Demonstrating dynamic surface codes
Google Quantum AI and Collaborators · 2024
Read Demonstrating dynamic surface codes by Google Quantum AI and Collaborators (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-14360.txt.
Introduction
Google Quantum AI and a large group of collaborators report in 2024 on dynamic surface codes for quantum computers. Quantum bits are fragile, so surface codes spread one unit of information across many bits. That spread lets the machine spot and fix errors as it runs.
A dynamic code goes a step further, since its layout can shift during the run rather than stay fixed. The team built and ran such codes on their hardware to show the idea works in practice. Work of this kind matters because real quantum machines will need error control that adapts to the task at hand. The paper adds a proof point on the road to steady, large-scale quantum computing.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Google Quantum AI and Collaborators |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-14360
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Demonstrating dynamic surface codes Google Quantum AI and Collaborators Abstract A remarkable characteristic of quantum computing is the potential for reliable computation despite faulty qubits. This can be achieved through quantum error correction, which is typically implemented by repeatedly applying static syndrome checks, permitting correction of logical information Kitaev 1997 ; Fowler et al. 2012 ; Terhal 2015 . Recently, the development of time-dynamic approaches to error correction has uncovered new codes Hastings and Haah 2021 and new code implementations McEwen et al. 2023 ; Gidney and Jones 2023 ; Shaw and Terhal 2024 . In this work, we experimentally demonstrate three time-dynamic implementations of the surface code, each offering a unique solution to hardware design challenges and introducing flexibility in surface code realization. First, we embed the surface code on a hexagonal lattice, reducing the necessary couplings per qubit from four to three. Second, we walk a surface code, swapping the role of data and measure qubits each round, achieving error correction with built-in removal of accumulated non-computational errors. Finally, we realize the surface code using iSWAP gates instead of the traditional CNOT, extending the set of viable gates for error correction without additional overhead. We measure the error suppression factor when scaling from distance-3 to distance-5 codes of Λ 35 , hex = 2.15 ( 2 ) \Lambda_{35,\text{hex}}=2.15(2) , Λ 35 , walk = 1.69 ( 6 ) \Lambda_{35,\text{walk}}=1.69(6) , and Λ 35 , iSWAP = 1.56 ( 2 ) \Lambda_{35,\text{iSWAP}}=1.56(2) , achieving state-of-the-art error suppression for each. With detailed error budgeting, we explore their performance trade-offs and implications for hardware design. This work demonstrates that dynamic circuit approaches satisfy the demands for fault-tolerance and opens new alternative avenues for scalable hardware design Debroy et al. 2024 . Quantum Error Correction (QEC) enables accurate quantum computation in the presence of uncontrolled physical noise Shor 1995 . The surface code Kitaev 1997 ; Bravyi and Kitaev 1998 ; Dennis et al. 2002 is a preeminent example, capable of suppressing physical errors below a relatively high threshold and providing excellent capabilities for logical computation Fowler et al. 2012 ; Horsman et al. 2012 . These desirable characteristics have inspired extensive experimental work on the surface code Krinner et al. 2022 ; Google Quantum AI 2023 , including recently demonstrated below-threshold performance on a superconducting quantum processor Google Quantum AI 2024 and transversal logical gates in a neutral atom quantum processor Bluvstein et al. 2022 . To date, all of these experiments have been designed around a square grid of statically assigned qubits implementing CNOT/CZ entangling interactions to match the standard circuit implementation. This was assumed to comprise the minimum requirement to perform the code, since fault-tolerant circuits are traditionally constructed from static QEC codes. Figure 1: Dynamic implementation of quantum error correction. a : A distance-5 surface code on a square lattice. The colors indicates the stabilizer Pauli flavor (Red=X, Blue=Z). b : Propagation rules for the Z-type detecting region. c : A Z-type detection region evolving through the circuit for the standard implementation, highlighting where Pauli errors that anti-commute will be detected. d : Time slices of the detecting region between gates layers of ( c ). e : End-cycle (after measurement) time-slices for four surface code implementations: standard, along with hexagonal, walking, and iSWAP, which feature alternating end cycle states. Recent progress in the theory of time-dynamic QEC, including dynamic codes Hastings and Haah 2021 and space-time stabilizers Gottesman 2022 ; Delfosse and Paetznick 2023 , challenge the traditional static stabilizer approach and unlock new opportunities for the construction of fault-tolerant circuits. The new framework of the space-time detecting region generalizes these approaches, defined by local and connected regions of space-time that report the presence of errors. This framework permits the re-interpretation of QEC circuits as intermeshed detecting regions, featuring overlapping sensitivity such that all physical errors can be appropriately triangulated. It also highlights that maintaining the precise shape of such detecting regions is less crucial than ensuring all circuit locations are appropriately covered. Exploiting this freedom opens the door to an expansive equivalence class of circuits for implementing well-understood QEC codes McEwen et al. 2023 ; Bombin et al. 2023 ; Gidney and Jones 2023 ; Camps et al. 2024 ; Shaw and Terhal 2024 , providing distinct flexibility in their hardware implementation. In this work, we demonstrate the ability to switch out the circuit implementation of the surface code, achieving error suppression from distance-3 to distance-5 with three time-dynamic circuits that feature qualitatively different demands on the underlying hardware. These circuits are examples representing particularly large departures from previous assumptions about the hardware and gateset necessary to implement the surface code. First, we embed the surface code onto a hexagonal grid, reducing the necessary qubit connectivity from four neighbours to three. Second, we perform a walking circuit in which the qubits are dynamically reassigned between data and measure, frustrating the spread of time-correlated errors. Finally, we perform the surface code using iSWAP gates rather than CNOT/CZ gates, demonstrating that QEC can be performed using entangling interactions previously reserved for NISQ experiments. We operate all three implementations on Willow processors Google Quantum AI 2024 , optimised for the standard surface code circuit, permitting direct comparisons of performance but leaving open the possibility of optimising future hardware around alternative circuits. The newfound freedom in circuit implementation can be understood naturally using detecting regions, which indicate all locations in a QEC circuit where a non-commuting error would be detected by measurements the region touches. Fig. 1 a shows a standard distance-5 surface code patch, where we highlight a single detecting region in Fig. 1 c . This Z-type detecting region is sensitive to any X or Y error occurring in highlighted locations in the circuit. The region propagates through the circuit in the same way that Pauli terms propagate through Clifford operations, illustrated in Fig. 1 b . The detecting region persists over two consecutive cycles, first expanding from a single qubit to cover the static code stabilizer immediately after the first measurement gate, which we call the end-cycle state , then contracting to end in a second measurement. Time-slices of the detecting region are shown in Fig. 1 d ; using a tiling of spacetime through overlapping detecting regions, we ensure that all circuit locations are checked for errors. Given this general framework, circuit flexibility arises by modifying the gate layers and associated detecting regions while preserving the tiling of spacetime. The end-cycle states for the three alternative constructions measured in this work are illustrated in Fig. 1 e . Each alternative construction features unique alternating end-cycle states, as opposed to the standard code which has a static end-cycle state. Such periodic deformation of the detecting region tiling allows the alternative circuit constructions. In this manuscript, we measure the QEC performance of these three time-dynamic circuits in isolation using a logical memory experiment, proving their ability to reduce the logical error rate as the surface code distance is increased from 3 to 5, while discussing their unique hardware requirements. Hexagonal lattice Surface Code Figure 2: Hexagonal lattice surface code. a : Z-type detection region time-slices. Each panel shows a gate layer and detecting region after.