Multiple reflections on Huygens’ principle
Kees Wapenaar Department of Geoscience and Engineering, Delft University of Technology, The Netherlands · 2024
Read Multiple reflections on Huygens’ principle by Kees Wapenaar Department of Geoscience and Engineering, Delft University of Technology, The Netherlands (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-13833.txt.
Introduction
Kees Wapenaar, a solo author, presents a 2024 paper on Huygens' principle in wave physics. The classic principle treats each point on a wave front as a fresh source. The envelope of their spherical waves forms the next front. Modern math writes those waves as Green's functions. Many imaging methods swap in time-reversed versions of those functions. That swap powers backpropagation, seismic imaging, and inversion.
When the wave field is known only on one open border, the swap mishandles multiply reflected waves. A modified principle fixes this by using focusing functions instead. Imaging, inverse scattering, and source monitoring all gain a sounder base. Geophysicists are the prime readers, since seismic data are one-sided by nature. Multiple reflections carry real signal about deep layers. A principle that counts them correctly can sharpen images of the Earth.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kees Wapenaar Department of Geoscience and Engineering, Delft University of Technology, The Netherlands |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 91 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-13833
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Multiple reflections on Huygens’ principle Kees Wapenaar Department of Geoscience and Engineering, Delft University of Technology, The Netherlands Abstract According to Huygens’ principle, all points on a wave front act as secondary sources emitting spherical waves, and the envelope of these spherical waves forms a new wave front. In the mathematical formulation of Huygens’ principle, the waves emitted by the secondary sources are represented by Green’s functions. In many present-day applications of Huygens’ principle, these Green’s functions are replaced by their time-reversed versions, thus forming a basis for backpropagation, imaging, inversion, seismic interferometry, etc. However, when the input wave field is available only on a single open boundary, this approach has its limitations. In particular, it does not properly account for multiply reflected waves. This is remedied by a modified form of Huygens’ principle, in which the Green’s functions are replaced by focusing functions. The modified Huygens’ principle forms a basis for imaging, inverse scattering, monitoring of induced sources, etc., thereby properly taking multiply reflected waves into account. Introduction Dutch mathematician, physicist and astronomer Christiaan Huygens (1629 – 1695) described light as a longitudinal mechanical wave, propagating through an ether medium. Even though, centuries later, Maxwell proposed light as a transverse electromagnetic wave and Einstein showed it doesn’t need an ether to support its propagation, the early wave theoretical approach of Huygens appeared very effective in the analysis of the propagation and reflection of light. In his book “Traité de la Lumière” (Treatise on Light, published in 1690), he explains that around each undulating particle of the matter through which a wave propagates, a spherical wave is formed of which this particle is the center. The common tangent (or envelope) of these spherical waves forms a new wave front. This is in a nutshell Huygens’ principle, and it applies to light as well as to other wave phenomena. For an extensive discussion of the work of Huygens and his important role in bridging ancient and modern science, see Moser & Robinson (2024) . In the early nineteenth century, French physicist Augustin-Jean Fresnel (1788 – 1827) added the theory of interference to Huygens’ principle. With this extension, the new wave front along the envelope of aforementioned spherical waves can be explained as the result of constructive interference of these spherical waves. In the following, when we speak “Huygens’ principle”, we mean the original theory of Huygens, extended with the theory of interference. Figure 1 is an illustration of Huygens’ principle, applied to acoustic waves. A point source, indicated by the red star, emits a circular wave which propagates through a medium with a constant propagation velocity (the example is 2D, hence, instead of spherical waves we have circular waves). At a certain time this wave reaches a screen with a small opening (Figure 1 a). The wave field in this opening acts as a secondary source, which emits a circular wave into the half-space above the screen. Figure 1 b shows a similar setup, but this time the screen has many small openings, which all act as secondary sources, emitting circular waves at the time the original wave reaches these openings. Hence, the field above the screen consists of a superposition of circular waves. The envelope of these superposed waves approximately forms a circular wave, resembling the wave that would be radiated by the original point source into the upper half-space in absence of the screen. In Figure 1 c the screen contains one large opening. All points in this opening act as secondary sources (indicated by the dense distribution of blue stars) and the superposition of the circular waves above the screen has indeed converged to the circular wave radiated by the original source. Figure 1: Illustration of Huygens’ principle for acoustic waves in a homogeneous medium. (a) A source at {\bf x}_{S} emits a circular wave. The wave field in the opening of the screen at {\bf x}_{0} acts as a secondary source, emitting a secondary circular wave into the upper half-space. (b) Many openings in the screen, acting as secondary sources. The envelope of the superposition of the secondary circular waves in the upper half-space approaches the circular wave, originating from the source at {\bf x}_{S} . (c) All points in one large opening in the screen act as secondary sources (indicated by the blue stars). The superposition of the secondary circular waves in the upper half-space has converged to the circular wave, originating from the source at {\bf x}_{S} . Animations of this and other figures can be found in the Supporting Information. Huygens’ principle has found many applications in optics, acoustics and other fields in which wave propagation and scattering plays a role. In this paper we restrict ourselves to applications in acoustics and geophysics, in particular for wave field extrapolation. Traditionally, the waves emitted by the secondary sources in Huygens’ principle are represented by Green’s functions. In the section “Traditional Huygens’ principle, using Green’s functions”, we review applications of Huygens’ principle in forward and inverse wave field extrapolation through homogeneous and inhomogeneous media. It appears that with the traditional Huygens’ principle, internal multiply reflected waves are not correctly handled in inverse extrapolation through an inhomogeneous medium. In the section “Modified Huygens’ principle, using focusing functions”, we first introduce focusing functions for homogeneous and inhomogeneous media. Next, we discuss a modified version of Huygens’ principle, in which the Green’s functions are replaced by these focusing functions. We discuss applications of this modified Huygens’ principle in forward and inverse wave field extrapolation through an inhomogeneous medium and in the retrieval of the homogeneous Green’s function of an inhomogeneous medium. We show that internal multiply reflected waves are correctly handled in these applications. The style of the main text is informal, with an emphasis on explanations of the different forms of Huygens’ principle, using simple mathematics. More detailed derivations can be found in the appendices. Traditional Huygens’ principle, using Green’s functions Forward wave field extrapolation through a homogeneous medium We discuss some mathematics behind Huygens’ principle, as illustrated in Figure 1 , and use this as a starting point for the discussion of forward wave field extrapolation. We define a Cartesian coordinate system, with the z -axis pointing downward and coordinate vector {\bf x} denoting position in this system. For the 3D situation this vector is defined as {\bf x}=(x,y,z) . Whereas most of the theory in this paper holds for 3D, the examples are 2D, in which case the coordinate vector is defined as {\bf x}=(x,z) . Time is denoted by t . Let {\bf x}_{S} denote the position of a monopole source (in Figure 1 it is defined as {\bf x}_{S}=(0,1200) m). We define the acoustic Green’s function G({\bf x},{\bf x}_{S},t) (named after George Green, 1793 – 1841) as the response to an impulsive monopole source at {\bf x}_{S} and t=0 , observed at {\bf x} as a function of t . The Green’s function is a causal function of time, meaning G({\bf x},{\bf x}_{S},t)=0 for t<0 . The source of the Green’s function is a volume-injection rate source, see Appendix A–1 for further details. When the source in an actual situation is not an impulse but a transient wavelet s(t) , then the observed acoustic