Harmonic spectrum of pulsar timing array angular correlations
Bruce Allen, Joseph D. Romano · 2024
Read Harmonic spectrum of pulsar timing array angular correlations by Bruce Allen, Joseph D. Romano (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-14852.txt.
Introduction
Bruce Allen and Joseph Romano work out how to read the fingerprint of gravitational waves in a 2024 paper. Pulsar timing arrays listen for these waves through tiny shifts in pulse arrival times from many pulsars. The average shift between two pulsars follows a predicted curve set by their angle on the sky, worked out by Hellings and Downs in 1983. Spotting that curve is the key proof that the waves are real.
The same curve can be rebuilt as a sum of smooth angle patterns called Legendre polynomials, each with its own weight. Allen and Romano derive the best ways to estimate those weights and their error sizes, assuming the waves and the noise behave like Gaussian random fields. One method tunes each weight alone. The other tunes the whole set to match the mean curve as closely as possible.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bruce Allen, Joseph D. Romano |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-14852
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Harmonic spectrum of pulsar timing array angular correlations Bruce Allen, Joseph D. Romano Abstract Pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) detect gravitational waves (GWs) via the correlations they create in the arrival times of pulses from different pulsars. The mean correlation, a function of the angle γ \gamma between the directions to two pulsars, was predicted in 1983 by Hellings and Downs (HD). Observation of this angular pattern is crucial evidence that GWs are present, so PTAs “reconstruct the HD curve” by estimating the correlation using pulsar pairs separated by similar angles. The angular pattern may be also expressed as a “harmonic sum” of Legendre polynomials P l ( cos γ ) {\rm P}_{l}(\cos\gamma) , with coefficients c l c_{l} . Here, assuming that the GWs and pulsar noise are described by a Gaussian ensemble, we derive optimal estimators for the c l c_{l} and compute their variance. We consider two choices for “optimal”. The first minimizes the variance of each c l c_{l} , independent of the values of the others. The second finds the set of c l c_{l} which minimizes the (squared) deviation of the reconstructed correlation curve from its mean. These are analogous to the so-called “dirty” and “clean” maps of the electromagnetic and (audio-band) GW backgrounds. Introduction.— This paper is about reconstruction of the Hellings and Downs (HD) correlation Hellings and Downs 1983 , starting from pulsar timing array (PTA) data Antoniadis et al. 2023 ; Agazie et al. 2023 ; Reardon et al. 2023 ; Xu et al. 2023 ; Miles et al. 2024 . Previous work Allen and Romano 2024 shows how to optimally estimate this correlation using data from a set of pulsar pairs lying in a particular angular separation bin Allen and Romano 2023 . This paper shows how to optimally reconstruct the correlation expressed in harmonic form, as a sum of Legendre polynomials, using all pulsar pairs. This paper must be read in conjunction with Allen and Romano 2024 , because we omit almost all equations which can be taken from there. Those are referred to using the notation (AR7) to indicate Eq. (7) of Allen and Romano 2024 . The goal is to reconstruct the HD correlation -1\leq\frac{3}{2}\mu\leq 1 as a function of the angle \gamma\in[0,\pi] between the directions to pulsars ( Allen and Romano 2024 , Introduction) . The correlation can be expressed as a sum of Legendre polynomials \mu(\gamma)=\sum_{l=0}^{\infty}c_{l}{\rm P}_{l}(\cos\gamma)\,. (1) Here, we derive optimal estimators for the c_{l} and compute their variance. The expected value of the correlation is called the HD curve \mu_{\rm u}(\gamma)\equiv\langle\mu(\gamma)\rangle and is illustrated in Fig. 1 . The corresponding expected values of the harmonic coefficients are computed in Gair et al. 2014 ; Roebber and Holder 2017 ; Allen 2024 and are \langle c_{l}\rangle=\begin{cases}0&\text{ for }l<2\\ (2l+1)/\bigl((l+2)(l+1)l(l-1)\bigr)&\text{ for }l\geq 2\,.\end{cases} (2) These different contributions are also shown in Fig. 1 ; partial sums may be seen in ( Romano and Allen 2024 , Fig. 11) . Because the \langle c_{l}\rangle fall off like 1/l^{3} for large l , summing the terms up to l=5 already gives a good approximation of the HD curve. (Note that the correlation is doubled to 3\mu_{\rm u}(0)=1 for pulsars that are closer together than the typical GW wavelength, see ( Allen 2023 , App. C.2) .) Figure 1: The HD curve \mu_{\rm u}(\gamma) (dashed line) and its first four harmonic components \langle c_{l}\rangle{\rm P}_{l}(\cos\gamma) (solid lines). Approach 1: Matched Filter – Our first approach is inspired by that of Allen and Romano 2024 . In (AR23) we considered estimators \hat{\mu}(\gamma) which are arbitrary linear combinations of the form \sum_{ab\in\gamma}\sum_{j,k}W_{ab}^{jk}Z_{a}^{j}Z_{b}^{k}\,, (3) where Z_{a}^{j} is the (complex) Fourier amplitude of the redshift of pulsar a in frequency bin j , defined in (AR12), and the W_{ab}^{jk} are a set of weights. There, the sum was over a set of pulsar pairs ab in a narrow angular bin at angle \gamma , and the weights satisfied W_{ab}^{jk*}=W_{ab}^{-j,-k} , to ensures that the estimator is real. The weights were selected so that the estimator is unbiased and minimum variance. (Note that all analysis there and here may also be done in terms of timing residuals; the results are identical, see ( Allen and Romano 2024 , Footnote 19) .) In analogy with this, we define an unbiased estimator for c_{l} . The estimator is analogous to (AR28), although we do not know how to derive it from first principles. For a PTA containing N_{\rm pul} pulsars, the estimator is \displaystyle\hat{c}_{l} \displaystyle\equiv \displaystyle\langle c_{l}\rangle\frac{({\boldsymbol{\mu}}_{l}\boldsymbol{\overline{H}})^{t}{\boldsymbol{C^{-1}}}\boldsymbol{ZZ}}{({\boldsymbol{\mu}}_{l}\boldsymbol{\overline{H}})^{t}{\boldsymbol{C^{-1}}}({\boldsymbol{\mu}}\boldsymbol{\overline{H}})} (4) \displaystyle\equiv \displaystyle\langle c_{l}\rangle\frac{\displaystyle\sum_{a<b}\sum_{c<d}\sum_{j,k}\sum_{\ell,m}\mu_{l,ab}{\overline{H}}_{jk}\bigl(C^{-1}\bigr)_{ab,cd}^{jk,\ell m}Z_{c}^{\ell}Z_{d}^{m}\,\,\,\,}{\displaystyle\sum_{a<b}\sum_{c<d}\sum_{j,k}\sum_{\ell,m}\mu_{l,ab}{\overline{H}}_{jk}\bigl(C^{-1}\bigr)_{ab,cd}^{jk,\ell m}\mu_{cd}{\overline{H}}_{\ell m}}\,, where \boldsymbol{ZZ}\equiv Z_{a}^{j}Z_{b}^{k} . Here, {\boldsymbol{\mu}}_{l}\equiv\mu_{{}_{l,ab}}\equiv(1+\delta_{ab}){\rm P}_{l}(\cos\gamma_{ab})\,. (5) and {\boldsymbol{\mu}}=\sum_{l}\langle c_{l}\rangle{\boldsymbol{\mu}}_{l} are vectors of dimension N_{\rm pair}=N_{\rm pul}(N_{\rm pul}-1)/2 . In contrast with ( 3 ), the sum is not confined to a particular angular bin, but includes all possible pulsar-pair cross-correlations a<b . This estimator takes the form \hat{c}_{l}=\langle c_{l}\rangle\frac{d_{l}}{u_{l}}\,, (6) where we have defined \displaystyle d_{l} \displaystyle\equiv({\boldsymbol{\mu}}_{l}\boldsymbol{\overline{H}})^{t}{\boldsymbol{C^{-1}}}\boldsymbol{ZZ}\,, (7) \displaystyle u_{l} \displaystyle\equiv({\boldsymbol{\mu}}_{l}\boldsymbol{\overline{H}})^{t}{\boldsymbol{C^{-1}}}({\boldsymbol{\mu}}\boldsymbol{\overline{H}})\,. (8) Expression ( 7 ) is an optimal matched filter for the angular correlation pattern {\boldsymbol{\mu}}_{l} . The corresponding “filter template” ( 5 ) is proportional to the l ’th term in ( 1 ); the \delta_{ab} can be dropped since a<b . This is an optimal matched filter because it is obtained by “whitening the template and the data” via the inverse covariance matrix {\boldsymbol{C^{-1}}} , and then normalizing. Our normalization, placing u_{l} in the denominator of ( 6 ), gives an unbiased estimator of c_{l} . To see this, note that \langle\boldsymbol{ZZ}\rangle={\boldsymbol{\mu}}\boldsymbol{\overline{H}} . It follows from inspection of ( 7 ) and ( 8 ) that \langle d_{l}\rangle=u_{l} , thus implying \langle\hat{c}_{l}\rangle=\langle c_{l}\rangle . The variance of the optimal matched filter estimator ( 4 ) is easy to calculate. The covariance of \boldsymbol{ZZ} is \boldsymbol{{\mathcal{C}}}\equiv\bigl\langle\boldsymbol{ZZ}(\boldsymbol{ZZ})^{\dagger}\bigr\rangle-\bigl\langle\boldsymbol{ZZ}\bigr\rangle\bigl\langle(\boldsymbol{ZZ})^{\dagger}\bigr\rangle\,. (9) An explicit formula for \boldsymbol{{\mathcal{C}}}\equiv{\mathcal{C}}_{ab,cd}^{jk,\ell m} is given in (AR19), in terms of covariance matrices computed from the gravitational wave background (GWB) and pulsar noise power spectra. The covariance matrix {\boldsymbol{C}} , whose inverse {\boldsymbol{C^{-1}}} appears in ( 4 ), is the symmetric part of \boldsymbol{{\mathcal{C}}} with respect to the frequency indices (AR20): {\boldsymbol{C}}\equiv C_{ab,cd}^{jk,\ell m}\equiv{\mathcal{C}}_{ab,cd}^{(jk),(\ell m)} (10) From the definition ( 7 ) of the d_{l} it follows that their covariance is \displaystyle\langle d_{l}d_{l^{\prime}}\rangle-\langle d_{l}\rangle\langle d_{l^{\prime}}\rangle \displaystyle\hskip 14.45377pt=({\boldsymbol{\mu}}_{l}\boldsymbol{\overline{H}})^{t}{\boldsymbol{C^{-1}}}\left(\langle({\boldsymbol{Z}}{\boldsymbol{Z}})({\boldsymbol{Z}}{\boldsymbol{Z}})^{\dagger}\rangle-\langle{\boldsymbol{Z}}{\boldsymbol{Z}}\rangle\langle({\boldsymbol{Z}}{\boldsymbol{Z}})^{\dagger}\rangle\right) \displaystyle\hskip 86.72377pt\times{\boldsymbol{C^{-1}}}({\boldsymbol{\mu}}_{l^{\prime}}\boldsymbol{\overline{H}}) \displaystyle\hskip 14.45377pt=({\boldsymbol{\mu}}_{l}\boldsymbol{\overline{H}})^{t}{\boldsymbol{C^{-1}}}{\boldsymbol{C}}{\boldsymbol{C^{-1}}}({\boldsymbol{\mu}}_{l^{\prime}}\boldsymbol{\overline{H}}) \displaystyle\hskip 14.45377pt=F_{ll^{\prime}}\,, (11) where ( 9 ) was used to get the second equality and we have defined a matrix {\boldsymbol{F}}\equiv F_{ll^{\prime}}\equiv({\boldsymbol{\mu}}_{l}\boldsymbol{\overline{H}})^{t}{\boldsymbol{C^{-1}}}({\boldsymbol{\mu}}_{l^{\prime}}\boldsymbol{\overline{H}})\,, (12) where l and l^{\prime} are indices labeling harmonics. Thus, the variance of the HD correlation estimator is \displaystyle\sigma^{2}_{\hat{c}_{l}} \displaystyle\equiv\langle\hat{c}^{2}_{l}\rangle-\langle\hat{c}_{l}\rangle^{2} (13) \displaystyle=\langle c_{l}\rangle^{2}\bigl(\langle d_{l}^{2}\rangle-\langle d_{l}\rangle^{2}\bigr)/u_{l}^{2} \displaystyle=\langle c_{l}\rangle^{2}F_{ll}/u_{l}^{2}\,, where F_{ll} are the diagonal elements of {\boldsymbol{F}} . We will write the variance ( 13 ) as \sigma^{2}_{\hat{c}_{l}}=\frac{\langle c_{l}\rangle^{2}}{(2L_{\rm eff}+1)N_{\rm freq}}=\frac{\langle c_{l}\rangle^{2}F_{ll}}{u_{l}^{2}}\,, (14) where N_{\rm freq} and 2L_{\rm eff}+1 are functions of l . (This, along with the formulas given below for N_{\rm freq} and 2L_{\rm eff}+1 , is one of the two main results of this paper.) The division into the two factors is arbitrary; we break this degeneracy by imposing two requirements: (i) The effective number of frequency bins N_{\rm freq} for which the GWB dominates pulsar noise equals N_{\rm cr} in the crossover frequency limit. (ii) The effective number of harmonic degrees of