Black Hole Shadow and other Observables away from the Horizon: Extending the Effective Metric Descriptions

Manuel Del Piano, Stefan Hohenegger, Francesco Sannino · 2024

Read Black Hole Shadow and other Observables away from the Horizon: Extending the Effective Metric Descriptions by Manuel Del Piano, Stefan Hohenegger, Francesco Sannino (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-13673.txt.

Introduction

Manuel Del Piano, Stefan Hohenegger, and Francesco Sannino present a 2024 physics paper on black holes changed by quantum effects. In earlier work they built a model-free way to describe such black holes near the horizon, the point of no return. That method used series expansions that work well nearby but lose accuracy farther out.

Here they extend the reach of the method with a math tool called a Padé approximant, which stretches a series into a ratio that stays accurate over a wider range. With it, they can write clear formulas for things that can be observed, such as the dark shadow a black hole casts. In the limit, they get a closed formula for the shadow of the fully changed black hole. Tests on known models matched well in all cases.

Catalog record

CREATORManuel Del Piano, Stefan Hohenegger, Francesco Sannino
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE80 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-13673

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Black Hole Shadow and other Observables away from the Horizon: Extending the Effective Metric Descriptions Manuel Del Piano, Stefan Hohenegger, Francesco Sannino Abstract In previous work DelPiano:2023fiw ; DelPiano:2024gvw we have developed a model-independent, effective description of quantum deformed, spherically symmetric and static black holes in four dimensions. The deformations of the metric are captured by two functions of the physical distance to the horizon, which are provided in the form of self-consistent Taylor series expansions. While this approach efficiently captures physical observables in the immediate vicinity of the horizon, it is expected to encounter problems of convergence at further distances. Therefore, we demonstrate in this paper how to use Padé approximants to extend the range of applicability of this framework. We provide explicit approximations of physical observables that depend on finitely many effective parameters of the deformed black hole geometry, depending on the order of the Padé approximant. By taking the asymptotic limit of this order, we in particular provide a closed-form expression for the black hole shadow of the (fully) deformed geometry, which captures the leading quantum corrections. We illustrate our results for a number of quantum black holes previously proposed in the literature and find that our effective approach provides excellent approximations in all cases. Introduction Since the initial discovery of the celebrated Schwarzschild solution in General Relativity (GR) Schwarzschild:1916uq ; Wald:1984rg ; Maggiore:2018sht ; Chandrasekhar:1985kt ; Carroll:2004st ; misner1973gravitation , black holes have been a central object of theoretical study for almost a century. In particular in the context of (quantum) modified theories of gravity (that go beyond the classical theory), numerous space-time geometries that resemble black holes have been proposed theoretically and their properties studied in detail. With the advent of large scale astrophysical experiments (such as for example the Event Horizon Telescope EventHorizonTelescope:2019dse ; EventHorizonTelescope:2021dqv ; EventHorizonTelescope:2022wkp ; EventHorizonTelescope:2022xqj ; Vagnozzi:2022moj or the detection of gravitational waves stemming from black hole binaries and mergers LIGOScientific:2020tif ; LIGOScientific:2020stg ; LIGOScientific:2018dkp ; LIGOScientific:2016dsl ; LIGOScientific:2016aoc ), black holes have also moved to the forefront of observational studies. This has sparked the hope that (with an expected increase in the precision of the experimental measurements), black holes could reveal traces of physics beyond GR that might provide clues towards a theory of Quantum Gravity. As there is currently no universally accepted such theory, the correct description of black holes beyond GR is not at all obvious. In this work, we shall work under the assumption, that they still allow a geometric description in the form of a metric , at least in the region outside of the event horizon, which is accessible to direct observations. Since furthermore quantum 1 1 1 In the following we shall call modifications of black holes in vacuum that go beyond classical General Relativity ’quantum’ corrections. While we indeed have mostly in mind effects that are due to a quantum theory of gravity, our approach does not hinge on the quantum nature of these effects and our results are equally applicable to any other modified theory of gravity. effects are expected to be very small, quantum black holes are usually formulated as deformations of (established) classical solutions: indeed, numerous examples of such deformed geometries have been proposed in the literature, either within the framework of a concrete proposal of a theory of quantum gravity or motivated by symmetries and/or other properties. This plethora of isolated models makes a direct comparison to experimental results as well as a theoretical understanding of universal properties of quantum black holes difficult. Indeed, findings of either type are specific to a concrete (class of) model(s) and difficult to generalise to a larger context: e.g. in Cadoni:2022vsn , bounds have been formulated on the size of the deformation parameter of a specific black hole, based on astrophysical observations. However, these bounds are a priori only meaningful within the concrete model that was used to describe the deformation of the geometry beyond the Schwarzschild metric. For this reason we have developed in previous works Binetti:2022xdi ; DelPiano:2023fiw ; DelPiano:2024gvw an effective metric description (EMD) of black hole geometries that is capable of accommodating the various isolated models, while at the same time capturing universal features of black hole physics. Focusing on spherically symmetric and static black holes, the main feature of these EMD’s is to formulate the deformations with respect to the Schwarzschild geometry as functions of a physical quantity. While the choice of the latter does not impact physical observables (in the sense that EMD’s based on different choices are equivalent DelPiano:2024gvw ), previous works DelPiano:2023fiw have been based on the proper distance \rho to the event horizon of the black hole: we have developed a framework that allows to compute this proper distance in a self-consistent fashion from the metric (which itself depends on \rho ) in the form of a Taylor series around \rho=0 . This in turn allows to compute observables, such as the Hawking temperature, that only depend on the geometry at the event horizon of the black hole, as functions of finitely many 2 2 2 Three in the case of the Hawking temperature. , universally definable parameters. The latter appear as effective parameters in the Taylor series expansion of the metric deformations in terms of the physical quantity \rho . We also mention that using an asymptotic version of the EMDs Binetti:2022xdi ; DAlise:2023hls , in Li:2023djs the precession of bound orbits around the black hole have been studied, while in Belfiglio:2024qsa a version of entanglement entropy was discussed. The large scale astrophysical experiments mentioned above are in general poised to measure other observables that depend on the black hole geometry at a larger, but not asymptotic, distance to the event horizon. For example, the Event Horizon Telescope is able to measure the black hole shadow EventHorizonTelescope:2019dse ; EventHorizonTelescope:2021dqv ; EventHorizonTelescope:2022wkp ; EventHorizonTelescope:2022xqj , which is related to the last stable photon orbit of the black hole Perlick:2021aok ; Carroll:2004st ; misner1973gravitation ; Bozza:2002zj . While, relatively speaking, still close to the horizon 3 3 3 In the classical Schwarzschild geometry, the stable photon orbit is located at r_{\text{ps}}=\frac{3}{2}\,r_{H} , where r_{H} is the position of the event horizon. , the shadow probes the geometry in a region, where the distance EMD may develop technical problems due to the lack of convergence of the Taylor series expansion inherent in the metric deformations. In this paper, we therefore explore ways to extend the validity of the (distance) EMD to regions that are further away from the event horizon, with the concrete goal to provide (an approximate) expression for the black hole shadow. The core idea is to replace the metric deformations, which in the framework developed in Binetti:2022xdi ; DelPiano:2023fiw ; DelPiano:2024gvw are only given in the form of Taylor series expansions in close proximity of the horizon, by a function that is well defined in a region outside of the black hole. In particular, this region may extend outside of the radius of convergence of the initial Taylor series expansion, thus effectively extending the EMD beyond its original validity, albeit only approximately. These extended EMD’s in turn allow us to compute (approximations) of observables that probe a region further away from the

Read the complete text