What do we know about cosmic rays with energies above 5 EeV?

Jonathan Biteau, 1, 2 for the Pierre Auger Collaboration 3 · 2024

Read What do we know about cosmic rays with energies above 5 EeV? by Jonathan Biteau, 1, 2 for the Pierre Auger Collaboration 3 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-13077.txt.

Introduction

Above a certain energy, cosmic rays must come from outside our galaxy, and Jonathan Biteau reviews the proof in this 2024 paper for the Pierre Auger Collaboration. Arrival directions from the giant Argentine observatory lean to one side of the sky, a tilt that grows with energy. That pattern marks an extragalactic origin, since the galaxy could not hold such particles anyway.

Models of outside sources spraying bare atomic nuclei reproduce the energy spectrum's bends, including its ankle, instep, and final suppression. The average nucleus grows heavier as energy climbs. No source class is confirmed yet, though hunts for sky patterns matching nearby galaxy maps now near firm detection. The review takes stock of a field closing in on its century-old question.

Catalog record

CREATORJonathan Biteau, 1, 2 for the Pierre Auger Collaboration 3
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-13077

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

What do we know about cosmic rays with energies above 5 EeV? Jonathan Biteau, 1, 2 for the Pierre Auger Collaboration 3 Abstract Cosmic rays begin to reveal their secrets at energies above 5 EeV. Beyond this characteristic energy, known as the spectral “ankle”, the arrival-direction data from the Pierre Auger Observatory show anisotropy on large angular scales of increasing amplitude with energy. This discovery provides observational evidence that cosmic rays beyond the ankle originate outside the Milky Way, as expected from the weak Galactic confinement and the high luminosity required for the sources. Synthetic models of extragalactic source populations emitting fully ionized atoms have allowed us to reproduce the cosmic-ray flux beyond the ankle for almost a decade. These models capture the various slope breaks in the spectrum at ultra-high energies, including the flux suppression at ∼ {\sim}\, 45 EeV and the recently measured feature at ∼ {\sim}\, 15 EeV, known as the spectral “instep”. Such slope breaks are understood as changes in nuclear composition, with the average atomic mass increasing with energy. The population of astrophysical sources responsible for accelerating these nuclei remains unidentified, although serious contenders have been identified. Particularly instructive are the latest searches at the highest energies for anisotropies correlated with the flux patterns expected from galaxies outside the Local Group, which are approaching 5 ​ σ 5\,\sigma . 1 Extragalactic photon, neutrino and cosmic-ray backgrounds The astrophysical sources that populate the celestial sphere form a cosmic background through their cumulative emissions. Our understanding of this background has seen tremendous advances since the beginning of this century. The advances are the result of increasingly precise observations over more than 25 energy decades. A better understanding of local foregrounds (the solar system and the Milky Way), exhaustive deep-field counts of galaxies contributing to the cosmic background, and, in bands where possible, absolute measurements of the brightness of dark-sky patches have unveiled the multi-messenger spectrum of the Universe. The measurements of its intensity, in units of power per unit of solid angle on the sky and per unit of detection area, are shown as a function of frequency and energy in Fig. 1 . Figure 1: Multi-messenger spectrum of the universe. Measurements of, or limits on, cumulative emissions from astrophysical sources are indicated by coloured markers, together with the colour-coded names of the corresponding observatories as shown in the figure. Extracted and adapted from Ref. [ 1 ] . Three components corresponding to different messengers are visible in Fig. 1 : the extragalactic background light (EBL), which extends from radio frequencies above 20 MHz to gamma-ray energies below 1 TeV, the extragalactic neutrino background (ENB), which has been measured from 40 TeV to 2.5 PeV, and the extragalactic cosmic-ray background (ECRB), which reaches energies close to 200 EeV. 1 1 1 1\,\mathrm{TeV}\equiv 10^{12}\,\mathrm{eV} , 1\,\mathrm{PeV}\equiv 10^{15}\,\mathrm{eV} , 1\,\mathrm{EeV}\equiv 10^{18}\,\mathrm{eV} . Although the underlying question has been the subject of century-long theoretical debates, popularized by Olbers’ paradox, the measurement of cosmic backgrounds of astrophysical origin is a young field of research, involving virtually all the astronomical observatories of this century. Particularly noteworthy in the optical band is the recent convergence of direct measurements (New Horizons probe), indirect measurements (H.E.S.S., MAGIC and VERITAS) and galaxy counts (Hubble Space Telescope); [ 2 ] the measurement of the gamma-ray background up to flux suppression at TeV energies by the Fermi -LAT satellite launched in 2008; [ 3 ] the discovery of the ENB in 2013 by the IceCube experiment in Antarctica (see Ref. [ 4 ] for the latest measurements); and the measurement of the cosmic-ray flux at the highest energies, as accumulated over nearly 20 years at the Pierre Auger Observatory. [ 5 ] The census of astrophysical sources contributing to the EBL, ranging from star-forming galaxies for the optical and infrared components to active galactic nuclei with and without jets for the gamma-ray and X-ray components, has reached a high level of completeness. More than 80% of the backgrounds can be assigned to known source populations in the eV, keV, and GeV bands. These emissions are driven by star formation, accretion onto supermassive black holes, and ejection around some of these black holes. This knowledge has led to the recent emergence of broadband population synthesis models that reproduce with relative success the full range of EBL observations from the near millimetre to TeV energies (see the black line from Ref. [ 6 ] in Fig. 1 ). Comparable knowledge is still lacking for ENB and ECRB due to the low flux of their sources, which goes as I_{\nu} or EJ(E) i.e., one power of frequency/energy less than in Fig. 1 , and to the angular spread of the charged particles of the ECRB in the Galactic and intergalactic magnetic fields. The aim of these proceedings is to give an overview of what is known about the nature and origin of ECRB particles above 5 EeV, the energy which marks the ankle of the cosmic-ray spectrum, as shown by the arrow in Fig. 1 . 2 2 2 The cosmic-ray spectrum is shown in Fig. 1 with transparency between the iron knee, around 100 PeV, and the ankle. Below the iron knee, cosmic rays originate from the Milky Way. Above the ankle energy, the origin of cosmic rays was already expected to lie outside the Galaxy in the beginning of this century, as illustrated by the proceedings of M. Hillas published in Ref. [ 7 ] . The author points out that, at the time, there was little convincing evidence for ECRB anisotropies and that the fluxes reported by the various experiments did not agree very well. He therefore gave the newly built Pierre Auger Observatory the task of clarifying the flux level beyond the ankle and of searching for the presence of sources at the highest energies. To quote him: “such particles cannot have travelled more than about 50 Mpc, so the magnetic deflections should not be large and there should be few candidate sources in the directional error boxes”. Let us take stock of twenty years of observations led by the Pierre Auger Collaboration. 2 Cosmic-ray observations at energies larger than 5 EeV The Pierre Auger Observatory is located at 1400 m above sea level over a vast, flat area of the Argentinean pampas, covering 3000 km 2 . The first scientific data collection began in 2004, and the first phase of observations with a complete array ran from 2008 to 2021. Phase 2 is starting at the time of writing with upgraded detectors and will last until at least 2035. This second phase of the Observatory is not covered here. Two complementary types of detectors are used to estimate the energy, mass and arrival direction of cosmic rays beyond the ankle. The first one, operating on clear and dark nights with a duty cycle of the order of 15 %, allows the Collaboration to reconstruct the longitudinal profile of the energy deposition of cosmic-ray showers in the atmosphere, \mathrm{d}E/\mathrm{d}X , from the fluorescence of excited dinitrogen molecules. The integral of this profile, measured by the telescopes of the fluorescence detector (FD), provides a calorimetric estimate of the energy, E , of the primary cosmic ray. The height

Read the complete text