Selective excitation of collective modes in multiband superconductor MgB 2

Jiayu Yuan, Liyu Shi, Tiequan Xu, Yue Wang, Zizhao Gan, Hao Wang, Tianyi Wu, Dong Wu, Tao Dong, Nanlin Wang · 2024

Read Selective excitation of collective modes in multiband superconductor MgB 2 by Jiayu Yuan, Liyu Shi, Tiequan Xu, Yue Wang, Zizhao Gan, Hao Wang, Tianyi Wu, Dong Wu, Tao Dong, Nanlin Wang (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-13830.txt.

Introduction

Jiayu Yuan and co-authors probe, in a 2024 physics paper, the shared vibrations that arise inside a two-band superconductor called MgB2. Which of these modes shows up in tests, and under what push, has been debated for years.

The team used terahertz light pulses in two styles, steady multi-cycle bursts and single sharp cycles. The burst tests lit up signals tied mainly to the Higgs mode of one band, growing stronger at matching temperatures. The sharp pulse instead brought out a damped wave tied to the Leggett mode, which links the two bands. Showing that pulse shape selects the mode helps settle the debate and guides future tests.

Catalog record

CREATORJiayu Yuan, Liyu Shi, Tiequan Xu, Yue Wang, Zizhao Gan, Hao Wang, Tianyi Wu, Dong Wu, Tao Dong, Nanlin Wang
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-13830

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Selective excitation of collective modes in multiband superconductor MgB 2 Jiayu Yuan, Liyu Shi, Tiequan Xu, Yue Wang, Zizhao Gan, Hao Wang, Tianyi Wu, Dong Wu, Tao Dong, Nanlin Wang Abstract Recent developments in nonequilibrium and nonlinear terahertz (THz) spectroscopies have significantly advanced our understanding of collective excitations in superconductors. However, there is still debate surrounding the identification of Higgs or Leggett modes, as well as BCS charge fluctuations, in the well-known two-band superconductor MgB 2 . Here, we utilized both multi-cycle and single-cycle THz pump-broadband THz probe techniques to investigate the THz nonlinear response of MgB 2 . Through multicycle THz pump-THz probe experiments on MgB 2 , we observed distinct nonlinear signals at both the fundamental frequency ( ω \omega ) and the second harmonic frequency (2 ω \omega ) of the pump pulses, which exhibited resonant enhancement at temperatures where their frequencies respectively match 2 Δ π ​ ( T ) \Delta_{\pi}(T) . They are mainly attributed to the π \pi -band Higgs mode. By adjusting the THz pump pulse to a single-cycle waveform that satisfies non-adiabatic excitation criteria, we observed an over-damped oscillation corresponding to the Leggett mode. Our findings contribute to solving the ongoing debates and demonstrate the selective excitation of collective modes in multiband superconductors, offering new insights into the interaction between Higgs and Leggett modes. Introduction Investigating collective modes in superconductors is a critical area of research in condensed matter physics because these modes provide deep insights into the underlying properties of superconducting states and their interactions. In a single band superconductor, the spontaneous breaking of continuous U(1) symmetry leads to the emergence of two important collective modes: a massless phase (or Nambu-Goldstone) mode and a massive ’Higgs’ amplitude mode [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] . Due to the Anderson-Higgs mechanism, the phase mode is absorbed into the longitudinal component of the electromagnetic field, raising its energy to the plasma frequency. The Higgs mode, representing amplitude fluctuation of the complex order parameter, has the excitation energy at the superconducting gap (2 \Delta ) in the long-wavelength limit [ 3 ] . Detecting Higgs modes directly proves to be challenging due to their charge neutrality and spin inactivity, which requires nonlinear coupling to electromagnetic field without disturbing superconducting condensate. It is only in cases where superconductivity is accompanied by a charge density wave (CDW) order, like in 2H-NbSe 2 , that the Higgs mode can be detected using Raman spectroscopy [ 5 , 6 , 3 , 7 , 4 ] . Recent advancements of intense ultrashort terahertz (THz) pulses have allowed observation of Higgs modes through two experimental protocols: free oscillations at 2\Delta after nonadiabatic excitation ( \tau_{p}\Delta<1 ) and third harmonic generation (THG) via periodic driving ( \tau_{p}\Delta\gg 1 ) through a two-photon process, where \tau_{p} is the pulse duration [ 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] . Despite progress in understanding nonlinear response of superconductivity, distinguishing Higgs modes from single-particle excitations (BCS charge fluctuations) remains challenging, as they share the same energy at long wavelengths and are influenced by sample disorder and band structure [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] . Multiband superconductors host more collective modes compared to single-band superconductors. In two-band superconductors, each band has a Higgs mode related to amplitude fluctuation. In the phase sector, besides the overall phase fluctuation which is pushed up to the plasma energy, a relative phase fluctuation between the two bands emerges, which is called Leggett mode [ 20 ] . The energy scale of the Leggett mode depends on the two superconducting gaps and the interband and intraband coupling strengths. The interplay between this mode and the Higgs mode complicates the identification of non-equilibrium response sources in multi-band systems [ 21 ] . MgB 2 is a prototypical two-band s-wave superconductor with \mathrm{T_{c}} = 30-40 K, which features two types of electronic bands crossing the Fermi level E F : the three-dimensional \pi electron band and the quasi-two-dimensional \sigma hole band. A number of spectroscopic measurements have shown two distinct isotropic superconductivity gaps within the \pi and \sigma bands, \Delta_{\pi} = 0.4-0.7 THz and \Delta_{\sigma} = 1.3-1.9 THz, respectively [ 22 , 23 , 24 ] . The two gap characteristics thus establish MgB 2 as a platform to study the Higgs and Leggett modes. The Leggett mode is successfully identified in MgB 2 by Raman spectroscopy [ 24 ] . Recently, single-cycle THz pump-probe investigation with a center frequency of 1.4 THz in MgB 2 shows that the Leggett mode dominates the nonlinear response through the two-photon sum frequency process \chi^{(3)}(\omega_{p},\omega_{p},\omega_{probe}) [ 25 ] . This conclusion is further supported by wavelength-dependent narrowband THz driving–broadband THz probe measurement, in which no nonlinear response is observed at 0.57 THz driving (near \Delta_{\pi} = 0.44 THz), and a nonlinear signal becomes detectable only when the driving pulse nearly fulfills the resonant condition of 2\omega_{p}=\omega_{L}\approx 2.5 THz [ 25 ] . However, a subsequent multi-cycle THz-driven THG experiment suggested that the contribution of the \pi -band Higgs mode, rather than the Leggett mode, predominated the nonlinear response, as evidenced by systematic 2\omega_{p}=2\Delta(T) resonances with different driving frequencies [ 26 ] . Following the experimental investigations, a theoretical study supported the findings in the latter work that THz THG response in MgB 2 would show a resonance only for the lower gap [ 27 ] . Yet, another theoretical investigation indicated that the Leggett mode would dominate the nonlinear response when the pumping frequencies match one-half of its eigenfrequency, whereas the narrowband THz THG response was contributed by BCS charge fluctuations of the \pi -band gap rather than its Higgs mode [ 28 ] . The controversy then results in the following questions: First, how can we distinguish \pi -band Higgs mode from BCS charge fluctuations [ 25 , 26 , 29 ] ? Second, can we find the THz waveform that best selectively excites a given collective mode (Higgs mode of \pi/\sigma band and Leggett mode) by tuning its spectrum and pulse duration? Developing an experimental protocol to identify the collective modes in such a conventional multi-band superconductor is also a crucial initial step in utilizing the technique for unconventional multi-band superconductors, such as iron-pnictide and nickel-based superconductors. To address the above questions, in this work, we systematically investigate the nonlinear response of superconductivity collective modes in 10 nm MgB 2 thin films ( \mathrm{T_{c}} =33 K, as shown in the Supplementary Information Fig. S1) with comprehensive multi-cycle and single-cycle THz pump-broadband THz probe techniques. We initially use a multi-cycle THz pump to excite the MgB 2 sample. We observe that the \pi -band Higgs mode predominates the nonlinear response, as evidenced by both 2\omega_{p}=2\Delta_{\pi} (T= 24 K) resonance in \chi^{(3)}(\omega_{p},\omega_{p},\omega_{probe}) and \omega_{p}=2\Delta_{\pi} (T=26 K) resonance in the \chi^{(3)}(\omega_{p},\omega_{probe},-\omega_{probe}) nonlinear channels after taking account of the screening effect. While the origin of the former resonance is still debated [ 16 , 30 , 27 , 28 ] , the latter resonance is primarily attributed to the Higgs mode of the superconductivity order parameter, rather than BCS fluctuations, as suggested by recent studies [ 31 , 32 ]

Read the complete text