How many interactions does it take to modify a jet?

Chiara Le Roux, José Guilherme Milhano, Korinna Zapp · 2024

Read How many interactions does it take to modify a jet? by Chiara Le Roux, José Guilherme Milhano, Korinna Zapp (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-14983.txt.

Introduction

Chiara Le Roux, José Guilherme Milhano, and Korinna Zapp tackle a jet puzzle in small crash systems in a 2024 paper. In proton-lead crashes, fast bits spray out with a side tilt, yet their yield shows no loss. Loss with tilt is the norm in big systems, so the pair should clash. The team use a jet quench model and a plain brick of hot stuff. One joint count grades the stuff: hits per bit times a screen mass term.

For small systems and mild change, both yield and tilt scale with that count. The catch is scale: it takes a lot of hits to bend a jet in a clear way. The yield dip that pairs with the seen tilt may hide in test error bars. So no clash stands yet, the team say. Big loss breaks the scale in set ways, which they map.

Catalog record

CREATORChiara Le Roux, José Guilherme Milhano, Korinna Zapp
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-14983

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

How many interactions does it take to modify a jet? Chiara Le Roux, José Guilherme Milhano, Korinna Zapp Abstract It is a continued open question how there can be an azimuthal anisotropy of high p ⟂ p_{\perp} particles quantified by a sizable v 2 v_{2} in p+Pb collisions when, at the same time, the nuclear modification factor R AA R_{\text{AA}} is consistent with unity. We address this puzzle within the framework of the jet quenching model Jewel . In the absence of reliable medium models for small collision systems we use the number of scatterings per parton times the squared Debye mass to characterise the strength of medium modifications. Working with a simple brick medium model we show that, for small systems and not too strong modifications, R AA R_{\text{AA}} and v 2 v_{2} approximately scale with this quantity. We find that a comparatively large number of scatterings is needed to generate measurable jet quenching. Our results indicate that the R AA R_{\text{AA}} corresponding to the observed v 2 v_{2} could fall within the experimental uncertainty. Thus, while there is currently no contradiction with the measurements, our results indicate that v 2 v_{2} and R AA R_{\text{AA}} go hand-in-hand. We also discuss departures from scaling, in particular, due to sizable inelastic energy loss. 1 Introduction In the field of relativistic heavy ion collisions, the idea that high energy partons travelling through a medium will lose energy due to successive interactions with the medium constituents has long been established. This was done from the theoretical point of view bjEloss , BDMPS (for reviews see Wiedemann:2009sh , Majumder:2010qh , Mehtar-Tani:2013pia , Qin:2015srf , Apolinario:2022vzg ) and subsequently confirmed experimentally expQuenching1 , expQuenching2 (for reviews see Connors:2017ptx , Cunqueiro:2021wls ). The experimental confirmation was carried out via the measurement of nuclear modification factors, which compare the yields of high p ⟂ particles or jets in heavy ion collisions to those in pp collisions, where no medium was expected to be formed. These measurements were then repeated in small collision systems such as d+Au and p+Pb and the absence of quenching was confirmed expSmallSys1 , expSmallSys2 , ALICE:2015umm , CMS:2015gcq , CMS:2016svx , ALICE:2021wct , ATLAS:2022iyq , ALICE:2023plt , ATLAS:2014cpa , Khachatryan:2015xaa , Adam:2016jfp , Adam:2016dau . Such results motivated the interpretation of this suppression in the yields as a signature of the presence of a quark gluon plasma (QGP) phase in the early stages of relativistic heavy ion collisions. As a means to investigate this newly discovered, short lived phase of matter, several other observables were proposed. One of them is the azimuthal momentum anisotropy, which is commonly characterised via the flow coefficients, v_{n} , appearing in the Fourier decomposition of the particle distribution \frac{dN}{d\phi}=\frac{1}{2}\left(1+2\sum_{n}v_{n}\cos(2(\phi-\Psi_{n}))\right)\,. (1) Here, \Psi_{n} is the azimuthal angle of the n th symmetry plane. Since the overlap region of two colliding nuclei has a strong elliptical deformation, the corresponding elliptical term in the momentum distribution, v_{2} , is the most prominent one in heavy ion collisions. For n=2 , \Psi_{2} is the orientation of the short axis of the overlap region. Therefore, when all v_{n}=0 , the distribution is completely isotropic and, as it acquires an ellipsoidal shape, a non-zero v_{2} is observed. Several experiments have measured the flow coefficients and found them to be non-zero in relativistic heavy ion collisions v21 , v22 , Wang:2024irg , STAR:2011ert , Korotkikh:2010iao . In these collisions a non-vanishing v_{2} of low transverse momentum particles is a consequence of the collective flow of the system. Because the pressure gradient driving the expansion is larger along the short axis of the overlap region than along the long axis, the particles are pushed out preferentially along the short axis. At high p ⟂ , v_{2} is generated via the path length dependence of the energy loss suffered by the hard particle. It is thus also a consequence of the geometry of the system, but is not related to collective flow. Surprisingly, sizable flow coefficients, in particular v_{2} , were also observed in small systems v2small1 , v2small2 . These systems are believed to be too short lived to develop collective flow, but it has been shown in kinetic theory that, even with a low number of scatterings per particle, a sizable soft particle v_{2} can be generated via the so-called escape mechanism Kurkela:2018ygx , Ambrus:2021fej , He:2015hfa , Molnar:2019yam , Kurkela:2021ctp . On the other hand, an explanation in terms of a hydrodynamic evolution of the system has also been put forward Weller:2017tsr (and criticised in Zhou:2020pai ). While viable explanations thus exist for the observation of non-vanishing v_{2} of soft particles in small collision systems, the same is not true for the v_{2} of high p ⟂ particles found in such systems ATLAS:2019vcm , ALICE:2022cwa , CMS-PAS-HIN-23-002 . According to our current understanding, that would have to be generated by anisotropic energy loss, but the absence of jet quenching contradicts such an interpretation. However, the question really remains a quantitative one, namely whether it is possible that a small amount of energy loss could generate a measurable high p ⟂ v_{2} while not leading to a measurable R_{\text{AA}} of hard particles or jets. The present work aims to address precisely that question. To model the energy loss of hard partons, the Jewel event generator is used. Usually one must make assumptions of what a medium looks like and how it should expand, which, in turn, adds uncertainties about the assumptions in the specific the medium model used. In order to reduce the dependence on the medium model, we take a different approach and look specifically into how many jet-medium interactions one needs in order to see the aforementioned effects. In practice, we actually look at the magnitude of the average number of interactions per jet particle times the squared Debye mass of the medium \left<\text{n}_{\text{int}}\right>\cdot(\text{DM})^{2} , as will be discussed in the later sections. Therefore, we perform this study using a simplified medium model and then, knowing the \left<\text{n}_{\text{int}}\right>\cdot(\text{DM})^{2} needed to get effects of a given magnitude, we look into more realistic media. 2 JEWEL Monte Carlo Model The Monte Carlo model Jewel Zapp:2012ak simulates the QCD evolution of highly energetic partons produced in hard scattering processes in the presence of a background medium. It is based on Pythia 6.4 Sjostrand:2006za , which provides the hard scattering matrix elements, initial state parton shower and hadronisation. Jewel has a virtuality ordered final state parton shower that is similar but not identical to the virtuality ordered parton shower in Pythia 6. In vacuum this is an ordinary parton shower with the somewhat special feature that recoils from splittings are handled locally and in such a way that the algorithm never goes back to modify the kinematics of an earlier splitting. In the presence of a coloured medium, scattering off medium constituents can occur between the splittings generated by the parton shower. The scatterings are described by pQCD t -channel matrix elements regularised by the screening mass DM. If such a scattering is harder than the current parton shower scale it can reset the parton shower, re-starting it at the scale of the scattering. In this way, medium induced bremsstrahlung is effectively included and it is

Read the complete text