Robust estimates of theoretical uncertainties at fixed-order in perturbation theory
Matthew A. Lim, Rene Poncelet · 2024
Read Robust estimates of theoretical uncertainties at fixed-order in perturbation theory by Matthew A. Lim, Rene Poncelet (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-14910.txt.
Introduction
Lim and Poncelet propose a sturdier way to estimate the error bars on particle physics calculations, in a 2024 paper. Calculations stop at a fixed order, and the missing orders are the true uncertainty. The standard trick varies an energy scale, but it can badly understate the error.
Their fix adds theory nuisance parameters that stand in for the missing terms directly. Varying those parameters traces the uncertainty. On several collider processes, the method matched scale variation where that trick behaves. Where scale variation understates, the new estimates grew appropriately. The authors offer it as a simple, more honest error recipe.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Matthew A. Lim, Rene Poncelet |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-14910
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Robust estimates of theoretical uncertainties at fixed-order in perturbation theory Preprint: IFJPAN-IV-2024-15 Matthew A. Lim, Rene Poncelet Abstract Calculations truncated at a fixed order in perturbation theory are accompanied by an associated theoretical uncertainty, which encodes the missing higher orders (MHOU). This is typically estimated by a scale variation procedure, which has well-known shortcomings. In this work, we propose a simple prescription to directly encode the missing higher order terms using theory nuisance parameters (TNPs) and estimate the uncertainty by their variation. We study multiple processes relevant for Large Hadron Collider physics at next-to-leading and next-to-next-to-leading order in perturbation theory, obtaining MHOU estimates for differential observables in each case. In cases where scale variations are well-behaved we are able to replicate their effects using TNPs, while we find significant improvement in cases where scale variation typically underestimates the uncertainty. I Introduction A long-standing problem in using renormalisable quantum field theories to make phenomeological predictions in perturbation theory is how one reliably estimates missing higher-order uncertainties (MHOU). The conventional method to gauge the size of these terms relies on the fact that, for a prediction truncated at a given order, the difference between predictions computed at different values of the unphysical renormalisation scale \mu is of genuinely higher order. Typically, practitioners choose a ‘good’ value of the central scale and take an envelope of scale variations as a measure of the uncertainty. One then expects the size of this uncertainty to reduce as one calculates successive orders. There remains, however, an arbitrariness in the choice of the central scale and in the size of the variations which one performs. In practice, one often finds that scale variations provide an underestimate of the theoretical uncertainty, due to e.g. the emergence of new partonic channels at higher orders, cancellations rendering corrections artificially small, etc. In addition, scale variations do not correlate uncertainties between bins of a differential distribution (or between multiple differential distributions) correctly; moreover, \mu itself does not represent an actual parameter with a true value which the prediction depends upon, and thus cannot be relied upon to determine a true uncertainty. Various attempts have been made to place the MHOU estimation problem on a more stable footing. Ref. Cacciari and Houdeau 2011 aimed to associate the MHOU with a Bayesian degree of confidence, based on the perturbative expansion of an observable. This was further refined in Ref. Bonvini 2020 , which aimed to better treat cases with large higher-order corrections. Both methods were scrutinised in Ref. Duhr et al. 2021 , which also aimed to incorporate the dependence on the renormalisation and factorisation scales \mu_{R} , \mu_{F} into Bayesian inference. Ref. Ghosh et al. 2023 took a rather different approach, proposing an uncertainty estimate for an arbitrary process based on the scale variations of a set of QCD reference processes. Theory nuisance parameters (TNPs) were introduced in Ref. Tackmann 2024 as a way to directly parameterise unknown higher-order terms. Recent applications have sought to use TNPs in conjunction with scale variations to estimate the uncertainty from unknown higher-loop ingredients at a given order in resummed perturbation theory Dehnadi et al. 2023 ; Ju et al. 2023 ; Cal et al. 2024 . This is highly convenient, since factorisation in Soft-Collinear Effective Theory dictates the structure of the resummed calculation to all orders. This information allows TNPs to be directly identified with unknown terms in the resummation, such as anomalous dimensions. In a similar vein, TNPs have been employed to obtain approximate N 3 LO parton distribution functions by the MSHT collaboration McGowan et al. 2023 , where they have been used to parameterise both partially known PDF ingredients at N 3 LO and completely unknown cross sections. TNPs thus serve as an appealing alternative to the scale variation procedure, even for calculations at fixed order Tackmann 2024 . In this work, we apply TNPs to estimate missing higher-order uncertainties for fixed-order differential distributions. Unlike the resummed case, the all-order structure of a fixed-order calculation is a priori unknown. This necessarily introduces a greater arbitrariness in exactly how the parameterisation is accomplished. We shall show, however, that using relatively simple ansätze we are able to produce uncertainty bands which show a good convergence between orders, replicate the effects of scale variation procedures in cases where these work well, and greatly improve on scale variation in cases where it fails. Figure 1: Comparison between MHOU estimates from TNP and scale variation for differential distributions in t\bar{t} production, with QCD corrections to the production and decay processes treated separately and combined in the narrow width approximation. From left to right, we show the lepton pair invariant mass m(\ell\bar{\ell}) , the transverse momentum of the hardest b -jet p_{T}(b_{1}) and the ratio of the lepton transverse momenta p_{T}(\ell_{1})/p_{T}(\ell_{2}) . We take \mu=H_{T}/4 as our central scale choice and use a Bernstein parameterisation. The solid lines represent the LO (green), NLO (blue) and NNLO (red) central predictions and the corresponding bands of the estimated MHOU. The vertical lines indicate statistical uncertainties. We do not associate a TNP uncertainty with the LO prediction – see text for details. Figure 2: As in fig. 1 , but for \gamma jj production. We take \mu=H_{T} as our central scale choice and use a Chebyshev parameterisation. From left to right we show the hardest jet transverse momentum p_{T}^{\rm jet} , the photon transverse energy E_{T}(\gamma) , the invariant mass of the system m(\gamma j_{1}j_{2}) and the absolute rapidity difference between photon and hardest jet |\Delta y^{\gamma-\rm{jet}}| . II Implementation In contrast to resummed perturbation theory, given a computation at a certain fixed order we can infer very little about the structure of higher-order corrections a priori . We must therefore introduce some parameterisation of the missing higher orders. We begin by writing the expansion of a differential cross section in the strong coupling \alpha_{s} as \displaystyle\mathrm{d}\sigma \displaystyle=\alpha_{s}^{n}N_{c}^{m}\,\mathrm{d}\bar{\sigma}^{(0)}+\alpha_{s}^{n+1}N_{c}^{m+1}\,\mathrm{d}\bar{\sigma}^{(1)} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad+\alpha_{s}^{n+2}N_{c}^{m+2}\,\mathrm{d}\bar{\sigma}^{(2)}+\dots \displaystyle=\alpha_{s}^{n}N_{c}^{m}\,\mathrm{d}\bar{\sigma}^{(0)}\bigg[1+\alpha_{s}N_{c}\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\bar{\sigma}^{(1)}}{\mathrm{d}\bar{\sigma}^{(0)}}\right) \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad+\alpha_{s}^{2}N_{c}^{2}\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\bar{\sigma}^{(2)}}{\mathrm{d}\bar{\sigma}^{(0)}}\right)+\dots\bigg] (1) where we have abbreviated the differential cross section as \mathrm{d}\sigma and factored out the leading power of the number of colours N_{c} in each term. At a given order N in fixed-order perturbation theory, the term of order N+1 in eq. 1 provides an estimate of the theoretical uncertainty associated with truncating the series. It is this term which we wish to model using nuisance parameters. To do this, we use information from available lower orders of the calculation. Specifically, we assume that the coefficients of \alpha_{s}N_{c} in the square brackets of equation 1 are simple functions of the kinematics such that they can be modelled by a polynomial with coefficients of order 1 multiplying a lower-order term. We find this empirically to be true for a range of processes and distributions. This motivates us to write the order N+1 estimate as \displaystyle\frac{\mathrm{d}\bar{\sigma}^{(N+1)}_{\mathrm{TNP}}}{\mathrm{d}\bar{\sigma}^{(0)}}=\sum_{j=1}^{N}f^{(j)}_{k}\Big(\vec{\theta},x\Big)\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\bar{\sigma}^{(j)}}{\mathrm{d}\bar{\sigma}^{(0)}}\right) (2) where f_{k} is a polynomial of degree k in a (suitably rescaled) kinematic variable x and the \theta_{i} are the TNPs. We have experimented with different choices of polynomial basis, and present results using Bernstein polynomials: \displaystyle f_{k}^{B}\Big(\vec{\theta},x\Big) \displaystyle=\sum^{k}_{i=0}\theta_{i}\bigg(\begin{array}[]{c}k\\ i\end{array}\bigg)x^{k-i}(1-x)^{i}\, defined in the range x\in[0,1] as well as for Chebyshev polynomials of the first kind, \displaystyle f_{k}^{C}\Big(\vec{\theta},x\Big) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2}\sum^{k}_{i=0}\theta_{i}T_{i}(x)\,, (5) defined in the range x\in[-1,1] . The choice of the integer k modulates the amount of