Redshift tomography of the kinematic matter dipole

Sebastian von Hausegger, Charles Dalang · 2024

Read Redshift tomography of the kinematic matter dipole by Sebastian von Hausegger, Charles Dalang (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-13162.txt.

Introduction

Sebastian von Hausegger and Charles Dalang formalize in this 2024 paper how to slice the cosmic matter dipole by distance. Our motion through space stamps a dipole on the sky map of far-off sources, a basic check of standard cosmology. Computing it in redshift bands sounds simple, but picking sources by observed redshift adds a twist: the same motion boosts the redshifts themselves.

That boost leaves correction terms that do not vanish and can grow large, even flipping the dipole's direction for some sample shapes and cuts. The authors give formulas for any selection rule, weigh shaky redshift measures, and size the corrections for coming surveys. Survey teams can now budget for the shift.

Catalog record

CREATORSebastian von Hausegger, Charles Dalang
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE86 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-13162

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Redshift tomography of the kinematic matter dipole Sebastian von Hausegger, Charles Dalang Abstract The dipole anisotropy induced by our peculiar motion in the sky distribution of cosmologically distant sources is an important consistency test of the standard FLRW cosmology. In this work, we formalize how to compute the kinematic matter dipole in redshift bins. Apart from the usual terms arising from angular aberration and flux boosting, there is a contribution from the boosting of the redshifts that becomes important when considering a sample selected on observed redshift, leading to non-vanishing correction terms. We discuss examples and provide expressions to incorporate arbitrary redshift selection functions. We also discuss the effect of redshift measurement uncertainties in this context, in particular in upcoming surveys for which we provide estimates of the correction terms. Depending on the shape of a sample’s redshift distribution and on the applied redshift cuts, the correction terms can become substantial, even to the degree that the direction of the dipole is reversed. Lastly, we discuss how cuts on variables correlated with observed redshift, such as color, can induce additional correction terms. I Introduction T he foundational assumptions of the standard cosmological model are homogeneity and isotropy, also known as the Cosmological Principle, which together motivate the use of the Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) spacetime. In such a spacetime, all comoving observers would see isotropic radiation and matter fields [ 1 ] , which in turn would be sufficient to prove that we live in a Friedmann universe [ 2 , 3 ] . However, firstly, we only perform observations on or within our past light cone, so only from one vantage point; secondly, we are not comoving observers; thirdly, homogeneity and isotropy are only expected to be satisfied statistically, in practice. Tests of the Cosmological Principle therefore become consistency checks 1 1 1 For recent reviews see, e.g., [ 4 , 5 ] . , and, having entered the era of big data in cosmology, it is now possible to undertake such tests with observations rather than simply going along with the above assumptions. An important question in particular is whether the reference frames in which radiation and matter appear statistically isotropic are truly the same, as is the case in the standard model. The rest frame of radiation can be defined as the frame in which the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) appears statistically isotropic. This is expected to coincide with the frame in which the CMB dipole, considered to be the Doppler-boosted monopole [ 6 ] , vanishes. To-date, the highest-precision measurement of the CMB dipole was performed by the Planck Collaboration, who reported an amplitude of \Delta T=(3.36208\pm 0.00099)\,{\rm mK} , corresponding to a boost 2 2 2 \beta denotes the observer speed v relative to c , the speed of light, \beta\equiv v/c . of \beta=(1.2336\pm 0.0037)\times 10^{-3} towards (l,b)=(264.021\pm 0.011^{\circ},48.253\pm 0.005^{\circ}) [ 7 ] . A number of tests for consistency of this measurement with its kinematic interpretation are possible using CMB data alone. For example, measurements of the dipolar modulation of the higher multipole temperature (and polarization) fluctuations, expected from special relativistic aberration [ 8 ] , generally agree in amplitude and direction with that of the dipole itself [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] . While such measurements, within measurement uncertainties, support the kinematic origin hypothesis, they do not exclude other scenarios, such as those in which large-scale isocurvature perturbations contribute to the CMB dipole [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] . Therefore it is also necessary to test whether there is consistency with the rest frame of matter. The rest frame of matter is determined by observing tracers of the matter distribution, such as galaxies at high redshift, where the Universe is expected to be approximately homogeneous. If such a sample is indeed isotropic across the sky for a comoving observer, Ellis and Baldwin [17] noted that an observer moving with respect to the matter rest frame should see a dipolar modulation of source number counts in a flux-limited catalog, directly proportional to their boost \beta . A cut on observed flux S>S_{*} selects more sources in the direction of motion in which fluxes were Doppler boosted upwards. This dipole is predicted to have an amplitude \mathcal{D}_{\rm kin} that depends only on observed properties of the given sample: the power law index x of the projected integral source counts \mathcal{N}(S>S_{*})\propto S_{*}^{-x} and the average spectral index \alpha of the source spectra S_{\nu}\propto\nu^{-\alpha} , both evaluated directly at the flux cut S_{*} , and the observer’s boost \beta , \displaystyle\mathcal{D}_{\rm kin}=\left[2+x(1+\alpha)\right]\beta\,. (1) The same special relativistic effects that create a dipole in the CMB are responsible for this matter dipole: the factor of 2 arises from angular aberration that scales the unit solid angle of the number density, while the additional terms arise due to the Doppler boosting of the sources’ flux above and below the flux cut. Moreover, similarly to the aberration of CMB fluctuations, an analogous computation predicts a concomitant dipolar modulation of the number count fluctuations [ 18 ] . Hence just as with the CMB dipole, the matter rest frame can be defined with observations of the matter dipole. Our ability to measure the matter dipole has however been limited by the availability of sufficiently large high-redshift galaxy catalogs. While radio catalogs were considered the best-suited for this measurement, due to radio AGN (active galactic nuclei) predominantly occupying redshifts z\sim 1 , the necessary procedures of catalog cleaning suppressed the eligible number of sources to \mathcal{O}(10^{5}) where shot noise undermines a precise dipole measurement. 3 3 3 For comparison, a significant measurement of the expected matter dipole is achieved only with \mathcal{O}(10^{6}) sources. [ 19 , 20 ] Nevertheless, early studies employing the 1.4\,{\rm GHz} NRAO VLA Sky Survey (NVSS) catalog, resulted in observed dipoles that agreed with the CMB dipole expectation in direction, but not in amplitude [ 21 , 22 , 23 ] . Since the discrepancy was a mild \sim 2-3\sigma , more precise measurements were required to conclusively test the consistency between radiation and matter rest frames. Only recently, this requirement was addressed via the new CatWISE catalog of high-redshift quasars in the mid-infrared, compiled using data from the WISE survey. This was the first significant measurement of the matter dipole [ 24 , 25 ] and it confirmed the discrepancy in amplitude previously reported with radio observations. Subsequent independent confirmation with alternative methods and more data now places the ‘matter dipole anomaly’ on firm grounds with a significance of over 5\sigma [ 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 ] . Intriguingly, the rest frames of radiation and matter appear not to coincide. The explanation for this anomaly remains unknown. Tomographic measurements in redshift appear to be a natural next step to the previous redshift-integrated studies. Such measurements might reveal a redshift-dependence of the matter dipole amplitude that could help in finding the explanation for this tension. However, selection in observed redshift requires additional considerations to those made for Eq. ( 1 ): Redshifts of sources are boosted according to \displaystyle(1+z)=(1+\bar{z})(1-\beta\cos\theta)\,, (2) to linear order in \beta , where z is the observed (boosted) redshift of a source, \bar{z} is

Read the complete text