Where do X-ray low surface brightness clusters sit with respect to filaments?

S. Zarattini, S. Andreon, and E. Puddu · 2024

Read Where do X-ray low surface brightness clusters sit with respect to filaments? by S. Zarattini, S. Andreon, and E. Puddu (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-13258.txt.

Introduction

Zarattini, Andreon, and Puddu ask where gas-poor galaxy clusters sit inside the cosmic web, in a 2024 paper. Clusters with faint X-ray glow hold less hot gas than bright ones. The team took twenty-nine clusters from a carefully unbiased sample and measured each one's distance to the spine of its nearest filament, the great strands along which galaxies gather. They then compared distances with mass, gas fraction, and brightness.

Faint clusters sat, on average, farther from filaments than bright ones, with middling clusters in between. Very few faint clusters came within two megaparsecs of a spine. A statistical test could not fully rule out chance, and the authors say so. They speculate that filaments shield clusters from their central black hole's outflows, letting gas fall back sooner. A larger sample is needed to settle the idea, they conclude.

Catalog record

CREATORS. Zarattini, S. Andreon, and E. Puddu
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE23 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-13258

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Where do X-ray low surface brightness clusters sit with respect to filaments? S. Zarattini, S. Andreon, and E. Puddu Abstract Aims. The aim of this work is to study the position of gas-rich and gas-poor galaxy clusters within the large-scale structure and, in particular, their distance to filaments. Methods. Our sample is built from 29 of the 34 clusters in the X-ray unbiased cluster sample (XUCS), a velocity-dispersion-selected sample for which various properties, including masses, gas fractions, and X-ray surface brightness were available in the literature. We compute the projected distance between each cluster and the spine of the nearest filament with the same redshift and investigate the link between this distance and the previously-mentioned properties of the clusters, in particular with their gas content. Results. The average distance between clusters and filaments is larger for low X-ray surface brightness clusters than for those of high surface brightness, with intermediate brightness clusters being an intermediate case. Also the minimum distance follows a similar trend, with rare cases of low surface brightness clusters found at distances smaller than 2 Mpc from the spine of filaments. However, the Kolmogorov-Smirnov statistical test is not able to exclude the null hypothesis that the two distributions are coming from the same parent one. We speculate that the position of galaxy clusters within the cosmic web could have a direct impact in their gas mass fraction, hence on its X-ray surface brightness, since the presence of a filament can oppose resistance to the outward flow of gas induced by the central AGN and reduce the time required for this gas to fall inward after the AGN is shut. However, a larger sample of clusters is needed in order to derive a statistically-robust conclusion. 1 Introduction Studies of the intracluster medium are primarily conducted on galaxy cluster samples selected according to the properties of the intracluster medium itself. This selection can be performed either directly, by detecting the X-ray emission of the gas, or indirectly, by examining its effect on cosmic background photons, a phenomenon known as the Sunyaev–Zeldovich effect ( Sunyaev & Zeldovich 1972 , SZ effect,) . It is now accepted that this kind of selections can lead to a biased vision of the entire galaxy cluster population. In fact, for a given mass, X-ray observations can more easily find clusters that are brighter than average, whereas clusters that are fainter than average would be mainly undetected. This bias has often been taken into account ( Stanek et al. 2006 ; Pacaud et al. 2007 ; Andreon et al. 2011 ; Andreon & Moretti 2011 ; Eckert et al. 2011 ; Planck Collaboration et al. 2011 ; Andreon et al. 2016 , for example in) , however correcting it is not trivial, since it is based on assumptions on the unseen population. Andreon et al. 2022 showed that the covariance between the position of a cluster in the mass-temperature diagram and its detectability is strong. On the other hand, the luminosity-temperature plane is not affected by the missing population, thus demonstrating that this population behaves differently depending on the analysed scaling relations. In Andreon et al. 2016 , an unbiased sample was selected using velocity dispersion measurements. Using this sample, called XUCS, the authors demonstrated that the clusters missing from X-ray selection are those with low X-ray surface brightness. Subsequently, Andreon et al. 2017b showed that differences in surface brightness were related to the gas fraction of clusters. In particular, systems with lower brightness have a smaller gas fraction. Figure 1: Environment of two clusters, CL1052 (left panel), which is one of the most distant clusters from filaments, and CL3030 (right panel), which is a high surface brightness with typical (median) distance. Our clusters are marked by the black cross in the centre, with the dark green circle representing their virial radii r 200 , whereas filaments are in coral and intersections (not used in this work) are in rose. The closest filament point, used for measuring the distance, is surrounded by a green rhombus. It was recently found that groups and clusters behave differently depending on their position on the cosmic web. In particular, Zarattini et al. 2023 found that fossil groups (FGs, called in this way for historical reasons, but that include both groups and clusters) are located, on average, farther from both filaments and nodes with respect to non-fossil ones. Moreover, FGs seem unable to survive in the nodes of the cosmic web. Their interpretation is that the position on the cosmic web is the main driver of their evolution, reducing the number of bright galaxies accreted by these systems and affecting the orbits of the infalling galaxies. As a consequence, the merging rate of bright satellites increases, favouring the creation of the large difference in magnitude between the two brightest members of the system. Similarly, Popesso et al. 2024 studied the position of GAMA clusters and groups ( Driver et al. 2022 ) that were not detected in the early data release of the eROSITA Final Equatorial Depth Survey ( Brunner et al. 2022 , eFEDS,) . They found that the eRosita undetected population is more likely to be found in filaments, whereas the population of groups and clusters detected also by eRosita is more likely found in nodes. It is thus becoming urgent to assess the role of the cosmic web in the evolution of galaxy clusters and groups. In fact, the presence of filaments and nodes could have a direct impact on the gas distribution within the cluster, as it was shown by Gouin et al. 2022 using the IllustrisTNG simulation. In particular, these authors found that the warm and hot intergalactic medium follows the dark matter azimuthal distribution, meaning that the gas is following the filaments in its motion. This effect should leave clear imprints in the mass assembly history, in particular in the formation time, accretion rate, and dynamical state of clusters. Recently, Santoni et al. 2024 also found in The Three Hundred hydrodynamical simulation that cluster masses are related to the connectivity (e.g. the number of filaments globally connected to a cluster), whereas the dynamical state of clusters seems unrelated to this parameter. The goal of our work is to test if low surface brightness cluster are found in peculiar positions of the cosmic web and if this position can in some way justify the smaller gas fraction found in these objects. Throughout this paper, we assume \Omega_{M}=0.3 , \Omega_{\Lambda}=0.7 , and H_{0}=70 km s -1 Mpc -1 . 2 Sample of clusters and large-scale structure In this Section we introduce the catalogue of filaments and intersections and the X-ray unbiased cluster sample (XUCS) that we use in our analysis. 2.1 Catalogue of the large-scale structure The catalogue of the large-scale structure that we use in this work was presented in Chen et al. 2016 . It is based on the so called subspace constrained mean shift (SCMS), a gradient-based method able to detect filaments through density ridges (smooth curves tracing high-density regions). The SCMS method was applied to the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 12 (SDSS-DR12) spectroscopic data. This is the last data release from the SDSS-III phase and it includes more than one

Read the complete text