Testing linearity of spatial interaction functions à la Ramsey
Abhimanyu Gupta, Jungyoon Lee, Francesca Rossi · 2024
Read Testing linearity of spatial interaction functions à la Ramsey by Abhimanyu Gupta, Jungyoon Lee, Francesca Rossi (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-14778.txt.
Introduction
Abhimanyu Gupta, Jungyoon Lee, and Francesca Rossi offer a test for spatial models in a 2024 paper. Spatial interaction functions often take a linear form, either by choice or from agent behavior. The authors build a simple test for whether that linear form fits. It follows the spirit of the Ramsey RESET test used in regression.
The test is nonparametric but rests on the Lagrange Multiplier idea, so only the null model needs fitting. That null is a linear spatial model that is easy to run. Simulations show good size control and power. Finnish data on tax rivalry between towns show the test in action.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abhimanyu Gupta, Jungyoon Lee, Francesca Rossi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 102 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-14778
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Testing linearity of spatial interaction functions à la Ramsey Thanks: This paper is dedicated to the memory of Francesca Rossi. We are grateful to a co-editor and three referees for comments that improved the paper considerably, and to seminar participants at Princeton, Aarhus, Cambridge, Queen Mary, RCEA, Warwick Econometrics Workshop, National University of Singapore, EcoSta, Midwest Econometrics Group 2024, Queen’s and Exeter, as well as Sílvia Gonçalves and Mikkel Sølvsten, for comments and feedback. Abhimanyu Gupta’s research was supported by the Leverhulme Trust via grant RPG-2024-038. Abhimanyu Gupta, Jungyoon Lee, Francesca Rossi Abstract We propose a computationally straightforward test for the linearity of a spatial interaction function. Such functions arise commonly, either as practitioner imposed specifications or due to optimizing behaviour by agents. Our conditional heteroskedasticity robust test is nonparametric, but based on the Lagrange Multiplier principle and reminiscent of the Ramsey RESET approach. This entails estimation only under the null hypothesis, which yields an easy to estimate linear spatial autoregressive model. Monte Carlo simulations show excellent size control and power. An empirical study with Finnish data illustrates the test’s practical usefulness, shedding light on debates on the presence of tax competition among neighbouring municipalities. Keywords: Spatial autoregression, Series expansion, Specification testing, Nonparametric. JEL Classification: C31, C14. 1 Introduction There has been a recent surge in the study of econometric models capturing social interactions between agents, see e.g. de Paula (2017) for a survey. By virtue of its close links to network and social interaction models, the spatial econometrics literature has also grown commensurately. A key component of this literature is the linear spatial autoregressive (SAR) model, introduced by Cliff and Ord (1968) ; Cliff and Ord (1973) . The ‘spatial’ moniker is unfortunate in some sense because it belies the generality of the SAR model. In fact the ‘space’ in question can be any economic dimension that connects individuals, e.g. social networks and conflict alliances. In this paper we propose and theoretically justify a convenient nonparametric test for the linearity of the SAR specification, which is by far the most prevalent in the literature. The assumption of linearity in the preponderance of studies involving SAR models is perhaps unsurprising given that even in straightforward multiple regression the linear model wins the popularity contest. Nevertheless, linearity is a strong assumption, criticized by Pinkse and Slade (2010) for instance, and discussed in detail in de Paula (2017) , Section 3.2. In the case of spatial autoregressions, nonlinearity in the spatial lag also induces immense technical difficulties due to the simultaneity inherent in the model. This has led to the seminal development of sophisticated machinery ( Jenish and Prucha, 2009 ; Jenish and Prucha, 2012 ) , but the flipside is that the conditions tend to be technically challenging and restricted to geographic data. The econometric implications of nonlinearity in spatial or network interactions are manifold. The focus of this paper is to test for potential nonlinearity in the so called ‘link’ function, which transmits a network connection-weighted average of peer outcomes to an individual’s own outcome. Tincani (2026) finds evidence of nonlinearities in education peer effects in Chile, the link function here operating on the distribution of peer outcomes. Other implications of nonlinearities can include multiple equilibria, or potentially none at all. We refer the reader to detailed discussions of various forms of nonlinearity and their implications in, for example, Blume et al. (2011) and de Paula (2017) . While of importance in its own econometric right, and possibly in a reduced form sense, testing for the linearity of a SAR specification can also address deeper economic considerations. Many network games yield equilibria with linear best responses and, when taken to the data, imply linear SAR specifications. Thus, a rejection of the linearity of the SAR specification can in fact be viewed as a rejection of the underlying structural economic model. Examples of such models include contest success functions (CSFs) in the Tullock (1980) style ( König et al., 2017 ) , quadratic utility network games ( Ballester et al., 2006 ; Calvó-Armengol et al., 2009 ) and public goods provision games in networks ( Bramoullé and Kranton, 2007 ) . These are discussed in more detail in the next section. Nonlinearity of best responses in network games can have profound economic implications. Acemoglu et al. (2016) emphasize that convexity or concavity of nonlinear network interactions can shape how the underlying network transmits shocks. Most strikingly, they show that with concave interactions, densely connected economies outperform sparser ones in the sense of expected macroeconomic outcomes. Indeed, an economy in which interlinkages are maximally dense outperforms all other (symmetric) economies. On the contrary, with convex interactions this pattern is completely reversed, with the maximally dense economy being the worst performing. The finding that concavity of interactions acts as a ‘shock absorber’ while convexity turns this into a ‘shockwave propogator’ aligns with the groundbreaking work of Allen and Gale (2000) on financial contagion. Thus, if a theoretical structural model begets a linear best response equilibrium, it behoves the economist to have some statistical confidence in the resulting empirical model. We employ a residual based test statistic reminiscent of the Lagrange Multiplier (LM) test to avoid nonparametric estimation altogether. The basic idea is to approximate the potentially nonlinear part of the model with a sieve expansion of length p . By choosing a basis of polynomial components, a test of linearity may be constructed by setting to zero all coefficients except the one corresponding to the linear term. This is an approach in the spirit of the famous Ramsey RESET test described in Ramsey (1969) . By employing the LM principle, we require parameter estimates only under the null hypothesis, which yields the familiar linear SAR model. Because p is a smoothing parameter, the number of coefficients on nonlinear terms must grow with sample size. Therefore our test will be for an increasing number of restrictions p\rightarrow\infty asymptotically, and the usual \chi^{2}_{p} asymptotic distribution cannot be relied upon. To address this, we will use a centred and scaled version of the statistic. In particular our test statistic will be of the form (\mathcal{T}_{p}-p)/\sqrt{2p} , where \mathcal{T}_{p} is computable by estimating the model under the null of linearity. We will show that this is asymptotically standard normal under the null, noting that a \chi^{2}_{p} random variable has mean p and variance 2p , in the spirit of de Jong and Bierens (1994) , Hong and White (1995) , Donald et al. (2003) and Gupta and Seo (2023) , to cite a few examples. We also establish the test’s consistency and ability to detect local alternatives at a suitably dampened nonparametric rate. There are several specification tests in the literature for linearity of the regression function in a linear SAR model, see for instance Su and Qu (2017) , Gupta and Qu (2024) and Chen et al. (2025) . On the other hand, the cupboard is rather bare as far as tests of linearity of the spatial lag are concerned. The most direct linearity test is provided by Hoshino (2022) and relies on the nonparametric function being estimated. This is a different approach from our Ramsey-style test, which stresses simplicity. The model considered is also somewhat