Study of NbN as superconducting material for the usage in superconducting radio frequency cavities
Kristof Schmieden, Tim Schneemann, Matthias Schott, Malavika Unni, Hendrik Bekker, Arne Wickenbrock, Dmitry Budker · 2024
Read Study of NbN as superconducting material for the usage in superconducting radio frequency cavities by Kristof Schmieden, Tim Schneemann, Matthias Schott, Malavika Unni, Hendrik Bekker, Arne Wickenbrock, Dmitry Budker (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-14958.txt.
Introduction
Kristof Schmieden and co-authors study, in a 2024 paper, how a niobium nitride coating behaves in a superconducting radio frequency cavity set inside a strong magnetic field. The cavity belongs to a new experiment hunting for axions, hypothetical particles that may make up dark matter. The search needs a cavity that keeps a high quality factor while sitting in the field that coaxes axions to reveal themselves.
Their cavity, coated with the nitride, was tested at a resonance near 8.4 gigahertz in a 2.5 tesla field. As the field rose, the surface resistance rose with it. That lowered the quality factor, meaning more energy leaked per cycle. The pattern matched earlier cavities made with a related tin compound. The result tells the axion hunters what performance to expect, and what to improve, in the magnetic setting.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kristof Schmieden, Tim Schneemann, Matthias Schott, Malavika Unni, Hendrik Bekker, Arne Wickenbrock, Dmitry Budker |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 11 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-14958
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Study of NbN as superconducting material for the usage in superconducting radio frequency cavities Kristof Schmieden, Tim Schneemann, Matthias Schott, Malavika Unni, Hendrik Bekker, Arne Wickenbrock, Dmitry Budker Abstract A new axion-haloscope is setup at the Johannes Gutenberg university of Mainz, named the Supax (a SUPerconducting AXion search) experiment. This setup is used to characterize the behaviour of a NbN coated superconducting cavity in a 2.5 T strong magnetic field, at a resonance frequency of 8.4 GHz . We observe an increasing surface resistance with increasing magnetic field, leading to a decreasing quality factor. The behaviour is similar to that of previously studied cavities using Nb 3 Tn \text{Nb}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{3}}}\text{Tn} . 1 Introduction The quest to find the axion solving the strong-CP problem [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] has spawned a multitude of experiments, which exploit coupling of the axion field to nucleons, gluons and photons. A detailed overview on the experimental searches for axions can be found in Refs. [ 4 , 5 ] . Three types of experiments study the axion-photon coupling and are targeting different sources of axions: Light-shining-through-wall experiments (LSTW), where the axions are produced in the laboratory; helioscopes using the sun as source and haloscopes looking for axions in the dark matter halo of our galaxy [ 6 ] . In all three types of experiments the axions convert in a magnetized volume via the inverse Primakoff effect into photons. The photon frequency corresponds to the axion energy. To boost the conversion rate of axions to photons both LSTW and haloscope experiments utilize resonators. For typical haloscope experiments the resonance frequencies lie in the radio frequency (RF) regime and cavities are used to resonantly enhance the signal. The signal over noise ratio of a haloscope experiment is given by \text{SNR}\propto g_{a\gamma\gamma}^{2}m_{a}VC_{mnl}B^{2}Q_{L}\frac{1}{T_{\text{sys}}} (1) where g_{a\gamma\gamma} is the axion–photon coupling, m_{a} the axion mass, B the static magnetic field, V the conversion volume of the cavity, T_{\text{sys}} the systems noise temperature and C_{mnl} the geometric form factor describing the overlap of the cavity mode with the magnetic field. Q_{L} is the loaded quality factor of the cavity and the main topic of this paper. In recent years superconducting cavities were studied by several experiments like RADES [ 7 ] and at CAPP [ 8 ] in order to increase the quality factor and hence the sensitivity. As it turns out, classic superconductors, in particular pure Nb and \text{Nb}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{3}}}\text{Tn} exhibit an increasing surface resistance with increasing magnetic field and show lower quality factors than non superconducting copper cavities at high magnetic fields. High temperature superconductors (HTS) based on rare-earth barium copper oxide (REBCO) show good performance in magnetic fields with quality factors above 3\cdot 10^{5} at 8 T field as shown in [ 8 ] . However, HTS tapes are not suitable for coating curved surfaces significantly constraining usable cavity geometries. REBCO coated cavities are typically built out of many pieces with flat surfaces, approximating the desired geometry. This works well for cylindrical shapes, where the simulated losses due to not coated ends of the cavity are in the order of 10\% [ 7 ] . For other shapes, like spherical cavities a significant reduction in performance is expected in addition the mechanical challenges. To overcome this problem we study niobium nitride (NbN) as superconductor in the context of a new axion haloscope experiment, Supax , which is currently prepared [ 9 ] at Mainz and Bonn. 2 Cavity Design A cavity with a resonance frequency of the TM 010 mode of 8.4 GHz was designed, based on experiences from the RADES group [ 7 ] . The cavity is built out of two copper half-shells with dimensions 27 mm x 40 mm x 160 mm. The inner dimensions are 22.8 mm x 30 mm x 150 mm where all corners of the cavity are rounded with a radius of 9 mm. Expendable material is removed from the outside as much as possible to lower the heat capacity. A 2\,\mu m thick layer of NbN was deposited on the copper substrate [ 10 , 11 ] . Images of the cavity half-shell before and after the coating are shown in Fig. 1 . Two antennas are attached to the cavity at opposite ends of its long-axis. One is strongly coupled to the TM 010 mode, the other weakly. The resonance frequency of the TM 010 mode is measured to be 8.4 GHz at a temperature of 4 K. Figure 1 : Images of the cavity under test. Left: the electropolished copper cavity. Right: after depositing the NbN superconductor. 3 The Measurement Setup The Supax experiment is currently setup at the University of Mainz and utilises a liquid helium cryostat inserted into the room temperature bore of a 14.1 T magnet located at the Helmholz-Institute Mainz. A schematic drawing of the experiment is shown in Fig. 3 together with its data acquisition system in Fig. 3 . Figure 2 : Schematic drawing of the setup of the Supax experiment. Figure 3 : Schematic view of the data acquisition system. The temperature of the cryostat can be adjusted between 1.5 K and 300 K as needed and is stabilised to better than 0.1 K at 4 K. The magnetic field can be adjusted between 0 and 14.1 T with a ramp time of approximately 5 h. Signals from the cavity are amplified by a 36 dB cryogenic low noise amplifier, which is connected via a circulator to the strongly coupled cavity port to avoid reflections off the amplifier. Signals can be injected into the cavity either via the weakly coupled antenna or through the circulators 3rd port and the strongly coupled antenna. Both input lines are equipped with attenuators which are thermally coupled to the base temperature of the cryostat to diminish thermal noise from outside of the cryostat. This setup allows measuring the S_{11} and S_{12} parameters with a vector network analyser without changing the setup. The resonance frequency of the cavity is determined from the S_{21} parameter to be f_{0}=8.4 GHz. The loaded quality factor Q_{L} is calculated dividing the centre frequency by the width of the resonance curve 3\,\text{dB} below the maximum. Q_{L}=\frac{f_{0}}{\text{FWHM}}. (2) Due to the installed pre-amplifier and losses in the cables the normalization of the measured S-parameters is lost and needs to be restored. For this the S_{11} parameter is plotted in the complex plane, where a scan over the resonance peak will form a circle. The data is rescaled so that the fit of the data around the peak has its maximum magnitude at \lvert S_{11}\rvert=1 , as shown in Fig. 4 . The rescaled data is converted to a linear scale and the coupling factor \beta is determined as \beta=\frac{1-\min(\lvert S_{11}\rvert)}{1+\min(\lvert S_{11}\rvert)} (3) if the port is undercoupled and \beta=\frac{1+\min(\lvert S_{11}\rvert)}{1-\min(\lvert S_{11}\rvert)} (4) otherwise. Note that for critical coupling ( \beta=1 ) eqs. 3 , 4 are equal since S_{11}^{\beta=1}=0 at the resonance frequency. The information if the port is over- or under coupled is obtained from the fit of a circle to the rescaled S_{11} data. If the diameter of the circle is larger than 1, the port is overcoupled and undercoupled otherwise. Figure 4 : On the left