Modeling coskewness with zero correlation and correlation with zero coskewness

Carole Bernard, Jinghui Chen, Steven Vanduffel · 2024

Read Modeling coskewness with zero correlation and correlation with zero coskewness by Carole Bernard, Jinghui Chen, Steven Vanduffel (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-13362.txt.

Introduction

Carole Bernard, Jinghui Chen, and Steven Vanduffel untangle two dependence measures in a 2024 paper. Correlation tracks whether variables move together on average. Coskewness tracks whether one variable's extremes pair with another's squared swings, a subtler joint pattern used in finance.

Intuition might link the two, but the authors show they are free of each other. Among symmetric variables, any coskewness values can occur while every pairwise correlation is zero. The reverse also holds: coskewness can vanish at any correlation level. They extend the result to arbitrary distributions using rank based versions. The warning is practical: do not infer one measure from the other when modeling joint risk.

Catalog record

CREATORCarole Bernard, Jinghui Chen, Steven Vanduffel
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-13362

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modeling coskewness with zero correlation and correlation with zero coskewness Carole Bernard, Jinghui Chen, Steven Vanduffel Abstract This paper shows that one needs to be careful when making statements on potential links between correlation and coskewness. Specifically, we first show that, on the one hand, it is possible to observe any possible values of coskewness among symmetric random variables but zero pairwise correlations of these variables. On the other hand, it is also possible to have zero coskewness and any level of correlation. Second, we generalize this result to the case of arbitrary marginal distributions showing the absence of a general link between rank correlation and standardized rank coskewness. Keywords: Coskewness, Correlation, Rank coskewness, Rank correlation, Copula, Marginal distribution. 1 Introduction Let X_{i}\sim F_{i} , i=1,2,\dots,d be random variables such that \mu_{i} and \sigma_{i} are their respective means and standard deviations, and their second moments are finite. One of the essential characteristics of dependency of a random vector \bm{X}=(X_{1},X_{2},\dots,X_{d}) is the k th order standardized central mixed moments \mathbb{E}\left(\left(\frac{X_{1}-\mu_{1}}{\sigma_{1}}\right)^{k_{1}}\left(\frac{X_{2}-\mu_{2}}{\sigma_{2}}\right)^{k_{2}}\cdots\left(\frac{X_{d}-\mu_{d}}{\sigma_{d}}\right)^{k_{d}}\right) where k_{i}, i=1,2,\dots,d, are non-negative integers such that \sum_{i=1}^{d}k_{i}=k . Specifically, the Pearson correlation coefficient ( Pearson, 1895 ) is obtained when k_{1}=k_{2}=1 ( d=2 ) and coskewness is obtained when k_{1}=k_{2}=k_{3}=1 ( d=3 ). The correlation coefficient between X_{i} and X_{j} denoted as \rho_{ij} , i,j=1,2,\dots,d , is given as \rho_{ij}=\frac{\mathbb{E}((X_{i}-\mu_{i})(X_{j}-\mu_{j}))}{\sigma_{i}\sigma_{j}}, and the correlation matrix is a d by d matrix. Jondeau and Rockinger (2006) define the d by d^{2} coskewness matrix of a d -dimensional random vector \bm{X} , as a matrix that contains all coskewnesses. The coskewness of X_{i} , X_{j} and X_{k} , denoted by S(X_{i},X_{j},X_{k}) , i,j,k=1,2,\dots,d , is given as S(X_{i},X_{j},X_{k})=\frac{\mathbb{E}((X_{i}-\mu_{i})(X_{j}-\mu_{j})(X_{k}-\mu_{k}))}{\sigma_{i}\sigma_{j}\sigma_{k}}. The coskewness matrix is denoted by M_{d} , so that, for example, when d=3 , M_{3}=\left[\begin{array}[]{ccc|ccc|ccc}s_{111}&s_{112}&s_{113}&s_{211}&s_{212}&s_{213}&s_{311}&s_{312}&s_{313}\\ s_{121}&s_{122}&s_{123}&s_{221}&s_{222}&s_{223}&s_{321}&s_{322}&s_{323}\\ s_{131}&s_{132}&s_{133}&s_{231}&s_{232}&s_{233}&s_{331}&s_{332}&s_{333}\end{array}\right], where s_{ijk}=S(X_{i},X_{j},X_{k}) , i,j,k=1,2,3 . The coskewness matrix M_{d} is invariant w.r.t. location and scale parameters, i.e., a linear transformation of X_{i} , i=1,2,\dots,d , does not affect M_{d} . However, the coskewness S(X_{i},X_{j},X_{k}) generally depends on the marginal distributions and copula among the three variables; see Bernard et al. (2023) . It is well-known that correlation always takes values in [-1,1] . However, such affirmation is not true for higher co-moments such as coskewness and cokurtosis. In particular, no universal range of values for coskewness works for all distributions; see Bernard et al. (2023) . We thus use the notion of standardized rank coskewness, which is normalized and takes values in [-1,\ 1] . This paper studies whether a relationship exists between correlation and coskewness. At first glance, it is easy to think that the answer is affirmative because the mathematical formulas of correlation and coskewness share some similarities. Moreover, correlations do not determine the dependence but at least impose some structure. For instance, the maximum and minimum correlation between two random variables are obtained by comonotonic and antimonotonic dependence, respectively. Hence, one could expect a link between the second cross and the third cross moment. For example, Beddock and Karehnke (2020) use a split bivariate normal model to illustrate that the coskewness is monotonic to the correlation; see their Table 3. However, such conclusion heavily depends on the model assumed (here the split bivariate normal), and the remaining of this paper is dedicated to showing that, in general, there is no link between correlation and coskewness and that such conclusions can only be made under specific model assumptions. The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we present counterexamples based on three symmetrically distributed random variables. In Section 3 , we generalize the result to the case of random variables with arbitrary marginal distributions. Section 4 provides some elements to justify statements that appear in previous literature on the link between coskewness and tail risk. The last section draws the conclusion. 2 Correlation and coskewness with symmetric marginals In this section, we aim to show that, in general, there is no link between the coskewness and the correlation coefficient in the case of symmetric distributions. Let F_{i} , i=1,2,3 , be symmetric distributions, i.e., X_{i}\sim F_{i} . For symmetric case, we have explicit copulas to obtain the maximizing and minimizing coskewness ( Bernard et al., 2023 , see) . Moreover, the symmetric distribution appears as a benchmark in many applications in finance, such as optimal portfolio choice. More general distributions are discovered in Section 3 . The goal of Section 2 is to prove the following two propositions. Proposition 2.1 . Let (X_{1},X_{2},X_{3}) be a random vector with symmetric marginals. For any given value of coskewness, ranging between the minimum and maximum admissible values, there exists a dependence model such that the coskewness among the three variables attains this value, and such that the pairwise correlations are all equal to zero. Proof. In Section 2.1 , we construct such a model. ∎ Proposition 2.2 . Let (X_{1},X_{2},X_{3}) be a random vector with symmetric marginals. For every given set of correlations among the three variables, there exists a dependence model such that their coskewness is equal to zero. Proof. In Section 2.2 , we construct such a model. ∎ 2.1 Arbitrary coskewness and zero correlation We recall that the range of possible values for coskewness depends on the choice of marginal distributions. The following lemma recalls Theorems 3.1 and 3.2 of Bernard et al. (2023) . We thus do not provide a proof. Lemma 2.1 (Theorems 3.1 and 3.2 of Bernard et al. (2023) ) . Let X_{i}\sim F_{i} in which the F_{i} are symmetric, i=1,2,3 , and U\sim U[0,1] . The explicit bounds \underline{S} and \bar{S} for the coskewness of X_{1} , X_{2} and X_{3} are \underline{S}\mathrel{\mathop{\mathchar 58\relax}}=-\mathbb{E}\left(G^{-1}_{1}(U)G^{-1}_{2}(U)G^{-1}_{3}(U)\right)\leq S(X_{1},X_{2},X_{3})\leq\bar{S}\mathrel{\mathop{\mathchar 58\relax}}=\mathbb{E}\left(G^{-1}_{1}(U)G^{-1}_{2}(U)G^{-1}_{3}(U)\right), in which G_{i} is the distribution of \lvert(X_{i}-\mu_{i})/\sigma_{i}\rvert . The maximum coskewness \bar{S} is attained for \bar{S}=S(Y_{1},Y_{2},Y_{3}) in which Y_{i}=F_{i}^{-1}(U_{i}) with U_{i} as in \displaystyle U_{1} \displaystyle=U, (2.1) \displaystyle U_{2} \displaystyle=IJU+I(1-J)(1-U)+(1-I)JU+(1-I)(1-J)(1-U), \displaystyle U_{3} \displaystyle=IJU+I(1-J)(1-U)+(1-I)J(1-U)+(1-I)(1-J)U, where I=\mathds{1}_{U>\frac{1}{2}} , J=\mathds{1}_{V>\frac{1}{2}} , and V\overset{d}{=}U[0,1] is independent of U . The minimum coskewness \underline{S} is attained for \underline{S}=S(H_{1},H_{2},H_{3}) in which H_{i}=F_{i}^{-1}(U_{i}) with U_{i} as in \displaystyle U_{1} \displaystyle=U, (2.2) \displaystyle U_{2} \displaystyle=IJU+I(1-J)(1-U)+(1-I)JU+(1-I)(1-J)(1-U), \displaystyle U_{3} \displaystyle=IJ(1-U)+I(1-J)U+(1-I)JU+(1-I)(1-J)(1-U). When F_{i} , i=1,2,3 , are symmetric, the bounds can be computed explicitly; see Table 2 in Bernard et al. (2023) . We now construct a model in which the coskewness varies from \underline{S} to \bar{S} but where the pairwise correlations of these variables are always equal to zero. To do so, let us introduce a mixture copula C^{\lambda} for \lambda\in[0,1] based on Lemma 2.1 . We refer to Lindsay (1995) for a study on mixture models. Definition 2.1 (Mixture Copula) . Let X_{i}\sim F_{i} , i=1,2,3 , in which the F_{i} are symmetric, U\overset{d}{=}V\sim U[0,1] such that U\perp V , B\sim Bernoulli(\lambda) where B is independent of X_{i} , U and V , and \lambda\in[0,1] . Define two indicator functions I=\mathds{1}_{U>\frac{1}{2}} and J=\mathds{1}_{V>\frac{1}{2}} . The dependence structure of X_{1}=F_{1}^{-1}(U_{1}) , X_{2}=F_{2}^{-1}(U_{2}) and X_{3}=F_{3}^{-1}(U_{3}^{\lambda}) is called a mixture copula C^{\lambda} when the trivariate random vector (U_{1},U_{2},U_{3}^{\lambda}) is given as \displaystyle U_{1} \displaystyle=U, (2.3) \displaystyle U_{2} \displaystyle=IJU+I(1-J)(1-U)+(1-I)JU+(1-I)(1-J)(1-U), \displaystyle U_{3}^{\lambda} \displaystyle=BU_{3}^{M}+(1-B)U_{3}^{m}, where \displaystyle U_{3}^{M} \displaystyle=IJU+I(1-J)(1-U)+(1-I)J(1-U)+(1-I)(1-J)U and \displaystyle U_{3}^{m} \displaystyle=IJ(1-U)+I(1-J)U+(1-I)JU+(1-I)(1-J)(1-U). U_{j} in ( 2.1 ) and U_{j} in ( 2.2 ) are the same for j=1,2 , thus U_{j}^{m}=U_{j}^{M}=U_{j}^{\lambda}=U_{j} . Note that McNeil et

Read the complete text