Non-perturbative exciton transfer rate analysis of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson photosynthetic complex under reduced and oxidised conditions
Hallmann Ó. Gestsson, Charlie Nation, Jacob S. Higgins, Gregory S. Engel, Alexandra Olaya-Castro · 2024
Read Non-perturbative exciton transfer rate analysis of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson photosynthetic complex under reduced and oxidised conditions by Hallmann Ó. Gestsson, Charlie Nation, Jacob S. Higgins, Gregory S. Engel, Alexandra Olaya-Castro (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-14883.txt.
Introduction
Hallmann Gestsson and four co-authors model energy transfer in a photosynthetic complex in a paper from two thousand twenty-four. The Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex moves excitation energy in green sulfur bacteria. Experiments show its transfer paths change sharply between reduced and oxidised states, hinting at a role for vibration-assisted transfer.
Earlier theory blamed shifts in site energies under oxidation, which detune energy gaps from a key vibration. The authors use a non-perturbative method that keeps memory effects, unlike the older approach. They find site energy shifts alone cannot match the observed rate changes. Adding local environment changes gives a closer, though not full, match. They suggest the complex's standard energy parameters need a fresh derivation.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hallmann Ó. Gestsson, Charlie Nation, Jacob S. Higgins, Gregory S. Engel, Alexandra Olaya-Castro |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 52 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-14883
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Non-perturbative exciton transfer rate analysis of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson photosynthetic complex under reduced and oxidised conditions Hallmann Ó. Gestsson, Charlie Nation, Jacob S. Higgins, Gregory S. Engel, Alexandra Olaya-Castro Abstract Two-dimensional optical spectroscopy experiments have shown that exciton transfer pathways in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) photosynthetic complex differ drastically under reduced and oxidised conditions, suggesting a functional role for collective vibronic mechanisms that may be active in the reduced form but attenuated in the oxidised state. Higgins et al. [PNAS 118 (11) e2018240118 (2021)] used Redfield theory to link the experimental observations to altered exciton transfer rates due to oxidative onsite energy shifts that detune excitonic energy gaps from a specific vibrational frequency of the bacteriochlorophyll a . Using a memory kernel formulation of the hierarchical equations of motion, we present non-perturbative estimations of transfer rates that yield a modified physical picture. Our findings indicate that onsite energy shifts alone cannot reproduce the observed rate changes in oxidative environments, either qualitatively or quantitatively. By systematically examining combined changes both in site energies and the local environment for the oxidised complex, while maintaining consistency with absorption spectra, our results suggest that vibronic tuning of transfer rates may indeed be active in the reduced complex. However, we achieve qualitative, but not quantitative, agreement with the experimentally measured rates. Our analysis indicates potential limitations of the FMO electronic Hamiltonian, which was originally derived by fitting spectra to second-order cumulant and Redfield theories. This suggests that reassessment of these electronic parameters with a non-perturbative scheme, or derived from first principles, is essential for a consistent and accurate understanding of exciton dynamics in FMO under varying redox conditions. I Introduction The Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) protein Olson and Romano 1962 ; Fenna and Matthews 1975 found in green sulfur bacteria Chlorobaculum tepidum Wahlund et al. 1991 is a homotrimer whose subunits each consist of eight interacting bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) a that collectively absorb light and facilitate excitation energy transfer (EET) in the form of delocalised excitons to the reaction centre van Amerongen et al. 2000 ; Hauska et al. 2001 ; Olson 2004 ; Schmidt am Busch et al. 2011 ; May and Kühn 2011 . It has become an exemplary system for the study of EET in photosynthetic complexes Adolphs and Renger 2006 ; Ishizaki and Fleming 2009a ; Ritschel et al. 2011 ; Dostál et al. 2016 ; Kell et al. 2016 ; Sokolov et al. 2024 ; Daré et al. 2024 , particularly since reports of long-lived quantum beats in two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy (2DES) both at low and physiological temperatures Engel et al. 2007 ; Hayes et al. 2010 ; Panitchayangkoon et al. 2010 ; Fidler et al. 2012 . These findings suggest that non-trivial quantum phenomena may play an important role in the biological function of the FMO complex, but there is no yet conclusive evidence or consensus regarding their significance Duan et al. 2017 . A central hypothesis for the observed beats in the FMO, and in similar studies for other complexes Richards et al. 2012 ; Christensson et al. 2012 ; Kolli et al. 2012 ; Chin et al. 2013 ; O’Reilly and Olaya-Castro 2014 ; Dean et al. 2016 ; Blau et al. 2018 ; Caycedo-Soler et al. 2018 ; Arsenault et al. 2020 , is the presence of vibronic mechanisms whereby a specific vibrational motion couples to excited state dynamics acting to sustain coherence and assist energy transfer. The recent discovery of redox-sensitive cysteines in FMO by Orf et al. Orf et al. 2016 has enabled a new approach to investigate this hypothesis and to further understand the possible importance of such a mechanism in biological function. To this end, 2DES experiments have investigated the energy transfer dynamics in FMO proteins under both reducing and oxidising conditions Allodi et al. 2018 ; Higgins et al. 2021a ; Higgins et al. 2021b . These studies have revealed some key significant features: quantum beats observed in the reduced FMO complex disappear under oxidised conditions Higgins et al. 2021b , and specific exciton transfer pathways are significantly attenuated in the latter Allodi et al. 2018 ; Higgins et al. 2021a . Based on this, Higgins et al. Higgins et al. 2021a posit the modulation of vibronic processes as key to the redox mechanism of FMO, acting to funnel excitations towards quenching sites in oxidising conditions and stemming the generation of reactive oxygen species that can damage the reaction centre. However, in the above experiments the hypothesis was rationalised within the Redfield theoretical framework Redfield 1957 ; Redfield 1965 ; Pollard and Friesner 1994 ; Ishizaki and Fleming 2009b which is known to have limited applicability Ishizaki and Fleming 2009b . An important question is whether the energy transfer rate analysis and hypothesis that have been put forward for the observed differences in reduced and oxidised FMO in the above works hold if we apply a more accurate framework, namely the hierarchical equations of motion (HEOM) Tanimura and Kubo 1989 ; Ishizaki and Tanimura 2005 ; Ishizaki and Fleming 2009c ; Shi et al. 2009 ; Tanaka and Tanimura 2009 ; Tanimura 2020 . This is not a simple question to address as the concept of transfer rate is not clear when the dynamics is non-Markovian and multi-exponential. Recent theory has addressed this issue by recasting the set of HEOM to a memory kernel form to define generalised transfer rates Jesenko and Žnidarič 2013 ; Jesenko and Žnidarič 2014 ; Zhang and Yan 2016 . In this work, we apply this framework to develop a systematic comparison of the experimental and predicted exciton kinetics according to both HEOM and Redfield, to assess whether the proposed modulation of vibronic processes holds when an appropriate non-perturbative treatment of the vibrational environment is considered. We observe a stark disagreement between the predicted HEOM and Redfield excitonic transfer rates for spectral densities that include an underdamped vibrational motion resonant to an excitonic transition in the FMO. This leads us to conclude that perturbative approaches to describe effective transfer rates in systems such as FMO are liable to lead to inconsistencies with experimentally determined rates via ultrafast spectroscopy; therefore efforts to rationalise experimental observations of exciton kinetics in such systems should rely on non-perturbative approaches such as HEOM Tanimura and Kubo 1989 ; Ishizaki and Tanimura 2005 ; Ishizaki and Fleming 2009c ; Shi et al. 2009 ; Tanaka and Tanimura 2009 ; Tanimura 2020 , tensor-network models Pollock et al. 2018 ; Strathearn et al. 2018 ; Fux et al. 2023 ; Cygorek et al. 2024 , and direct path-integral approaches Makri and Makarov 1995 ; Makri 2020 . Furthermore, we demonstrate that the model proposed by Higgins et al. Higgins et al. 2021a for the oxidised FMO does not reproduce experimental measurements of the absorption spectra Allodi et al. 2018 , prompting us to develop an investigation of generalised excitonic transfer rates over a parameter range consistent with linear spectra observations. The absorption spectrum is a key fingerprint of a photosynthetic complex, and any theoretical model must first and foremost be able to recover it. By restricting the variation of the electronic and vibrational parameters of the oxidised model to be faithful to its corresponding absorption spectrum we are