A parameter-free statistical model for two-dimensional carbon nanostructures

Chang-Chun He, Shao-Gang Xu, Jiarui Zeng, Weijie Huang, Yao Yao, Yu-Jun Zhao, Hu Xu, Xiao-Bao Yang · 2024

Read A parameter-free statistical model for two-dimensional carbon nanostructures by Chang-Chun He, Shao-Gang Xu, Jiarui Zeng, Weijie Huang, Yao Yao, Yu-Jun Zhao, Hu Xu, Xiao-Bao Yang (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-13588.txt.

Introduction

Chang-Chun He and co-authors introduce a parameter-free statistical model for two-dimensional carbon structures, in a 2024 paper. Energy degeneracy, where states share one energy, can arise from symmetry. In carbon structures, resonance of such states can boost stability. Their model uses the octet rule to lift that degeneracy.

By minimizing bonding free energy, the model finds electron density and other core traits without outside parameters. Applied to carbon clusters and graphynes, it predicts bonding energies and electron density precisely. The authors contrast their route with standard quantum mechanics and with density-based theory. The model offers a direct path to material properties.

Catalog record

CREATORChang-Chun He, Shao-Gang Xu, Jiarui Zeng, Weijie Huang, Yao Yao, Yu-Jun Zhao, Hu Xu, Xiao-Bao Yang
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-13588

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A parameter-free statistical model for two-dimensional carbon nanostructures Chang-Chun He, Shao-Gang Xu, Jiarui Zeng, Weijie Huang, Yao Yao, Yu-Jun Zhao, Hu Xu, Xiao-Bao Yang Abstract Energy degeneracy in physical systems may be induced by symmetries of the Hamiltonian, and the resonance of degeneracy states in carbon nanostructures can effectively enhance the stability of the system. Combining the octet rule, we introduce a parameter-free statistical model to determine the physical properties by lifting the energy degeneracy in carbon nanostructures. This model offers a direct path to accurately ascertain electron density distributions in quantum systems, akin to how charge density is used in density functional theory to deduce system properties. Our methodology diverges from traditional quantum mechanics, focusing instead on this unique statistical model by minimizing bonding free energy to determine the fundamental properties of materials. Applied to carbon nanoclusters and graphynes, our model not only precisely predicts bonding energies and electron density without relying on external parameters, but also enhances the prediction of electronic structures through bond occupancy numbers, which act as effective hopping integrals. This innovation offers insights into the structural properties and quantum behavior of electrons across various dimensions. Preprint: APS/123-QED I Introduction Energy degeneracy resulting from latent symmetry is a crucial aspect of quantum systems, contributing to various quantum phenomena [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . The latent symmetry is attributed to the symmetry of the isospectral effective Hamiltonian obtained through subsystem partitioning, and the rotational symmetries can be broken in a controlled manner while maintaining the more fundamental symmetry [ 4 ] . Lifting the degeneracy by external perturbations can lead to a lower energy state with energy level splitting. For instance, the Jahn-Teller effect describes how local geometric distortions can lower the overall energy of a system by removing degeneracy [ 5 ] . In carbon nanostructures, quantum resonance provides another mechanism for lifting energy degeneracy by the combination of possible degenerate Kekul \acute{\textrm{e}} structures, emerging delocalized electron states and aromaticity to further stabilize the system [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] For the benzene molecule, there are two Kekul \acute{\textrm{e}} structures with C 3 symmetry that both meet the octet rule, exhbiting the two-fold energy degeneracy. Resonance theory shows that the uniform superposition of Kekul \acute{\textrm{e}} structures with C 6 symmetry corresponds to the true electron density of benzene [ 9 ] , lifting the energy degeneracy with additional resonance energy. Generally, a polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) molecule has a series of Kekul \acute{\textrm{e}} structures that satisfy the octet rule in degenerate energy state. To construct the most valuable one to represent all Kekul \acute{\textrm{e}} structures, Clar’s rule identifies the key structure by maximizing the number of nonadjacent \pi -sextets [ 10 ] . The nonadjacent \pi -sextets have two forms with alternating single and double bonds, independently contributing a statistical weight of 2, and the statistical weight is 2^{N} for N \pi -sextets. Therefore, Clar’s rule provides an avenue to lift energy degeneracy by favoring the structure with the largest statistical weight, which best approximates the relative stability of various carbon nanostructures [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] . The sextets predicted by Clar’s rule generally correspond to aromatic rings, aligning with various theoretical methods [ 15 , 16 ] , though exceptions exist in irregular-shaped PAHs [ 17 ] . Additionally, PAH isomers with more sextets tend to exhibit higher kinetic stability, lower reactivity, and larger energy gaps [ 18 ] . Despite the success in interpreting chemical bonding, the empirical rules limit quantitative electron distribution analysis for lack of rigorous mathematical foundation in quantum theory [ 19 , 20 , 21 ] . A single Clar structure often cannot accurately reproduce the actual electron density distribution of a PAH molecule, as the symmetry of the Clar structure often disagrees with the realistic molecular symmetry [ 22 ] . The Clar’s rule, as a parameter-free model, falls short in accurately predicting the electron density along with structural stabilities and electronic properties of carbon nanostructures. Current quantitative models require training data from DFT to acquire model parameters and precisely predict the properties of unknown structures, which belong to a first-principles-based (second-principles) scheme [ 23 ] . To address electronic properties, the tight-binding (TB) model offers a simpler method to construct an effective Hamiltonian [ 24 ] , but it relies on DFT or experimental data for integral parameters [ 25 ] . Several deep learning methods have been proposed to predict structural properties after fitting millions of parameters based on massive data from DFT [ 26 , 27 , 28 ] . However, the inherent chemical origin and deeper insights into specific systems are obscured by the intricate neural network model. Therefore, there is a need for a more direct parameter-free method that can both conceptualize and quantify the electron density distribution, providing a deeper understanding of chemical bonding in carbon nanostructures. In this work, we introduce a streamlined parameter-free statistical bonding free energy (BFE) model for determining electron density distribution by lifting the energy level in carbon nanostructures. The predicted structural properties of this model remarkably align with both experimental findings and first-principles calculations. By integrating the octet rule with the BFE model within a grand canonical ensemble, we can accurately evaluate bonding energies, uncovering significant contributions of bonding entropy to structural stability in carbon nanostructures. Furthermore, the occupancy numbers (ONs) of each C-C bond derived from our model predict the electron density and bond length. These ONs can serve as hopping integrals in the TB models, thereby simplifying accurate predictions of electronic structures, including energy gaps, energy levels, and the corresponding spatial distribution of wavefunctions. Local aromaticity is defined by the mean value of ONs in each six-membered ring, offering a simple yet effective method to measure electron delocalization in the \pi -conjugated system. Our method provides valuable insights into the structural properties and quantum behavior of electrons across different dimensional carbon nanostructures. II RESULTS AND DISCUSSION II.1 The derivation of bonding free energy model Figure 1: (a) Top part is two Kekul \acute{\textrm{e}} structures (denoted by \phi_{1},\phi_{2} ) and the average structure of benzene (denoted by \psi_{1} ); middle part is the energy level diagram of two degenerate state \phi_{1},\phi_{2} ; bottom part is the structure and charge distribution of benzene calculated by DFT. (b) Top part is four Kekul \acute{\textrm{e}} structures of anthracene (denoted by \phi_{1} - \phi_{4} ); middle part is the energy level diagram of four degenerate state \phi_{1} - \phi_{4} with the undetermined parameters; bottom part is the structure and charge density of anthracene calculated by DFT. To understand the interatomic interactions in carbon nanostructures, we start from the simple benzene molecule, which has two different forms of alternating single and double bonds that obey the octet rule as shown in the top panel of FIG. 1(a). The degenerated Kekul \acute{\textrm{e}} structures hold three-fold symmetry, where the fictional C-C double bond is stronger than C-C single bond, violating the identical C-C bonds in the benzene molecule. To lift the two-fold degenerate energy level, the equally weighted superposition of two Kekul \acute{\textrm{e}} structures can satisfy the intrinsic symmetry as depicted in the middle panel of FIG. 1 (a), which has the lowest

Read the complete text