Surface Wave-Aerodynamic Roughness Length Model for Air-Sea Interactions
Manuel Ayala, \aff a Dennice F. Gayme, \aff a Charles Meneveau, \aff a · 2024
Read Surface Wave-Aerodynamic Roughness Length Model for Air-Sea Interactions by Manuel Ayala, \aff a Dennice F. Gayme, \aff a Charles Meneveau, \aff a (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-13491.txt.
Introduction
Manuel Ayala, Dennice Gayme, and Charles Meneveau model how wind drags on ocean waves in a paper from twenty twenty-four. The key quantity is the surface roughness length, which sets air-sea momentum exchange. Their SWARL model takes maps of wave surface height at successive times, plus a flow Reynolds number. Pressure drag is estimated from flow over moving wave shapes, and viscous drag from a standard equilibrium model. Tested on over three hundred data sets, the model matched measured roughness and drag better than common existing methods.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Manuel Ayala, \aff a Dennice F. Gayme, \aff a Charles Meneveau, \aff a |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-13491
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Surface Wave-Aerodynamic Roughness Length Model for Air-Sea Interactions Manuel Ayala, \aff a Dennice F. Gayme, \aff a Charles Meneveau, \aff a Abstract A new model to evaluate the equivalent hydrodynamic length or surface roughness, z 0 z_{0} , of ocean waves is developed and tested. The proposed Surface Wave-Aerodynamic Roughness Length (SWARL) model requires maps of the wave surface height at consecutive times and the air flow characteristic Reynolds number as inputs. Pressure drag is accounted for by approximating the relative velocity in a frame moving with the local wave phase-speed assuming ideal inviscid ramp flow ( Ayala et al., 2024 ) . Drag from viscous and unresolved ripples is modeled using the standard equilibrium model. The SWARL model is tested using over 300 datasets for monochromatic and broad-spectrum wave surfaces. The model-predicted z 0 z_{0} and drag coefficients are compared to measured values, as well as commonly used wave parametrization methods found in the literature. For datasets with well-characterized surfaces, the proposed model shows significantly better agreement with data compared to prior models. For data that did not include a full characterization of the wave fields (typically field data), the model yields predictions with accuracy similar to prior models. Results highlight that including detailed flow physics and extensive wave-field characterization in the modeling of z 0 z_{0} can provide significant improvements in roughness-length based modeling of air-sea interactions. \statement This paper introduces a new method to predict the surface drag force of wind over ocean waves, a key parameter for weather forecasting, climate modeling, and offshore engineering. Drag is typically quantified by a roughness length (a measure of the resistance to the wind at the wind-wave interface due to moving surface waves), which conventional methods estimate using empirical formulas or assumptions that fail to capture the dynamics accurately. Our model predicts the roughness length based on geometric knowledge about the moving surface. It performs well on both simple and complex wave shapes, showing significantly better agreement with data than traditional approaches. By improving drag predictions, this method can enhance simulations of hurricane prediction, climate modeling, and offshore wind farm design. 1 Introduction The interaction between wind and waves represents one of nature’s most intricate, multiscale phenomena, occurring at the crucial interface between the atmosphere and the ocean ( Young, 1999 ) . Accurate prediction of the associated fluxes (of momentum, heat, water, air) is essential for advancing weather forecasting, climate studies ( Cronin et al., 2019 ) , and enhancing offshore wind farm design and construction, especially as the demand for sustainable energy sources such as offshore wind farms, increases ( Veers et al., 2023 ) . However, developing accurate and practical parameterizations of air-sea surface fluxes remains challenging due to the inherent complexity of marine atmospheric boundary layer (MABL) turbulence. Similar to static surface roughness, moving waves play a critical role in shaping the momentum balance between turbulent air flow and the underlying surface ( Sullivan and McWilliams, 2010 ; Chung et al., 2021 ) . However, unlike static roughness elements that are fixed and interact with the flow only through form and viscous drag due to the relative velocity between air and the surface, wave fields move, and are characterized by local phase velocity and orbital velocities that affect the air flow above. Nonetheless, flow over both surfaces often result in logarithmic (or Monin-Obukov similarty theory based) profiles of the mean air velocity, at sufficiently high Reynolds numbers. Therefore, the averaged wave effects can be similarly represented with an equivalent hydrodynamic length, z_{0} ( Deskos et al., 2021 ) . Determining this quantity accurately based on information about the surface and without having to perform costly experiments or eddy and surface-resolving numerical simulations remains an open challenge. In the case of static surface roughness, traditional methods to determine z_{0} utilize topographical parameters that depend solely on the geometry of the surface ( Chung et al., 2021 ) . Approaches for estimating equivalent roughness lengths a priori have been developed with some success using empirically fit models ( Flack and Chung, 2022 ) , machine learning approaches ( Aghaei Jouybari et al., 2021 ) , and more recently, a fluid mechanics-based geometric parameter called the wind-shade factor ( Meneveau et al., 2024 ) . On the other hand, due to the inherently time-varying nature of waves, most of the ideas and methods that work for static surfaces are not applicable. State-of-the-art approaches for determining equivalent surface roughness for surface waves similarly rely heavily on empirical models with parameters obtained via fits to available data ( Deskos et al., 2021 ) . Using dimensional analysis, Charnock (1955) proposed the earliest and best-known roughness parametrization for ocean waves as: z_{0}/H_{s}=\alpha_{\text{c}h}u_{*}^{2}/(gH_{s}), (1) where z_{0} is the equivalent hydrodynamic length (roughness length), H_{s} is the significant wave height, u_{*} is the friction velocity, and g is the gravitational acceleration. The Charnock parameter \alpha_{\text{ch}} was originally treated as a constant, though subsequent studies have demonstrated that it varies significantly with sea state and environmental conditions ( Deskos et al., 2021 ) . One of the most widely used surface flux parameterizations is the Coupled Ocean–Atmosphere Response Experiment (COARE) 3.5 bulk flux algorithm ( Edson et al., 2013 ) . The COARE 3.5 algorithm provides two parameterizations for \alpha_{\text{ch}} , one based on wave age: \alpha_{\text{c}h}=0.114(u_{*}/c_{p})^{0.622}, (2) and another based on wave steepness: \alpha_{\text{c}h}=0.091\,H_{s}k_{p}, (3) where c_{p} and k_{p} are the wave-field’s peak wave phase speed and wave-number, respectively. Wave forecasting models such as WAve Model (WAM), Simulating WAves Nearshore (SWAN), and WaveWatch III (WW3) adopt yet another approach for estimating the Charnock parameter. In these models, it is calculated as: \alpha_{\text{c}h}=\frac{\hat{\alpha}}{\sqrt{1-\frac{\tau_{w}}{\tau}}}, (4) where, \hat{\alpha} is typically taken between 0.01 and 0.0185 ( European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts, 2016 ; The SWAN team, 2024 ) , \tau=\rho_{a}\,u_{*}^{2} is the total stress at the interface between wind and waves, where \rho_{a} is the density of the air. \tau_{w} is the wave-induced stress calculated as: \tau_{w}=\rho_{a}\int\int\omega^{2}\,\gamma\,E(|k|,\theta)\,d\theta|k|dk, (5) where \omega is the angular frequency, E(|k|,\theta) is the two-dimensional wave energy spectrum and \gamma is the growth rate parameter, which is commonly taken as \gamma=0.25\left(\frac{u_{*}}{c}\cos{\theta_{w}}-1\right) (6) in WAM ( The WAMDI Group, 1988 ) and SWAN ( The SWAN team, 2024 ) . Many other studies have proposed parameterizations of roughness based on wave age, defined as c_{p}/u_{*} . These models generally take the form: z_{0}/H_{s}=A(u_{*}/c_{p})^{B}, (7) where, A and B are two empirically-determined parameters from fitting to data. Drennan et al. (2003) proposed A=3.35 and B=3.4 while Donelan (1990) proposed A=0.46 and B=2.53 . To account for wind-wave misalignment, Porchetta et al. (2019) introduced a directional dependence in the coefficients and proposed A=20\cos{(0.45\,\theta_{w})} and B=3.82\cos{(-0.32\,\theta_{w})} , where \theta_{w} is the angle between wind and wave direction. An alternative roughness parameterization based on wave steepness was proposed by Taylor and Yelland (2001) , leading to the expression: z_{0}/H_{s}=1200(H_{s}/\lambda_{p})^{3.4}, (8) where \lambda_{p} is the wavelength of the peak wave.These surface roughness parameterizations form a foundational component of many atmospheric and oceanographic modeling systems. For a more comprehensive discussion of these and other models, we refer to Zhao and Li (2024) ; Lin and Sheng (2020) ; Deskos et al. (2021) . Surface roughness models are routinely used to