Generating Diverse Hypotheses for Inductive Reasoning
Kang-il Lee, Hyukhun Koh, Dongryeol Lee, Seunghyun Yoon, Minsung Kim, Kyomin Jung · 2024
Read Generating Diverse Hypotheses for Inductive Reasoning by Kang-il Lee, Hyukhun Koh, Dongryeol Lee, Seunghyun Yoon, Minsung Kim, Kyomin Jung (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-13422.txt.
Introduction
Kang-il Lee and five co-authors present a 2024 method to help language models reason by forming general rules from a few examples. A common approach samples many guesses at the rule and keeps the one that fits best. Random sampling, though, often repeats near-identical guesses and wastes computing power. Raising the randomness setting adds variety only up to a point, after which the text falls apart.
Their method, Mixture of Concepts, borrows from how people reason: it guides the model to build guesses from different starting concepts. On several inductive reasoning benchmarks, the method beat plain repeated sampling and other rivals by a clear margin. It produced guesses that were both more varied in meaning and higher in quality. The work matters for tasks where a model must infer hidden rules from sparse clues.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kang-il Lee, Hyukhun Koh, Dongryeol Lee, Seunghyun Yoon, Minsung Kim, Kyomin Jung |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-13422
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Generating Diverse Hypotheses for Inductive Reasoning Kang-il Lee, Hyukhun Koh, Dongryeol Lee, Seunghyun Yoon, Minsung Kim, Kyomin Jung Abstract Inductive reasoning — the process of inferring general rules from a small number of observations — is a fundamental aspect of human intelligence. Recent works suggest that large language models (LLMs) can engage in inductive reasoning by sampling multiple hypotheses about the rules and selecting the one that best explains the observations. However, due to the IID sampling, semantically redundant hypotheses are frequently generated, leading to significant wastage of compute. In this paper, we 1) demonstrate that increasing the temperature to enhance the diversity is limited due to text degeneration issue, and 2) propose a novel method to improve the diversity while maintaining text quality. We first analyze the effect of increasing the temperature parameter, which is regarded as the LLM’s diversity control, on IID hypotheses. Our analysis shows that as temperature rises, diversity and accuracy of hypotheses increase up to a certain point, but this trend saturates due to text degeneration. To generate hypotheses that are more semantically diverse and of higher quality, we propose a novel approach inspired by human inductive reasoning, which we call Mixture of Concepts (MoC). When applied to several inductive reasoning benchmarks, MoC demonstrated significant performance improvements compared to standard IID sampling and other approaches. 1 Introduction Inductive reasoning , inferring general rules that explain a small number of observations (Figure 1 ), is a key factor of human intelligence ( Lake et al., 2015 ; Chollet, 2019 ) . Recently, there has been exploration into automatic inductive reasoning using large language models (LLMs). Trained with vast corpora and instruction tuning, LLMs can function as zero-shot rule proposers when given an inductive reasoning problem ( Qiu et al., 2024 ) . By leveraging this capability, a new paradigm in automatic inductive reasoning has emerged: feeding observations (often referred to as train examples) as prompts into the LLM, sampling multiple hypotheses about the rule, and selecting the one that best explains the observations ( Wang et al., 2024b ; Greenblatt, 2024 ; Brown et al., 2024 ) . However, when the hypotheses are generated by LLMs are fundamentally IID, it often leads to redundant sampling of semantically identical hypotheses. Such redundancy reduces the diversity of hypotheses and results in a significant waste of compute. To address aforementioned problem, we begin by increasing the temperature, which is often considered a diversity parameter for LMs, in IID sampling setup. Our findings indicate that while both diversity and accuracy improve up to a certain point with increased temperature, they quickly reach saturation. This is because raising the temperature deteriorates the quality of hypotheses, and increases the rate of text degeneration ( Holtzman et al., 2020 ) . Figure 1: A motivation for MoC approach. IID sampling frequently generates redundant hypotheses (top). Increasing the temperature leads to frequent occurrences of text degeneration (middle). MoC allows for the generation of diverse hypotheses without a decline in hypothesis quality (bottom). To generate diverse hypotheses while maintaining their quality, we propose a simple yet effective method called Mixture of Concepts (MoC). Inspired by human inductive reasoning ( Hofstadter, 1979 ; Mitchell, 2021 ) , our approach consists of two stages: concept proposal and hypothesis generation . In the concept proposal, we instruct the LLM to generate “a list of K concepts” that are likely to aid in the formation of hypotheses, and semantically non-redundant concepts are generated sequentially . In the hypothesis generation, these concepts are parsed and each concept is provided as a hint for generating hypotheses. Our approach allows for the parallel generation of semantically diverse hypotheses without hurting the quality of hypotheses (Figure 1 ). We conduct experiments on four inductive reasoning datasets from distinct domains. Our methodology significantly improves performance across four LLMs by generating diverse hypotheses while maintaining their quality. Compared to vanilla IID sampling with the same number of generated hypotheses, MoC boosts average accuracy by 4.5%p for GPT-4o-mini and 5.0%p for Llama-3.1-70B-Instruct as base LLM, respectively. Our analysis also shows that MoC enables the LLMs to crack challenging problems that are impossible to solve through IID sampling within a practical compute budget. Our contributions are as follows: • We analyze how the diversity and accuracy of IID hypotheses generated from LLMs vary with a change in temperature. • We propose Mixture of Concepts (MoC), a methodology enabling more diverse and parallel hypothesis generation in LLMs. • Our experimental results on four datasets and four models show that MoC significantly enhances both the efficiency and performance of inductive reasoning capability of LLMs. 2 Hypothesis Diversity and Temperature In this section, we provide a description of the problem statement and the baseline method. Subsequently, we analyze the impact of temperature on the diversity and accuracy of hypotheses generated by an LLM. 2.1 Problem Statement and Baseline Problem Statement We consider inductive reasoning problem with n train examples D_{train}=\{(x_{1},y_{1}),(x_{2},y_{2}),...,(x_{n},y_{n})\} and m test examples D_{test}=\{(x_{1}^{\prime},y_{1}^{\prime}),(x_{2}^{\prime},y_{2}^{\prime}),...,(x_{m}^{\prime},y_{m}^{\prime})\} . There is a function f that maps all the inputs to corresponding outputs: f(x_{i})=y_{i} and f(x_{j}^{\prime})=y_{j}^{\prime} for all i\in[n] and j\in[m] , where [n]=\{1,2,...,n\} . The goal of this task is to predict \{y_{1}^{\prime},y_{2}^{\prime},...,y_{m}^{\prime}\} , given the D_{train} and \{x_{1}^{\prime},x_{2}^{\prime},...,x_{m}^{\prime}\} . Simple Baseline Here, we describe a simple baseline method that we use in our experiments. We adopt the setup defined in recent inductive reasoning and Programming-by-Example (PBE) literature, where the function \hat{f} is first inferred and the test outputs are obtained as \{\hat{f}(x_{j}^{\prime})\}_{j\in[m]} . The function \hat{f} is implemented as a Python function, unlike traditional PBE works using domain-specific lanuguages (DSLs). We prompt LLMs with instruction to generate a hypothesis about f in natural language form and then implement it in Python, following the recent LLM inductive reasoning works ( Qiu et al., 2024 ; Wang et al., 2024b ) . We sample a fixed number of K responses and extract the Python function from these responses, forming a hypothesis pool \{\hat{f}_{1},\hat{f}_{2},...,\hat{f}_{K}\} . Among these hypotheses, the one that perfectly explains the train examples, i.e. y_{i}=\hat{f}_{k}(x_{i}) for all i\in[n] , is picked and submitted to be validated on the test examples. If there is no such hypothesis, we regard the problem as not being solved correctly. We consider that a problem is solved correctly if \hat{f}_{k} passes every test cases: y_{j}^{\prime}=\hat{f}_{k}(x_{j}^{\prime}) for all j\in[m] . Duplicate Hypotheses The issue with the aforementioned simple baseline is that, since it samples K hypotheses from IID distributions, a significant portion of these hypotheses may be semantically redundant. If the hypothesis is correct, this redundancy does not pose a problem; however, if an incorrect hypothesis is sampled multiple times, it results in a serious waste of the generation budget. To investigate whether this redundancy is problematic, we analyze how many semantically unique hypotheses are among the K hypotheses, for the instances that the baseline failed to solve correctly. We implement the baseline using GPT-4o-mini ( gpt-4o-mini-2024-07-18 ) with temperature value of 1 and conduct the experiment in the List Functions dataset ( Rule, 2020 ) . In order to count the number of semantically unique hypotheses, a method to determine whether two hypotheses were semantically identical or different is needed. Since we represent the hypotheses as Python