS-DFT formalism is given by the Sham-Schlüter equation (SSE) Sham 1985 ; Sham and Schlüter 1983 that allows one to compute the local Kohn-Sham exchange-correlation potential once the self-consistent GF and its corresponding self-energy are known. Although the SSE can be solved self-consistently, the solution is typically found in its linearized form Casida 1995 . Part of the difficulty in solving the self-consistent Dyson equations stems from the handling of dynamical potentials. In this respect, Chiarotti et al. Chiarotti et al. 2022 ; Chiarotti 2023 ; Chiarotti et al. 2024 have recently exploited sum-over-poles (SOP), i.e. meromorphic (and rational) functions of the frequency having only simple (first order) poles, to represent dynamical propagators and self-energies. Similar constructions have also been employed, e.g., in Refs. Engel et al. 1991 ; Puig von Friesen et al. 2010 ; Di Sabatino et al. 2021 . Moreover, in Refs. Chiarotti et al. 2022 ; Chiarotti 2023 ; Chiarotti et al. 2024 , the SOP representation is combined with the algorithmic-inversion method (AIM-SOP) providing an in-principle exact way of solving the Dyson equation at all frequencies by means of the diagonalization of a linear eigenvalue problem in a larger space Güttel and Tisseur 2017 . Similar approaches have been used in the context of DMFT, GW, Bethe-Salpeter equation Savrasov et al. 2006 ; Budich et al. 2012 ; Wang et al. 2012 ; Bintrim and Berkelbach 2021 ; Bintrim and Berkelbach 2022 ; Monino and Loos 2023 . For instance, SOP-representations have been recently exploited in the multi-pole approximation (MPA) for full-frequency GW calculations Leon et al. 2021 ; Leon et al. 2023 ; Leon et al. 2025 to represent the RPA response functions, self-energies, and Green’s functions. In addition, the AIM-SOP framework can also be exploited Ferretti et al. 2024 to provide a fully analytical way of evaluating the Klein functional Klein 1961 . In this work we study self-consistent solutions of the Dyson equation as resulting from different self-energy approximations in a MBPT context, applied to one-dimensional lattice models, also including long-range interactions beyond the local Hubbard repulsion. Additionally, we also solve the – non-linearized – SSE and evaluate the derivative discontinuity of the Kohn-Sham potential. Technically, we make use of the AIM-SOP framework Chiarotti et al. 2022 ; Chiarotti et al. 2024 ; Chiarotti 2023 in order to implement a fully self-consistent solution of the Dyson equation, and also exploit a recently developed analytically expression to evaluate the \Phi[G] terms of the Klein functional Ferretti et al. 2024 . Our results show that the AIM-SOP framework is capable of solving self-consistently the Dyson equation in a stable and accurate way for the systems considered, obtaining an excellent agreement with Refs. Puig von Friesen et al. 2010 ; Di Sabatino et al. 2021 ; Joost et al. 2022 . Physically, when a long-range electronic repulsion is introduced in the model, both AFM and CDW solutions can be found depending on the strength of the non-local interaction term, consistently with the results of Refs. Motta et al. 2020 ; Barborini et al. 2022 . We show that the interplay between the local and non-local electronic interactions leads to a competition between AFM and CDW phases in the exact ground state, and thus to an explicit symmetry breaking in the case of MBPT solutions. This effect is particularly relevant in the case of a non-interacting metallic ground state. Remarkably, the evaluation of the total energy within the GW approximation improves considerably in the case of symmetry unrestricted calculations. Furthermore, by solving the SSE problem, we also find that the KS

Read the complete text