Asymptotically Conically Minkowskian spacetimes from self-gravitating dust
Matteo Fontana, Federico Scali, Sergio Luigi Cacciatori · 2024
Read Asymptotically Conically Minkowskian spacetimes from self-gravitating dust by Matteo Fontana, Federico Scali, Sergio Luigi Cacciatori (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-13048.txt.
Introduction
Matteo Fontana, Federico Scali, and Sergio Luigi Cacciatori examine spinning dust clouds whose gravity warps space into a cone at infinity. Their work appeared in twenty twenty-four. Exact solutions for self-gravitating dust can carry a missing wedge along the rotation axis, like a cosmic string's footprint.
Boundary conditions can erase the wedge on the axis itself. Far away, though, the geometry stays locally flat yet globally conical, never relaxing to ordinary empty space. The trio call such spacetimes asymptotically conically Minkowskian. That distant cone bends light differently than expected. It can also fool an observer into reading the vacuum as full of scalar particles. The effects give far-off watchers a fingerprint of the hidden defect.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Matteo Fontana, Federico Scali, Sergio Luigi Cacciatori |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 81 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-13048
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Asymptotically Conically Minkowskian spacetimes from self-gravitating dust Matteo Fontana, Federico Scali, Sergio Luigi Cacciatori Abstract In this work we investigate some non-Newtonian effects in exact solutions of the Einstein equations, which describe stationary and axisymmetric configurations of self-gravitating dust. A distinctive feature of these solutions is the potential presence of conical singularities along the rotation axis, manifesting as angular deficits. While such singularities can be removed by imposing suitable boundary conditions along the axis, asymptotically far away from it the geometry becomes locally flat, in the sense that the Riemann tensor vanishes, but globally, instead of reducing to Minkowski space, it takes the form of a cone. We refer to these spacetimes as Asymptotically Conically Minkowskian (ACM). We show that such conical structure can originate some interesting effects as seen by asymptotic local observers. These include modifications to the gravitational lensing and the misinterpretation of the vacuum state of a scalar field as a distribution of scalar particles. 1 Introduction Galaxy dynamics has long been understood within the framework of Newtonian mechanics, since the low velocities and weak gravitational fields of galaxies seem to suggest that General Relativity (GR) would play only a minor role. However, a significant problem arises when this traditional approach fails to explain the non-Keplerian velocity profiles observed in galaxies, particularly the nearly flat rotation curves that persist far from their centers, suggesting the presence of more mass than is directly observed [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . This situation could indicate either a limitation in the theory of gravity being used or a need for additional matter beyond what is observed. One prevailing approach has been to keep the Newtonian framework by introducing dark matter (DM), a hypothetical form of matter that interacts primarily through gravity with ordinary baryonic matter. Dark matter not only helps explaining rotation curves but also plays a crucial role in the \Lambda CDM cosmological model, facilitating structure formation [ 4 ] and providing insights into various astrophysical phenomena that appear to require additional mass. These include the virial estimates of galaxies within galaxy clusters [ 5 ] , gravitational lensing effects [ 6 ] , thermodynamic emissions of X-rays in galaxy clusters [ 7 ] , the Bullet Cluster [ 8 , 9 ] , and the peaks observed in the Cosmic Microwave Background [ 10 ] . Numerous hypotheses have been proposed regarding the exact composition of DM, ranging from Weakly Interacting Massive Particles to Axion-Like Particles and Massive Compact Halo Objects [ 3 ] . Despite extensive efforts to detect and characterize DM, its exact nature remains a subject of debate. Alongside the challenges posed by dark energy, this quest to comprehend the dark sector invites a reexamination of the \Lambda CDM model and its implications for our understanding of the universe. Importantly, all the observations challenging the Newtonian approach have gravitational nature; therefore, it could be possible to explain them by keeping the matter sector with the known particles while modifying the theory of gravity. This insight led to the formulation of Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] , suggesting that Newton’s law of gravitation would break down in regions of very low acceleration, like galaxy edges, where gravity would weaken more slowly than predicted by the inverse-square law, thus explaining the flat rotation curves of galaxies without the need of DM. Another alternative is provided by MOdified gravity theories (MOGs) [ 14 ] , which aim to extend or alter general relativity to explain cosmic acceleration and galactic dynamics without invoking dark matter or dark energy [ 15 ] . However, since the currently accepted theory of gravity, i.e., General Relativity (GR), already departs significantly from Newtonian theory, it is worthwhile to explore the potential of fully general relativistic models of galaxies. The fact that Newtonian theory, intended as the weak field, small velocities limit of General Relativity, is not able to account for the velocity curves of disk galaxies without DM is generally regarded as the failure of either Einstein’s theory or the Standard Model of elementary particles, or even both. However, unlike Newtonian gravity, the Einstein Equations (EE) are non-linear and the gravitational field itself carries energy and momentum. Moreover, solutions to the EE possess more degrees of freedom than Newtonian gravity, which is described by a single scalar potential. When applied to galaxies, these features can significantly impact the theoretical explanation of the known phenomenology. A paradigmatic consequence is the frame dragging effect displayed by the off-diagonal components of the metric, which are in general of the same order of the Newtonian potential [ 16 , 17 , 18 ] , see also [ 19 , 20 ] . This observation suggests that, although Newtonian mechanics is often used as a weak-field, low-velocity limit of general relativity, it may be inadequate for a global description of spatially extended rotating systems like galaxies: general relativistic effects become increasingly important on large scales, where the non-linearities of GR and the additional degrees of freedom it introduces can lead to observable phenomena which are not captured by the Newtonian approximation. Therefore, it makes sense to seek exact solutions of the Einstein equations for modeling extended objects and explore the conditions under which, even at small velocities and energy densities, GR provides additional information that Newtonian gravity is missing. In this context, after the pioneering work carried out in previous studies, the first viable fully general relativistic model for a disk galaxy was presented by Balasin and Grumiller (BG) [ 21 ] , eliminating some unphysical behavior of the earlier proposed solutions [ 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 ] . This model describes a disc galaxy in terms of a stationary and axially symmetric solution of the EE coupled to the energy-momentum tensor of rigidly rotating dust, along the equatorial plane and far away from the rotation center. In particular, it allows to determine a simple expression for the velocity profile possibly compatible with some observed curves. Their result suggest that general relativistic effects may contribute to the explanation of a fraction of the dark energy content. The BG velocity profile has been tested on the Milky Way from 5 up to 19\,kpc from the galactic center by fitting the data of a subsample made of 719143 stars (including 241918 OBA stars, 475520 RGB giants, and 1705 Cepheides) selected from a sample of nearly 33 million stars from the GaiaDR3 catalogue [ 16 , 17 ] . The results led to the conclusion that the BG velocity profile is statistically indistinguishable from its state-of-the-art DM analogues. At this point it is worth to mention that there is quite a confusion in the scientific literature about the extent of the analysis performed in [ 16 , 17 ] . While the authors use the BG velocity profile, they do not start from the BG model for the fitting, but from the general Lewis–Papapetrou–Weyl (LPW) structure [ 26 ] without selecting a particular analytic solution. Therefore, these analyses are not affected by the defects of the BG solution which is a very particular case of the LPW family. These general relativistic dust models cannot provide a description of an entire