Droplet impact on elastic substrates: force scaling crossover
Yuto Yokoyama, Hirokazu Maruoka, Yoshiyuki Tagawa* · 2024
Read Droplet impact on elastic substrates: force scaling crossover by Yuto Yokoyama, Hirokazu Maruoka, Yoshiyuki Tagawa* (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-12439.txt.
Introduction
Yuto Yokoyama, Hirokazu Maruoka, and Yoshiyuki Tagawa present a 2024 study of drops hitting soft surfaces. Drop impacts shape spray coating, erosion, and bioprinting. Force laws for hard floors are known, but soft floors bend with the drop, and the force rules there were murky. The team fired drops at elastic bases and filmed the stress fields in fine detail.
Peak force followed two laws, with a switch between them. Fast, heavy drops on soft bases followed the law of a hard ball on a springy floor, not the pure inertia law. One combined number captures when the switch happens, built from drop inertia, base softness, and contact time. The result rewrites how soft bases are expected to take a hit. Designers of soft, impact-safe materials gain a clear rule.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yuto Yokoyama, Hirokazu Maruoka, Yoshiyuki Tagawa* |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-12439
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Droplet impact on elastic substrates: force scaling crossover Yuto Yokoyama, Hirokazu Maruoka, Yoshiyuki Tagawa* Abstract Droplet impacts are fundamental to fluid-structure interactions, shaping processes from erosion to bioprinting. While previous scaling laws have provided insights into droplet dynamics, force scaling laws remain insufficiently understood, particularly for soft substrates where both the droplet and substrate deform significantly. Here, we show that droplet impacts on elastic substrates exhibit a scaling crossover in maximum impact force, transitioning from inertial force scaling, typical for rigid substrates under high inertia, to Hertzian impact scaling, characteristic of rigid spheres on elastic substrates. Using high-speed photoelastic tomography, we captured high-resolution dynamic stress fields and identified a similarity parameter governing the interplay between droplet inertia, substrate elasticity, and deformation time scales. Our findings redefine how substrate properties influence impact forces, demonstrating that droplets under high inertia—long thought to follow inertial force scaling—can instead follow Hertzian impact scaling on soft substrates. This framework provides practical insights for designing soft, impact-resistant materials. Keywords— Droplet Impact, Impact Force, Impact Stress, Substrate Elasticity, Scaling The behaviour of droplets impacting solid surfaces affects the quality and efficiency of many industrial processes, such as inkjet printing [ 1 ] and spray cooling [ 2 , 3 ] . The ubiquity and importance of droplet impact make it one of the most extensive areas of research in the fluid mechanics field [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] over a period of about 150 years, starting since Worthington’s pioneering work [ 7 , 8 ] . While research has frequently concentrated on the morphology of droplets at the moment of impact [ 9 , 10 ] , it has been demonstrated that scaling laws are crucial in explaining these complex phenomena. Scaling laws for droplet contact time [ 11 , 12 ] and maximum spreading diameter [ 13 , 14 ] have provided valuable insights into droplet dynamics. Despite the importance of forces and stresses generated during droplet collisions, their dynamics remain poorly understood. The impact force and stress produced by droplet impact are essential in various industrial technologies, such as aircraft erosion by raindrops [ 15 ] , cutting techniques such as water cutters [ 16 ] , and next-generation printing, such as bioprinting [ 17 ] . In particular, the maximum impact force is an essential parameter for many impact-related processes, and its quantitative prediction is required. There has been extensive research on the factors determining the maximum impact force F_{\rm max} [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] . Soto et al. [21] experimentally demonstrated that F_{\rm max} is proportional to the inertial force of the droplet in the high-Reynolds-number regime ( Re=\rho VR/\eta , where \rho , \eta , V , and R are the density, viscosity, impact velocity, and initial radius of the impacting droplet, respectively), i.e. F_{\rm max}\propto\rho V^{2}R^{2}. (1) This indicates that the dimensionless maximum impact force, \tilde{F}_{\rm max}=F_{\rm max}/(\rho V^{2}R^{2}) , is constant in the high- Re limit, which is called inertial force scaling in the review by Cheng et al. [22] . On the other hand, when the viscosity of the droplet increases, the fluid collides with the substrate with smaller spreads, but the normal force is significant, i.e. F_{\rm max} increases with decreasing droplet viscosity in the low- Re regime [ 19 ] . The variation of F_{\rm max} with respect to Re was formulated by Gordillo et al. [23] . However, the data for F_{\rm max} deviate from their predictions at Re\lesssim 1 , and they mentioned that Re is no longer a suitable dimensionless number for scaling \tilde{F}_{\rm max} in this region. Additionally, if the substrate is elastic, it can be supposed that the substrate deformation also becomes significant as viscosity increases. Therefore, it is suggested that the substrate elasticity should be considered when the droplet viscosity is significantly high. In this situation, F_{\rm max} is expected to exhibit Hertzian impact scaling , i.e. F_{\rm max}\propto\rho^{3/5}V^{6/5}R^{2}E^{2/5}, (2) as observed when a rigid sphere impacts an elastic substrate with an elastic modulus of E [ 24 , 25 ] . However, the transition process of scaling law has never been observed, and the effect of the substrate elasticity on the maximum impact force is not clarified. Investigating the stress field in the substrate, which changes in spatial distribution depending on the impacting droplet behaviour, is also crucial for understanding such a phenomenon involving fluid-structure interaction. Nonetheless, experimental measurement of the stress field in the substrate during droplet impact was not achieved until very recently due to the requirement for high spatio-temporal resolution. Sun et al. [26] were the first to successfully measure the stress field in the elastic substrate during droplet impact using digital image correlation. However, their experimental conditions were limited, and the effect of the substrate elasticity on the maximum impact force remains unclear. Their contribution has enabled quantitative investigation of the stress field, opening up new possibilities for research on such a dynamic fluid-structure interaction problem. However, to understand the impact force and stress in a wider parameter space, it is necessary to develop new stress measurement methods in addition to the above technique, as indicated in the latest review [ 22 ] . Here, we applied our novel optical stress measurement technology called “high-speed photoelastic tomography” [ 25 ] to quantify the stress field in the elastic substrate during droplet impact. We clarified for the first time that as the droplet’s viscosity increases, the scaling law of the maximum impact force F_{\rm max} shows a crossover from inertial force scaling to Hertzian impact scaling based on the stress field visualization. To explain the physics behind this crossover and how the substrate elasticity E is involved in the process, we explored the combination of similarity parameters bridging two asymptotics by the data-driven algorithm. Figure 1: Dynamic behaviours of the impactors and the substrate response. Spatio-temporal distribution of the stress field (bottom-left panels) photoelastic parameters, \Delta and \phi , and (bottom-right panels) reconstructed axial stress \sigma_{zz} when a sphere and droplet impact on an elastic substrate with V\simeq 2.8\pm 0.1 m/s. In the bottom-left panels, the colourmap indicates the retardation \Delta and white arrows indicate the orientation \phi . Figure 2: Stress and force acting on the elastic substrate. ( a ) Temporal evolution of the axial stress distribution acting on the substrate surface when Cauchy number, Ca=\rho V^{2}/E , is approximately 0.02. ( b ) Temporal evolution of the impact force with different impact velocities during a sphere or droplet impact. The shaded regions represent one standard deviation for three experiments. In the experiment, we recorded the behaviour of the impactor (a rigid sphere or silicone oil droplets with different viscosity) and the transparent elastic substrate (a polyurethane gel) by using the high-speed polarization camera. The polarization camera can access the polarization state, which is called photoelastic parameters, of the light passing through the stressed substrate. The polarization state is used for the stress reconstruction based on photoelastic tomography (see Method for details). Figure 1 shows the sequence of greyscale images of the impactor (top), the photoelastic parameters ( \Delta and \phi , bottom left), and the reconstructed axial stress ( \sigma_{zz} , bottom right). The time at which the impactor